News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Website That Got Me Expelled by gwilkes on Saturday September 05, 2015 @08:41AM (#10174673)
Loved reading this, I have a very similar story. Same year, 1997, I made a Geocities site and had teacher report cards just like in this story. I put the site up on the library computers home page and then it spread around the school immediately, kids were talking about in the hallways, teachers mentioned in class that they would find who did did it.

I also critiqued the school itself, some of the hypocrisies I saw and notably since it was a Catholic school they had a school rule against pornography even when you were at home. So of course I put up a very soft core nude photo as a sort of fuck you.

However, unlike this story I actually was expelled, but it's not very difficult to get expelled from a Catholic school, it was a regular occurrence at our school. Knowing this I kept it very anonymous and didn't tell anyone.

I got an email from the school saying they would sue me for libel unless I came and turned myself in. That made me pretty nervous and pretty soon after that a student who I knew emailed me saying he loved the site and wanted to help. I then told him who I was and it turns out it was actually a teacher impersonating a student.

My brother and I were both expelled, my brother didn't do anything but contribute a few of the teacher reviews, so it sucked pretty bad for him. For me too of course but I was kicked out halfway through my senior year so I was mostly done with high school anyway. Plus I had already applied to colleges so it the expulsion didn't show up on any transcript the colleges received.

My brother wasn't so lucky since he was only a sophomore when this happened, when it came time to apply for college he got accepted to none of the colleges he applied for. He appealed hard and finally got into one.

Re:The Website That Got Me Expelled by austenallred on Saturday September 05, 2015 @09:50AM (#10174807)
Similar story here, I still remember Mapleton.tk. I loved that the whole school was talking about it.

The killer feature was actually a forum where we could talk bad about teachers using pseudonyms. A lot of them deserved it too. Nothing made me happier than seeing how much everyone hated Mr. Peterson, the teacher somehow put in charge of the students who had skipped two years of math.

Re:The Website That Got Me Expelled by azraomega on Saturday September 05, 2015 @09:40AM (#10174786)
Did you ever find out how they targeted you at the first place?
Re:The Website That Got Me Expelled by gwilkes on Saturday September 05, 2015 @09:54AM (#10174817)
Oh, I had an anonymous email account listed on the website so people could leave feedback or submit additional teacher reviews. So, they didn't know who I was but they could contact me.

I fucked up by outing myself to the teacher impersonating a student, but with a legal threat I guess it could have turned out even worse if I didn't out myself.

Huge drama at the time, my parents were pretty religious so they actually took the values of the school seriously and were so upset that they told me they wouldn't let me go to college.

That was a pretty easy fight to win though as there is no way they could have stopped me.

Re:The Website That Got Me Expelled by azraomega on Saturday September 05, 2015 @11:42AM (#10175113)
It's interesting. I don't suppose there is a way to protect your anonymity at the time. They would have got you either way. Using an email list might be a better solution... haha, use a free email for every weekly update. Never reply.
Re:The Website That Got Me Expelled by mirimir on Saturday September 05, 2015 @04:29PM (#10175965)
In the late 90s, there was no Tor, or VPN services. There were still pseudonymous remailers (penet.fi having gone down in 1996). I remember using Potato Idaho to craft Mixmaster remailer messages with reply blocks. That's how I posted to filtered cypherpunks :) But it was tedious.
[dead]
Re:The Website That Got Me Expelled by gwilkes on Saturday September 05, 2015 @10:34AM (#10174899)
It was just for fun at first and also to air some real grievances about the school itself. It was supposed to be religious but it felt like the school was more about money, there were some other specific issues that felt like they were important at the time as well.

I really didn't mean to hurt my brother or family, still feel bad about it. I don't think the teachers took it too hard as I heard that some agreed with what was said and I don't think I said anything too hurtful about any of them, just honest really.

I'm certainly writing here in a somewhat detached manner as it does still bring up feelings and I could better explain with an entire blog post like the original story here. Maybe I'll do just that.

Re:The Website That Got Me Expelled by studentrob on Saturday September 05, 2015 @12:47PM (#10175303)
subscribe
Re:The Website That Got Me Expelled by dang on Saturday September 05, 2015 @04:00PM (#10175884)
Your first sentence crosses the line into a personal attack. Those are not ok here. The comment would be just fine without that.
Re:The Website That Got Me Expelled by JackFr on Saturday September 05, 2015 @09:32PM (#10176566)
I don't understand the down votes on my sibling post. I point out some hypocrisy (some people commended for violating community norms in another community, while I am criticized for violating HN norms) in a snarky way I find amusing. So call me immature and narcissistic, but get off your high horse.
Re:The Website That Got Me Expelled by ikeboy on Sunday September 06, 2015 @12:35AM (#10176830)
Getting expelled from school is considered worse than being banned from HN, and therefore requires more justification.
Re:The Website That Got Me Expelled by dang on Sunday September 06, 2015 @03:46AM (#10177043)
Users here are averse to snark because it's closely related to being mean, unsubstantive, or both. Usually both.
Re:The Website That Got Me Expelled by mcherm on Saturday September 05, 2015 @12:57PM (#10175339)
I agree. That is exactly why radical organizers like Martin Luther King or Evan Wolfson or Ed Snowden should learn to sit down and shut up. It is narcissistic, selfish, and immature of them to insist on speaking about issues society would prefer they stayed silent on. And the cost to their supporters and friends and those around them is quite significant.
Re:The Website That Got Me Expelled by msie on Saturday September 05, 2015 @02:01PM (#10175503)
Please, do not put this guy in the same boat as MLK or Ed Snowden.
Re:The Website That Got Me Expelled by mcherm on Friday September 11, 2015 @01:57PM (#10205160)
Defending free speech doesn't always mean defending MLK or Snowden. Sometimes it means defending creeps. Actually, usually it means defending creeps.
Re:The Website That Got Me Expelled by mcfunley on Saturday September 05, 2015 @02:49PM (#10175671)
Same here, I also did basically the same thing in 1997. I wasn't expelled but I was banned from my senior prom and served a lengthy in-school suspension stint.

The administration threatened to write to the colleges I'd already been accepted to and try to get those offers withdrawn, but as far as I know that was just a threat.