Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets
by LordKano on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @10:20PM
(#10195858)
Imagine airbus or boeing or the FAA allowing uncertified code to enter critical commercial aircraft systems.
Yeah because some tractor is as much of threat as a 450 ton jumbo jet.
Even if there were no regulations preventing it. Even if there were no technological locks preventing it. No one would install unapproved software on such a contraption because the risk of getting sued out of existence would be too great.
Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets
by nitrogen on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @06:14PM
(#10195004)
Regulations, IMO, should describe behavior, not implementation details. If my fully customized ECU still passes emissions tests, then nobody should have any say about whatever else I do or do not do with it.
Imagine airbus or boeing or the FAA allowing uncertified code to enter critical commercial aircraft systems.
So, I'm of two views on this. Critical systems should not be allowed to be modified by uncertified technicians, or similar, but at the dame time, they should not classify non critical components as critical. Some reasonable authority should make those calls, not the mfg or Joe/Jo public.