News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by Fradow on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @03:01AM (#10190120)
The title irks me a little: you already have the right to repair, provided you have enough knowledge. What the author demands is documentation.

I would love more documentation, like anyone, but you don't really need any documentation to replace a broken capacitor (a very common failure for most screens, I guess): you need to know how to spot a broken capacitor, find a replacement, and basic soldering skills. There are tons of videos that teach that, but few people really want to research that (generally because they are afraid of electronics, or think they are not smart enough).

On the other end, some issues can't be fixed at all, because repairing is so close to the full price of the device. Some examples that happened to me: inflating smartphone battery that damages the motherboard, damaged screen due to shock (wide vertical band of dead pixels).

Between that, there are probably a lot of small problems that are specific to a particular model. It would be great that those ones are documented, indeed.

Some other basic things, like replacing a smartphone/laptop battery and screens would be very welcome on the manufacturer website, but like capacitors, you should be able to find tutorials for a lot of devices.

The truth is, to repair things, you need mostly knowledge to identify problems and labor time to fix things. Both of which is what makes it expensive.

Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by belorn on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @05:58AM (#10190579)
Limited access to parts is mostly about patents so even if you had all the knowledge in the world you are prevent by the state to create what is needed to do the repairs. After the patent is expired we often find that the social contract between inventor and state is violated, and society do not in fact gain the necessary information to replicate the invention by reading the patent. There has been some political discussion to force car manufacturers to provide equal access to parts in order to protect the free market for car repairs and maintenance.

Then we have digital locks (DRM) which the article brings up which artificially prevents customers from repairing. You can have all the knowledge in the world and still not be able to fix a simple issue since the digital signature of the part won't be accepted by the device. There has been political discussion around the world to forbid this kind of technical restrictions in cars or at least force retailers to inform the customer about the limitations.

Both issues impacts customer rights and is entirely political in nature. The problem of having enough knowledge, access to documentation, or skill to perform repairs is all secondary problems once the political right to repair is granted.

Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by Fradow on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @08:11AM (#10190917)
Thanks, I didn't really consider this part of the problem. I thought, for "gadgets" (pc, smartphones and small electronics), DRM was a limited problem (I heard about coffee machines and cat litterbox DRM, and that's it). But it may well becomes a problem, if manufacturers find that people repairing gadgets reduce their revenue, which pre-suppose a non-negligible part of potential consumers are motivated to repair instead of buying new (I am not sure it's really a lot right now).

For limited access to parts, it depends what "parts" we are talking about. If it is an electronic part (capacitor, microcontroller etc...), most gadgets use off-the-shelf components, that are easy to find, provided you know where to search. If it is a black-box with very specific requirements (screen, battery, whole PCB ..), access to parts may indeed be a problem.

While I like the political right to repair, we have to be careful about what this mean. How does it affect small companies, that may not have the time to produce documentation, or very integrated products that can't really be repaired (which, if there is an exception, becomes a loophole big companies will use, of course).

Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by Retric on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @10:35AM (#10191680)
Printers also use DRM resulting in ridiculous ink costs or people that treat printers as disposable items. Even some water filtration systems have started to use DRM.
Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by Silhouette on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @12:49PM (#10192523)
I think this is a slightly different, though related, point. Built-in artificial obsolescence, where an otherwise perfectly usable device is deliberately crippled at some point by some sort of unnecessary software or hardware barrier, is never in the customer's interests.

This one has an easy solution, though: manufacturers and vendors should be compelled to prominently disclose exactly what the nature of any such behaviour will be before the sale is finalised, so customers can vote with their wallets and there is awareness in the market if anyone wants to compete on the basis that they have no (or at least less customer-hostile) artificial limitations. Fail to do so and be on the hook for whatever the normal compensation would be for a device breaking at the time the limitation kicks in, up to and including a partial or full refund of the purchase price or even paying additional compensation for any consequential losses.

Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by emp_zealoth on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @05:17PM (#10194683)
All you need to do is require 5 years of warranty that is not crippled beyond reason. It would fix most of the problems within a year.

Anything non-consumable broke? Fix it.

It is getting unbearable: washing mashines, fridges, phones, laptops dying within few years.

Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by Silhouette on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @05:51PM (#10194880)
Five years is still an arbitrary interval though, so I'm not sure that really does fix most of the problems.

For some devices, five years might be well into the range where a significant proportion of devices would be expected to fail even without artificial breakage. For example, it might be unreasonable to expect a minimum 5 year warranty on a typical consumer hard drive being hulked around in a laptop. It's possible to build more reliable drives with better components and more robust cases with improved physical protection for those who need better resilience, but it makes the products more expensive, and the market has already provided for this with a range of different product types at different price points.

On the other hand, I have plenty of white goods in the kitchen of my home that have been working just fine for a decade and there's no reason they shouldn't be. Fixing a 5 year warranty period regardless of context might have been an open invitation to the manufacturer of my fridge to build in something that would break after 61 months (which seems a lot closer to what you seem to get with more modern kitchen white goods today).

I still think full disclosure is probably the best way to fight this trend. You can artificially cripple your device if you want, but like the warnings on cigarette packets, you have to use at least 30% of the space on your packaging prominently warning users that your product is deliberately broken and explaining exactly how so they can make an informed decision about whether they still want to buy it. I'm going to guess a lot fewer manufacturers would be so keen on nerfing their products if they also had to come clean about it to their prospective customers before they got their money.

Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by LordKano on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @11:31AM (#10192037)
The title irks me a little: you already have the right to repair, provided you have enough knowledge.

Some manufacturers are trying to use DMCA to prevent user repairs/modifications.

We had the right to repair but it's in jeopardy.

Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by mc32 on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @11:39AM (#10192086)
I don't think companies will have a chance to come down on individuals. Where some manufacturers balk is when another company sees an advantage in another company's razor blades business strategy and tries taking advantage of the initial subsidy.

Whether that's valid or not is debatable. But it's not the same as saying an individual cannot repair their gadgets (voiding warranty is expected, but understandable).

Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by LordKano on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @11:54AM (#10192178)
You are mistaken.

Recently, John Deere has been threatening shade tree mechanics with DMCA suits for performing unauthorized repairs on tractors that they own.

Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by mc32 on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @12:01PM (#10192230)
That's a nuanced condition. Here you are not talking mechanical repair but rather ecu modification --which if done by an amateur could potentially end with dangerous results.
Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by wlesieutre on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @12:13PM (#10192287)
Only because John Deere designed their tractors to require poking around the ECU to replace a hydraulic sensor. They could build that failure mode into a million places if they wanted.

What if your next car from GM said "Oh the oil light came on. You'll need to go to the dealer for an oil change so they can have the engine control unit turn the oil light off."

Suddenly an easy fix turns into something protected by the DMCA, and we're just supposed to be OK with it?

http://www.wired.com/2015/02/new-high-tech-farm-equipment-ni... for anyone who hasn't seen the John Deere story:

> The family farmer who owns this tractor is a friend of mine. He just wanted a better way to fix a minor hydraulic sensor. Every time the sensor blew, the onboard computer would shut the tractor down. It takes a technician at least two days to order the part, get out to the farm, and swap out the sensor. So for two days, Dave’s tractor lies fallow. And so do his fields.

Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by wlesieutre on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @12:25PM (#10192352)
Or on the hypothetical car example, it wouldn't even be "Take it to the dealer."

Try "Your car isn't going to start even if you changed the oil. Just have it towed to your driveway and come up with other transportation until an authorized repair tech can come and press a button for a few hundred dollars."

Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by mc32 on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @04:27PM (#10194319)
Certainly the move to frustrate easily replaceable parts by tying it in to the ecu is a dick move. However, the push should be to challenge that aspect, rather than say ecus should be free to be modified any which way.

Imagine airbus or boeing or the FAA allowing uncertified code to enter critical commercial aircraft systems.

So, I'm of two views on this. Critical systems should not be allowed to be modified by uncertified technicians, or similar, but at the dame time, they should not classify non critical components as critical. Some reasonable authority should make those calls, not the mfg or Joe/Jo public.

Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by LordKano on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @10:20PM (#10195858)
Imagine airbus or boeing or the FAA allowing uncertified code to enter critical commercial aircraft systems.

Yeah because some tractor is as much of threat as a 450 ton jumbo jet.

Even if there were no regulations preventing it. Even if there were no technological locks preventing it. No one would install unapproved software on such a contraption because the risk of getting sued out of existence would be too great.

Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by nitrogen on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @06:14PM (#10195004)
Regulations, IMO, should describe behavior, not implementation details. If my fully customized ECU still passes emissions tests, then nobody should have any say about whatever else I do or do not do with it.
Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by Loudergood on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @01:24PM (#10192725)
"which if done by an amateur could potentially end with dangerous results"

That could describe a brake job, or replacing a fuel line.

Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by LordKano on Thursday September 10, 2015 @12:35PM (#10199044)
Or changing an oil filter. Or flushing the coolant. Or replacing shock absorbers or struts. Or ...

Basically, we all recognize that it's a BS justification.

Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by LordKano on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @01:09PM (#10192638)
Make up your mind.

Are you going to continue to argue that they're not doing it or will you argue that they're only doing it when they have a good reason?

Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by Fuxy on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @07:03AM (#10190724)
To be fair most electronics these days are not made with fix-ability in mind but them again that takes extra effort on the engineers part which would make the unit more expensive and less people would buy it.

Then again if the marketed it right a lot of the tinkerers would probably go for it.

Plus the reason Samsung recommends qualified shops is because at the end of the day electronics can be dangerous if you are not careful.

Touching a charged high voltage capacitor could give you a nasty shock or even kill you so it's not for everybody.

If i had to complain about something it would be that the repair shop is charging too much for a very simple job.

Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by Silhouette on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @12:56PM (#10192565)
To be fair most electronics these days are not made with fix-ability in mind but them again that takes extra effort on the engineers part which would make the unit more expensive and less people would buy it.

Manufacturers like this sort of argument, but often don't seem to have a lot of actual evidence to support their position. If using a certain kind of custom screw is necessary to save a few mm of thickness and 0.5lb of weight in a new laptop, there's a concrete benefit to the customer. If using a certain kind of custom screw really makes no detectable difference at all to the spec, but the only global supplier of such screws has an exclusive contract with the original manufacturer to supply them so no-one else can get hold of replacement screws without a silly amount of effort, that's just artificially limiting third party repair options. At some point that sort of behaviour justifies regulatory intervention to keep the market competitive.

Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by marincounty on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @06:29AM (#10190647)
I didn't read the article, but I think I know what the author is getting at?

Right now that fancy watch on your bosses wrist looks great while the wheels are turning. Once they stop, the person will need to send the watch to an expensive trip to the factory. Why, because these companies don't sell parts to independent watch repairers. That watch is essential a lease from the company.

That automobile, with the propiority operating system, breaks down. Independent auto repair shops have no legal right to buy the repair codes--let alone fiddle with the computers. All those fancy features break. People are being forced to bring their ailing automobile to expensive Dealerships. The tech has gotten so complicated, even dealership mechanics are learning on your dime. I know this for a fact. My best buddy is a dealership mechanic.

So, it's not just computers/electronics. I'm big on repair. I don't like this throw away society. If you don't have the knowledge/skills to repair a gadget--that's fine. If you are locked out of the system, can't get the schematics, or can't get parts--that just wrong?

I'm fine with not allowing a customer to fiddle with a gadget when in warranty, but after that warranty ends, they should be able to repair their Gadget?

Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by icebraining on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @06:56AM (#10190708)
I don't think the watch example is valid; it's not an artificial restriction like hidden repair codes or patented screws, they simply don't sell the product (extra parts) you want.
Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by Dylan16807 on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @11:32AM (#10192040)
They make the parts, keep stock of the individual parts, and do sell the parts... but only if you buy it in a bundle with a hundred others.

It is an extremely artificial restriction.

Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by icebraining on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @12:35PM (#10192408)
Are furniture shops in the wrong if they refuse to sell wood, as used in their products?
Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by Dylan16807 on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @12:38PM (#10192440)
That has nothing to do with prefab parts.
Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by icebraining on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @12:39PM (#10192446)
Fine, then what about parts of furniture? A leg of a chair, for example.
Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by Dylan16807 on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @03:48PM (#10193976)
That's sort of a bad fit because of relative amount, but if legs are cheap and detachable, and they offer a $100 service that will fix a broken leg, they're being jerks if they won't just sell you a $20 leg.
Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by jdmichal on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @10:58AM (#10191817)
I told him the same thing yesterday:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10184926