Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products
by giaour on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @12:09PM
(#10186535)
Wait, the John Deere lawsuits were about hardware? I thought they were arguing that they only licensed (and didn't sell) the firmware controlling their newer tractors. I.e., the same bullshit companies have been pulling for decades. IIRC, the original inspiration for the Free Software Foundation was a buggy, restrictively licensed printer driver.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products
by vinbreau on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @03:38PM
(#10187755)
Sorry, didn't mean to muddy the conversation. It's not the hardware they say is licensed, it's the necessary software used to run the machine. Either way, you don't own the entire product, only part of it, and the most essential part is what is licensed. Without the software the hardware is useless so it may as well be the hardware.
Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products
by giaour on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @03:52PM
(#10187839)
In theory, someone could write GPL tractor firmware, and I don't think anyone from John Deere could legally prevent you from replacing their locked-down firmware with GnuTractor or whatever. (Then again, IANAL, so maybe they could?)
Frankly, this seems like an area where the FSF could do a lot of good and garner a lot of goodwill.