News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by atirip on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @07:24AM (#10185024)
I don't know about Patent law, but it should be made illegal to mask renting as selling. That would be first step to let consumers know. Like in this Lexmark case - if you are required to return the cartridge, then this transaction is not sale. And on and on, same with electric cars where you do not own the battery.
Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by larrys on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @10:06AM (#10185720)
"if you are required to return the cartridge"

I'd love to see the exact legal language that even specifies that condition "required to return".

After all we can assume that most people don't do that or actually that those who don't return the cartridge almost certainly suffer no legal jeopardy for that inaction. If you are required to do something by a contract, then you would expect some degree of enforcement when the contract terms haven't been met. My guess is that Lexmark can't show any action they take for cartridges not returned.

I've often noted how companies that sell laser cartridges will give you a free label to UPS the cartridge back to them. They cloak it as "recycling" but it serves two purposes. It gives them a free cartridge to refill but it also takes away a cartridge that could be used by a third party that would a sale from the company.

Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by URSpider94 on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @10:29AM (#10185869)
In the US, unless you are signing a contract of some sort, then a sale is a sale. Any physical object that you simply buy at the store is yours, full stop.

I don't understand the comment that you make about not owning the batteries in an electric car. If you own the electric car, then you own the batteries, that's not in question.

However, manufacturers often put measures into place that make ownership less useful:

-- They might load software into the device that makes it respond to their control, and limits your ability to use the object

-- They might restrict availability of manuals, repair parts and other information to incentivize you to use their service facilities

However, I would argue that these are not the same as infringing on your ownership.

Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by rnovak on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @11:01AM (#10186077)
I'm not sure if you've been keeping up with US news, but this isn't true, at least until it's decided in court. GM, John Deere, and Ford all have the opposite opinion[1][2][3]

[1]http://www.againstcronycapitalism.org/2015/04/john-deere-and...

[2]https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20150421/23581430744/gm-sa...

[3]http://news.boldride.com/2015/04/gm-wants-to-make-working-on...

Not to mention I think it's currently illegal to Jailbreak an iPhone or root an Android, despite them being yours.

I really do wish the US was as cut/dry as you make it seem, and I wish they cared about consumers more, but in reality, Companies get far more rights then we, as consumers, do.

Edit:Formatting

Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by superuser2 on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @12:24PM (#10186626)
The hardware is yours. If you want to blow away the firmware and write your own, no one can (legally) stop you on copyright grounds, though it might lose its street-legal status in the interest of the people you might manslaughter by writing buggy code.

It's where you want to modify the software and post a derivative work online that copyright law kicks in. You may as well say that you do not "own" a book, because you don't have the right to share an edited version of it. Sort of true, but not very interesting.

Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by rnovak on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @12:34PM (#10186683)
Last time I checked, other than the Nexus phones, pretty much every manufacturer locks down their bootloaders, so no, you can't "blow away the firmware and write your own".
Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by TheLoneWolfling on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @12:37PM (#10186709)
> If you want to blow away the firmware...

False premise: you often cannot blow away the firmware, because it is either hard-coded, or signed.

And even when said premise is correct for a device, there are cases where the firmware inherently requires copyrighted material (For instance, requiring a (copyrighted) poem in a handshake).

Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by superuser2 on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @01:26PM (#10187034)
What the manufacturer makes it easy to do and what you can get in legal trouble for are different things.

Do you want the state to use men with guns to force everything with a microcontroller in it to also come with an SDK? I'm basically a socialist, and even I think that's ridiculous overreach.

Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by unprepare on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @01:48PM (#10187185)
Unlocking your phone in the US was actually illegal until August 1st of 2014.

You could be held for circumvention of copy protection schemes.

http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2013/01/unlocking-new-cel...

Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by rayiner on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @05:54PM (#10188420)
If you wiped the software rather than modifying it to unlock it, that probably wouldn't be illegal.
Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by TheLoneWolfling on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @02:52PM (#10187514)
> there are cases where the firmware inherently requires copyrighted material (For instance, requiring a (copyrighted) poem in a handshake).
Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by jahewson on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @01:13PM (#10186922)
> And even when said premise is correct for a device, there are cases where the firmware inherently requires copyrighted material (For instance, requiring a (copyrighted) poem in a handshake).

No way! Copyright law does not prevent someone from creating a new work that is designed to be compatible with an old work. Likely outcomes are that the poem would not qualify for copyright protection for that usage (it's not a poem as much as a sequence of arbitrary bytes to be read only by a computer), or that a fair use finding would be made, perhaps on the grounds that the copy does not affect the market for the original work - i.e. nobody was paying for the poem. Most likely a judge would just throw out the entire case at the start as a waste of the court's time.

Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by TheLoneWolfling on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @02:56PM (#10187531)
And when someone embeds an entire book (that was otherwise written and they have the rights for) into the handshake, what then?
Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by Kalium on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @01:36PM (#10187100)
Why do you think Oracle has so many lawyers?
Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by URSpider94 on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @06:42PM (#10188616)
Yes, I'm well aware of these restrictions. However, I don't think they impact whether or not you own the THING.

What GM, Ford, John Deere, Apple, etc. have said is that you can't tinker with their firmware that is installed on the device. None of them would argue that they can come repossess your tractor/car/mobile phone.

As others have pointed out, it is not currently illegal to jailbreak a phone, though that may change in the near future.

To make an analogy and play devil's advocate a little further, it would be hard to argue that I don't own my home. There is a deed to that effect recorded with the county, more than I can say for anything else I own. Yet:

* The state can take it from me in short order if I don't pay my taxes

* I have to get a permit from the city to make any substantial modifications to the property

* There is a neighborhood association that dictates property uses as well, which I have to comply with

* I couldn't just knock the house down and build a car repair garage -- city zoning ordinances restrict how I use my property.

And yet, I don't hear a big outcry that I don't truly own my house.

Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by rnovak on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @07:44PM (#10188851)
If you read that John Deere article, their specific quote is actually that you don't own the vehicle itself:

    ... an implied license for the life of the 
    vehicle to operate the vehicle
And fundamentally then, I think that I disagree with that particular view of ownership. I think my views align well with those declared by the EFF, in that I believe you should be allowed to tinker with your stuff.
Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @06:44PM (#10188625)
You forgot one. Most likely, the bank has first claim on your house.
Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by philipov on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @07:15PM (#10188754)
With a mortgage, in some sense you really don't own your own home. You have equity in the home, and the home is collateral on your debt for the home, so until you've payed everything off, the bank owns the home. Equity and Ownership are related, but not equivalent concepts.
Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by daxelrod on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @11:26AM (#10186251)
> Not to mention I think it's currently illegal to Jailbreak an iPhone or root an Android, despite them being yours.

Has the 2012 DMCA jailbreaking exemption now expired? I know exemptions expire every three years, but I wasn't sure exactly when.

Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by rnovak on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @11:35AM (#10186298)
From what I understand, the exemptions only allow jailbrakeing/rooting with permission from the Manufacturer, which I highly doubt would be given from 80-90% of manufacturers
Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by pmh on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @12:47PM (#10186764)
Your parent is referring to a DMCA exemption approved by the US Copyright Office in 2012. Jailbreaking phones is currently legal "where circumvention is accomplished for the sole purpose of enabling interoperability of [lawfully obtained software] applications with computer programs on the telephone handset"[0], while jailbreaking tablets is not.

See also this timeline of the EFF's efforts in getting DMCA exemptions: https://www.eff.org/issues/dmca-rulemaking

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IOS_jailbreaking#United_States

Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by pmh on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @12:42PM (#10186738)
It will expire in late October this year if the Librarian of Congress/US Copyright Office does not renew the exemption.
Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by chrismcb on Thursday September 10, 2015 @06:54AM (#10197265)
It is perfectly legal to jailbreak a phone... If you own it. You can't legally jailbreak it if it is on contract.
Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by dikaiosune on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @10:59AM (#10186059)
> They might load software into the device that makes it respond to their control, and limits your ability to use the object

I'd say that's a pretty direct infringement on my ownership, but then again I've got a few tin-foil hats lying around.

Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by vinbreau on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @10:51AM (#10186005)
I agree what you say should be true, but companies are trying to change the First-Sale Doctrine. Companies like John Deer say you are licensing the tech, not buying it, thus you do not own everything in the vehicle you 'bought'. Software companies have used this logic for years and it's beginning to bleed over into hardware. Companies want you to license things and do away with ownership. I'm on your side though, I believe in the First-Sale Doctrine and do not want to see it undermined, but there's a financial incentive for companies to do away with it and they will keep trying unless we make hard rulings in cases like this one against Lexmark. Look at what Nintendo tried to do with the resale market of their game discs and cartridges.
Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by giaour on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @12:09PM (#10186535)
Wait, the John Deere lawsuits were about hardware? I thought they were arguing that they only licensed (and didn't sell) the firmware controlling their newer tractors. I.e., the same bullshit companies have been pulling for decades. IIRC, the original inspiration for the Free Software Foundation was a buggy, restrictively licensed printer driver.
Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by vinbreau on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @03:38PM (#10187755)
Sorry, didn't mean to muddy the conversation. It's not the hardware they say is licensed, it's the necessary software used to run the machine. Either way, you don't own the entire product, only part of it, and the most essential part is what is licensed. Without the software the hardware is useless so it may as well be the hardware.
Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by giaour on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @03:52PM (#10187839)
In theory, someone could write GPL tractor firmware, and I don't think anyone from John Deere could legally prevent you from replacing their locked-down firmware with GnuTractor or whatever. (Then again, IANAL, so maybe they could?)

Frankly, this seems like an area where the FSF could do a lot of good and garner a lot of goodwill.

Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by vinbreau on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @05:43PM (#10188375)
If Apple can void your warranty for jailbreaking I'm sure John Deere could do the same.
Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by TrevorJ on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @06:27PM (#10188554)
>However, I would argue that these are not the same as infringing on your ownership.

You could argue that, but you'd be going against the clear meaning of ownership over the last few hundred years.

Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by throwawaykf05 on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @10:32AM (#10185887)
One could argue they are actually selling you the ink and simply renting out the cartridge. Not sure if the verbiage on the terms of sale in this case support that.
Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by kstrauser on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @01:38PM (#10187121)
> Not sure if the verbiage on the terms of sale in this case support that.

When I swing by Office Max to pick up toner, or click the Amazon button to add it to my card, there is literally no verbiage either presented to me or agreed to by me that would indicate anything other than a flat-out sale. One can't argue any such thing because no contract is sought or required for end users to buy toner.

Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products by novaleaf on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @07:04PM (#10188709)
I don't know about the battery, but when you buy a car you don't own the software/firmware, or at least that is what the mfg's want to tell us.