News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by bro-stick on Saturday September 05, 2015 @02:27PM (#10175582)
FYI: http://abcnews.go.com/US/exclusive-landlord-hell-defends-ter...

It would be foolish to support this effort, considering the reckless and uncivilized nature of one of its felonious founders. Someone like this should be kept imprisioned for 20 years, but they're white like me, they get off with a slap on the wrist and back to situation normal. When they double-cross investors, sue partners or get arrested again for stalking customers, don't play shocked.

Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by pavlov on Saturday September 05, 2015 @05:10PM (#10176041)
If this were a commercial venture, I would agree. But in open source, are there fundamentally any such stakeholders that could get hurt like "investors", "partners", "customers" as you mention?

It's code with an MIT/BSD license. If you like it, use it. If not, find something else. The people behind it have very little power over you.

Ideologically open source is supposed to be above this kind of personal stigma. You can be ugly, smelly, paraplegic, Gypsy, Swedish, psychotic, a former inmate, a Nazi doctor or a toothless dog, and your patches and projects will still be evaluated the same. (I realize the real world is never quite like this.)

Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by vezzy-fnord on Saturday September 05, 2015 @05:21PM (#10176073)
People here seem to disagree, but I firmly believe being a persistent nuisance about people's personal sins in relation to a technical project is counterproductive and reeks of holier-than-thou. Macy has served his time and his name is forever tarnished with his actions, so his debt has been paid. Dismissing what is purely a technical endeavor by attacking the unfortunate backstory of one person involved, is absolute horseshit. You either criticize the software, or the actions of the developers regarding the software, or you don't do anything. It's equivalent to rejecting a cure for prion diseases because one of the researchers responsible for it committed rape once.

(That said, I think this is indeed a commercial venture. It's an undertaking by iXsystems, who provide support for BSD-based systems and are major developers for PC-BSD, FreeNAS and FreeBSD.)

Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by bro-stick on Saturday September 05, 2015 @05:37PM (#10176124)
Compartmentalizing behavior is cognitive dissonance.

It's completely fair when they're selling themselves as leaders for change. They are clearly trying to set an example, give presentations, recruit users/contributors and so on.

PS: Would you trust Hans Reiser? Answer: no.

Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by vezzy-fnord on Saturday September 05, 2015 @05:42PM (#10176136)
Compartmentalizing behavior is cognitive dissonance.

Compartmentalizing behavior is how we function in society. It's the reason why people can simultaneously hold seemingly vile religious (or other) beliefs while still being good-natured people.

Why the hell do you keep saying "Paul Reiser"? It really makes me think you have no idea what you're talking about. No, I wouldn't trust Hans Reiser as a person. But he's in prison, so I'll never work with him, anyway. I certainly might trust his views on file systems, though.

It's completely fair when they're selling themselves as leaders for change. They are trying to set an example, in all regards, give presentations and so on.

They're trying to set a technical example. They're not selling themselves as "leaders" for anything, that's just you projecting your insecure vigilantism on things.

Let it go. I won't argue with you further, anyway.

Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by runjake on Saturday September 05, 2015 @04:19PM (#10175947)
Thanks for bringing this to our attention. I didn't know about this.

Unlike a lot of other commenters, I do believe stuff like this matters in the context of NextBSD, especially if you're using this software for commercial purposes -- for a variety of reasons.

Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by bro-stick on Saturday September 05, 2015 @05:28PM (#10176091)
No worries. I'm disappointed when organizations such as FreeBSD have ostensible Codes of Conduct but do not investigate matters consistently and/or give certain contributors carte blanche: it pays lip service to the values it claimed to respect.
Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by vezzy-fnord on Saturday September 05, 2015 @05:30PM (#10176098)
The FreeBSD Code of Conduct does not exclude Kip Macy, even in light of his crimes, in any way.

Please stop with this holier-than-thou nonsense. You are not the authority to determine who has served their debt and who hasn't. In fact, you have done nothing in this entire thread but poison the well.

Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by bro-stick on Saturday September 05, 2015 @05:44PM (#10176146)
Holier-than-thou? Exclusion makes it okay? What makes you any more of an authority? Seems hypocritical, doesn't it?

Code is only one piece of a project, and can't be divorced from the users and community, because living code is an evolving conversation about human description mapping to system behavior.

Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by pdx6 on Saturday September 05, 2015 @05:48PM (#10176159)
Are you so sure it is foolish? How many open source projects do you use that you have also check up on the founders about? How many contributors do you know that have committed a crime? Do you check them all? I don't think most people have.

I'm disappointed that you aren't interested in advancing the state of the art, and are instead standing on a soap box proclaiming which projects should be damned instead. Shame on you.

Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by bro-stick on Saturday September 05, 2015 @05:58PM (#10176183)
Shame on you for making a load of assumptions and jumping to wrong conclusions.

Some crimes are worse than others, especially systematically harassing tenants (Macy) and murder (Reiser).

It's the person whom stands on a soapbox preaching "new" technologies, whom is also an excon and got off easy, whom should worry, not those whom mention evidence for untrustworthiness.

Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by girvo on Saturday September 05, 2015 @08:48PM (#10176481)
"excon" "got off easy"

Oh. Your position just became a lot clearer.

Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by vezzy-fnord on Saturday September 05, 2015 @02:38PM (#10175633)
Kip's a very long time and skilled BSD hacker. The landlord episode is completely irrelevant to this subject.
Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by felixgallo on Saturday September 05, 2015 @03:22PM (#10175773)
the guy sawed through critical beams of a building that people were living in in order to make it unsafe and induce collapse. Then, when his family put up their life savings in order to bail him out before trial, he ran away to Italy and screwed his parents out of retirement.

At a minimum, he's a criminal sociopath who would correctly flunk the background check at a minimum wage fast food restaurant. Maybe ethics and morality and character don't matter to you when you install software, but they sure do matter to me when I install init systems.

Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by bro-stick on Saturday September 05, 2015 @03:33PM (#10175796)
Exactly. Thank you. Trust is the most important part of the social contract. Burn that, and someone like that should be DK'ed until they can prove otherwise.

Others quick to defend by attacking the messenger damaging their precious worldview is cognitive dissonance at work, but they should get their facts straight and know whom they're protecting before jumping over the holes in the floor.

I agree that people should get a second chance, but only when they earn back trust, otherwise it says whatever they can get away with is okay, as long as we benefit from their other work. It's not okay.

"Fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice shame on me"

Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by vezzy-fnord on Saturday September 05, 2015 @04:15PM (#10175931)
I care about ethics in software, too, but only insofar as they extend to technical and political issues played with the software specifically. I wouldn't care if Lennart Poettering was a rapist, because that is irrelevant to the workings of systemd. I do care about his architectural vision and how he promotes it.
Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by atmosx on Saturday September 05, 2015 @05:32PM (#10176102)
So, as long as he gives you aomething you use for free, you will make no judgement. Cool. What if the victim is your relative? Will you care? What if it is you? Should we care? I mean, we might use his software, why ahould we care about you?

Do you see how this affects every member of a society. Having a member of our society traumatized for life is not acceptable.

[dead]
Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by vezzy-fnord on Saturday September 05, 2015 @06:29PM (#10176245)
You've jumped the shark.

I'm sorry.

Invoking a quote regarding the goddamned Nazis over a BSD company hiring a hacker who served time for a criminal offense, reaches such levels of absurdity that it rivals the likes of talk radio pundits such as Rush Limbaugh.

I don't know how anyone can take you seriously or even be so persistent about hammering one's past so violently in their face, but I guess that's the power of moral agendas.

Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by dang on Saturday September 05, 2015 @09:08PM (#10176524)
Please stop conducting this flamewar. HN is no place for this.
Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by bro-stick on Saturday September 05, 2015 @05:20PM (#10176069)
Code by itself isn't often very useful, the community around it is often far more valuable. It's hard to know if someone who's committed antisocial acts didn't leave landmines in code or is hard to work with when it comes to support of issues or community discussions.

Hans Reiser (reiserfs) is a murderer, and I think it's hard to justify working with someone like that.

Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by vezzy-fnord on Saturday September 05, 2015 @05:27PM (#10176090)
It's hard to know if someone who's committed antisocial acts didn't leave landmines in code or is hard to work with when it comes to support of issues or community discussions.

No, I don't see how that follows at all. It's hard to know these things in general. Your adding of the qualifier "committed antisocial acts" is poisoning the well.

Paul Reiser (reiserfs) is a murderer

Hans Reiser.

And his being a murderer has no relation to the technical quality of the file system. That said, ReiserFS is largely dead, and Hans Reiser is in prison anyway, so you can't work with him even if you wanted to.

Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by bro-stick on Saturday September 05, 2015 @05:47PM (#10176154)
Minor issue, corrected.

Yes, I'm well aware. The leader of the FLDS still runs his town from prison, so you're wrong. For all we know, Hans is still coding on pencil and paper or on a computer.

The bigger issue: Should violent felons whom happen to produce something others value be embraced with blind, warm, happy-clappy love and trust? I think not.

Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by vezzy-fnord on Saturday September 05, 2015 @06:30PM (#10176246)
embraced with blind, warm, happy-clappy love and trust

You sure do have very low standards if you think anything going on here is equivalent to "happy-clappy love and trust".

Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by mappu on Saturday September 05, 2015 @08:20PM (#10176442)
>Should violent felons whom happen to produce something others value be embraced with blind, warm, happy-clappy love and trust?

The person is not the code. Working code can be used and valued regardless of who contributed to it.

Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by feld on Saturday September 05, 2015 @05:15PM (#10176052)
don't let the door hit you on the way out
Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by bigmofo on Saturday September 05, 2015 @03:11PM (#10175742)
The page referenced, refers to Matt Macy and not Kip. If it is the same person, then I disagree. One can't tell whether he would undermine any project he is on because he does not care about other people. That landlord episode was not a crime of passion where one can chuck it up to emotions at the time. Looks like something that was thought about and planned for an extended period of time. The landlords cared very little about how they were effecting their tenants lives.
Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by bro-stick on Saturday September 05, 2015 @03:12PM (#10175750)
Nope, read the article again. Here's an excerpt:

Kip Macy, 39, and his wife, Nicole Macy, also 39, were deemed "landlords of hell" by authorities for menacing the tenants of their San Francisco apartment building.

There are plenty of links about Kip and Nicole's adventures:

http://sfgate.com/crime/article/Landlords-from-hell-deal-inc...

http://huffpost.com/us/entry/3468487

The combination of antisocial, stupidity and passive-aggressive actions results in someone whom comes off as the worst kind of liability.

I'll let you take Kip and/or Nicole in as roommates, see how long that lasts.

Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by bigmofo on Saturday September 05, 2015 @03:34PM (#10175799)
I read the article. My only question was where Matt on the nextbsd page and Kip are the same person. I guess I could have searched first. Anyway this article seems to help indicate Kip and Matt of the nextbsd article are probably the same person:

http://gawker.com/383763/freebsd-developer-kip-macy-arrested...

Definitely not somebody I would want to associated with, work with on any project or be around. Even though he has served his time and could be a changed person, one would always wonder.

Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by bro-stick on Saturday September 05, 2015 @03:39PM (#10175821)
Wikipedia could be wrong, but it currently says Kip Macy is involved.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NextBSD

And, indeed, kmacy commits show up https://github.com/NextBSD/NextBSD/commits/NextBSD-CURRENT

Of course commit names are like the email From: field without using git's commit gpg signature features, but it seems to point in that direction.

Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by lawnchair_larry on Saturday September 05, 2015 @06:14PM (#10176213)
Same person.
Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by bro-stick on Saturday September 05, 2015 @02:45PM (#10175660)
The weaker road is to circle the wagons, my friend. Because someone seems good at something excuses criminal behavior through systematic harassment, intimidation, threats and attempted endangerment the lives of others? I think not. We should forget because of the slap on the wrist in San Quentin? I doubt it. But you would let him off the hook and forget about it, it's unimportant. Riight. That sort of behavior bleeds over because it makes a person a liability, rendering them untrustworthy for anything significant. Jeremy Clarkson was handled appropriately, Macy was not. As further evidence, I know of at least five (5) startups whom passed on about a dozen seemingly technical badasses for being too arrogant... capable but unable to mesh with various ventures. In a word: hubris. If a community's leadership doesn't consistently defend boundaries of civility, it's not going to endure because teams are fragile and cofounder/early participant squabbles kill more ventures/projects than anything else. Someone like that must prove beyond measure that they have changed, especially when others think no one's watching... Or they're just playing society for fools, again.

(The five startups all found exceptionally smart and nice early employees, and four of them exited in 7-8 figure territory. One combined with amother startup and pivoted.)

Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by gherkin0 on Saturday September 05, 2015 @03:29PM (#10175788)
> because of the slap on the wrist in San Quentin

It's that kind of thinking that gets people thrown in prison for 30 years for non-violent drug crimes.

He went to prison, he didn't just get a fine and community service. I don't think that's a "slap on the wrist."

Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by bro-stick on Saturday September 05, 2015 @03:37PM (#10175813)
Then you agree with the unfairness. If a black person did this, they would get 30 years. End the War on Drugs and let many more of the mandatory minimum folks out, not just because it's costly, but because it's unjust.

But that's a distraction away from the seriousness of the crimes committed and the lack of punishment in this case. So it is indeed, comparatively, a slap on the wrist, compared to people serving much longer sentences for far, far less.

Edit: Solitary confinement is one of the worst forms of passive torture imaginable and most state prison systems deliberately abuse it on a routine basis... This should also end.

Re:Clarifying NextBSD's Near Term Expectations by plorkyeran on Saturday September 05, 2015 @05:47PM (#10176157)
I was wondering how the followup post about the evils of the mainstream media was related...