As someone that leans left, this is one of the big arguments I make in favor of UBI.
Frankly, I'm tired of arguing over the minutia of welfare, unemployment benefits, the minimum wage, social security, etc.
Fine. Scrap most of our social assistance programs outside of healthcare and replace them with a UBI.
The progressive in me likes it because it gives everyone a minimum safety net and the capitalist in me likes it because it opens up entrepreneurism and the ability to pursue potentially innovative businesses -- especially in an economy increasingly geared toward service and information work -- to huge portions of the population that are otherwise locked out. Active, small businesses are good for everyone.
People will either do the job or you have to pay a reasonable amount for it - one key principle of the UBI - more people get a choice how they use / sell their time and are not prey like today in many regions / countries to the few who dictate how much they will receive for their time.
£1,500 ~= $2,274
$2,274/person/mo * 12 mo/yr * 300,000,000 people = $8,186,400,000,000/yr. $8 trillion a year to provide that level of UBI to all 300,000,000ish Americans.
Not an inconsequential amount of money!
When assessing the amount being redistributed, much of what's paid in UBI should be netted against what's collected to pay the UBI.
That is, if I am receiving $27k/yr in UBI, but paying $30k/yr in increased taxes toward the UBI, really only $3k/yr is being "redistributed" from me.
This is still going to be a substantial sum, but quite a bit less than "people * UBI amount".
Please don't take this as my asserting that I think $27k/yr would be sustainable in the US - for the record, I don't.
How will willingly pay $5 trillion of taxes after all the hard work only to watch everybody else living of their work for free?
The person receiving $y is actually getting it from the very taxes they pay. So essentially what you are giving them is a tax discount. Except in cases where a person makes $0, for which you have social security anyway.
So this is basically a tax discount? You could simply say based on their income some a% of tax discount will be offered every year.
It's one of the reasons I mentioned scrapping the minimum wage when implementing UBI.
The job market becomes much more of a market where work is paid for what it's worth because it's an actual market and employers don't have the undue leverage of simple survival over employees.
(Not that there isn't a good case for eliminating federal waste; but the reality I never hear uttered in the conservative bubble is that the largest government expense is federal employees and subcontractors.)
(Not that there isn't a good case for improving federal social programs; but the reality I never hear uttered in the progressive bubble is that the largest government expenses are social programs like social security, medicare, and medicaid.)
[1] http://eml.berkeley.edu/~dromer/papers/RomerandRomerAERJune2...
[2] http://www.newyorkfed.org/research/staff_reports/sr646.pdf
[3] http://time.com/9009/unemployment-is-worse-than-death/ (the point is made more thoroughly in the author's book)
You phase it in by starting it at a low level without replacing/reducing existing programs, and then as you ramp it up you start eliminating other programs.
Allowing people to make those important transitions without completely losing financial stability will help everyone.
In many countries the government negotiates medicine prices as one entity for the entire country. This gives it a lot of leverage and the ability to provide medicine for all its citizens at a price far lower than what they would each individually be able to buy it at.
Now if everybody had basic income the governments might start getting pressured to stop acting as an intermediate negotiator.
Government programs have huge constituencies and embedded supporters within and without government who will fight tooth and nail to keep them. There is no way you will actually cut down on them as suggested.
While they're figuring out what to do next with their lives, they won't be left in the lurch, they'll get that sweet, sweet (well, minimal) UBI check just like everyone else.
http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2015/01/the-failure-of-a-past...
"The idea of a basic income guarantee is very popular with readers, more so that the notion of a job guarantee. Yet as we have mentioned in passing, this very sort of program was put in place on a large-scale basis in the past. Initially, it was very popular. However, in the long run it proved to be destructive to the recipients while tremendously beneficial to employers, who used the income support to further lower wages, thus increasing costs to the state and further reducing incentives to work. And when the system was dismantled, it was arguably the working poor, as opposed to the ones who had quit working altogether, who were hurt the most."
I've yet to hear a good explanation for why basic income is superior to a job guarantee. We do not live a techno-futurist utopia where robots do all of our work. We do not want to be welfare queens; work gives us dignity. We do not even have world class infrastructure, we have infrastructure that is falling to pieces and direly needs work.
The last time we were in this situation, FDR created jobs. Jobs that built stuff like schools, hospitals... the lincoln tunnel.
You want a way in which the Universal Basic Income would be superior to a Job Guarantee? Administration. With a job guarantee, you will need a massive administration. While I agree wholeheartedly that meaningful work supports dignity. Creating jobs and Universal Basic Income are not opposed to each other.
They built a ton of stuff we still use today.
That prospect differs from a "job guarantee" precisely where that stuff is not sufficiently useful. In the margin there, I object to paying people to take time and effort away from places they may find more value, to do things that are of minimal value, in the name of "dignity." In fact, I think paying for useless work is destructive of precisely that dignity (along with a pile of economic value).
So you are saying, in essence, that people's art projects, poetry and one person startups and time spent watching daytime TV are, on average, more useful than projects like the lincoln tunnel, schools, hospitals and bridges and you object to resources being taken from one to build the other?
Bourgeois moralist crap. If working gives you dignity, by all means, work. But being forced to work to survive is not dignity, and the result is the bullshit jobs we see everywhere. If people who have free time feel the need for better infrastructure, they'll build it.
"Ne travaillez jamais!"
[1] http://www.jil.go.jp/english/JLR/documents/2012/JLR34_ohtake...
[2] http://wol.iza.org/articles/unemployment-and-happiness.pdf
[3] http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jmcb.12154/abstra...
In my second sentence, I implicitly agreed that some people might feel more dignified by working. The bourgeois moralism comes from using that to justify forcing everyone to work, as if dignity had to be imposed on people, those brutish sinful beings who have to be saved by those who know better.
And by the way, this moralist view is probably one of the great culprits for the effect shown in your links - like those people in the Philippines flogging themselves until their flesh is raw and bloody, we can do terrible things to ourselves when we've been convinced that we're lesser human beings.
A) Nobody much really wants voluntary unemployment. Not for extended periods, anyway.
B) Involuntary unemployment still exists with UBI meaning you still get most of that unhappiness.
C) It's not like we're short on useful work even if we are flooded with bullshit jobs and unemployment. We just have a really wasteful allocation of labor.
>The bourgeois moralism comes from using that to justify forcing everyone to work, as if dignity had to be imposed on people
A job guarantee isn't forcing anybody to do anything and it isn't imposed on anybody. It's an offer of a job to anybody who wants one.
>And by the way, this moralist view is probably one of the great culprits for the effect shown in your links - like those people in the Philippines flogging themselves until their flesh is raw and bloody, we can do terrible things to ourselves when we've been convinced that we're lesser human beings.
Economic policies that enforce idleness are only going to contribute to that.
Funny thing to say on a site where so many people chose a more challenging life exactly because they didn't want to be employees.
Few people want to be idle. That doesn't in any way imply they all want to be employed. There are many ways in which people enjoy living besides being employed - volunteering, studying, researching, exploring, creating art, developing a non-commercially-viable craft or skill, traveling, founding startups and other organizations, the list is endless.
B) Involuntary unemployment still exists with UBI meaning you still get most of that unhappiness.
When you don't need to pay anything to offer a job, there's absolutely no reason for most businesses not to accept anyone. Only unpleasant jobs that few people want to do will still have to be well remunerated - as it should be.
It's not like we're short on useful work even if we are flooded with bullshit jobs and unemployment. We just have a really wasteful allocation of labor.
Which is a great practical point in my favor. The State is one of the greatest sources of bullshit jobs; there's no reason to assume the new guaranteed jobs would be better allocated.
A job guarantee isn't forcing anybody to do anything and it isn't imposed on anybody. It's an offer of a job to anybody who wants one.
If people can't survived without a job, they are forced to get one. If society can easily avoid that but chooses not to for BS moralist reasons, the people advocating for that are forcing others to have jobs.
Economic policies that enforce idleness are only going to contribute to that.
The idea that there is only a choice between idleness and employment is one of the BS parts of the moralism I was referring to.
Because if they didn't, nobody would do that work.
This or, since budgets remain same. You will employ lesser people to do same job. Because that is the all budget you have to pay people.
Nope. Shareholders. Minimum wage hikes eat into profits before affecting prices or employment. This is why businesses hate them with such a seething passion.
To look at a more concrete example, compare the minimum wage in Australia vs. the US and the cost of big mac in both countries.
Involuntary unemployment is more efficient is it?
Let's say your wage is 30K per year. On Jan 1 a UBI of 12K per year is to be instated. What would happen to your wage in a year? Personally, given that most all businesses want us to be loyal to them with no loyalty returned to us, my guess would be that you are let go and someone would be hired to do your job for 20K per year.
The difference between a UBI and an income guarantee like the Speenhamland system is that the latter is a means-tested program that eliminates the marginal benefit of additional work and requires more administration, while the former, because it is unconditional, providing a fixed benefit regardless of outside income, has less administration and preserves the marginal benefit of additional work.
> Let's say your wage is 30K per year. On Jan 1 a UBI of 12K per year is to be instated. What would happen to your wage in a year? Personally, given that most all businesses want us to be loyal to them with no loyalty returned to us, my guess would be that you are let go and someone would be hired to do your job for 20K per year.
If they could get someone to provide the value you do for $20K now, they would. If you think UBI makes that more possible, you have to believe that it also makes it just as much more possible that you'd be able to get someone else's former 30K job for 20K of job income, which, with a 12K UBI, gives you a 6.67% increase in total income.
With BI, for each extra dollar your employer pays you, you get an extra dollar.
With income guarantee, for each extra dollar your employer pays you, you get nothing.
A similar observation is the "horseshoe theory": "The horseshoe theory in political science asserts that rather than the far left and the far right being at opposite and opposing ends of a linear political continuum, they in fact closely resemble one another, much like the ends of a horseshoe."[1]
See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_spectrum#Other_multi...
In the 1930s the global far left and far right agreed on authoritarianism. While I personally think UBI is a great idea, I think that invoking a principal of that the points on which the far right and far left half similar views are likely to be correct to promote it is probably a substantially less great idea.
They are all concerned that this will ultimately end up as just another dole and the mother of all doles. They ask questions I don't have good answers to like:
1. This includes healthcare?
2. This includes disability?
When I say...well, I don't know about healthcare, its curtains.
Where the appeal comes for the right is that a UBI would let you eliminate our patchwork of other social assistance programs and all the headache, cost, and inefficiency of their associated bureaucracy.
The basic pitch isn't actually all that different from the flat tax ideas that are popular in conservative circles with the distinction that a UBI would disproportionately affect the wealthy rather than the poor.
Everyone pays, directly or indirectly, sales and property taxes. Every employed person ,that isn't paid under the table, pays payroll (ok, a few legal exceptions to this) and income taxes (if they make enough money). Those who don't make enough money to pay income tax are still involved with the IRS because they need to file for refunds or other programs they may qualify for.
Social Security, because eligibility is contribution based, effects people (from a tracking perspective) from the time they start working in a Social Security covered job (pretty much all legal jobs other than the subset of non-federal public sector jobs that don't participate in social security.)
The SSA is currently handling some 64 million beneficiaries.
I'm not contending that it'd be easy, but it's a scaling problem at this point. Systems exist to handle it already.
It was one of the reasons advocate by Milton Friedman.
Milton Friedman is now "far right"?
Assume we give each of the 80 Mio germans 10000 Euro per year. That's an expense of 800 Billion per year. Contrast this with a total tax income of ca 600 Billion per year [1]. It's not gonna fly...
[1] https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steueraufkommen_(Deutschland)
To be clear I'm not saying that it's viable, I'm just saying that your calculation is not the one proponents of the idea are using.
Lefties hate the NSA spying and love a universal basic income because the spying tilts the power away from the people, and the income tilts toward the people.
Righties (well, go far right enough) hate the NSA spying and love a universal income because of government overreach in the first case, and the ability to drastically simplify government welfare--cutting out a ton of means-tested programs and their agencies, and replacing it all with a check each month.
Gotta love it!