Every story and comment from the Hacker News API, in a layout borrowed from 2001.
A comment on Citi's Chief Economist Recommends a Universal Basic Income. Parent comment
When assessing the amount being redistributed, much of what's paid in UBI should be netted against what's collected to pay the UBI.
That is, if I am receiving $27k/yr in UBI, but paying $30k/yr in increased taxes toward the UBI, really only $3k/yr is being "redistributed" from me.
This is still going to be a substantial sum, but quite a bit less than "people * UBI amount".
Please don't take this as my asserting that I think $27k/yr would be sustainable in the US - for the record, I don't.
There are no comments on this comment yet.
When assessing the amount being redistributed, much of what's paid in UBI should be netted against what's collected to pay the UBI.
That is, if I am receiving $27k/yr in UBI, but paying $30k/yr in increased taxes toward the UBI, really only $3k/yr is being "redistributed" from me.
This is still going to be a substantial sum, but quite a bit less than "people * UBI amount".
Please don't take this as my asserting that I think $27k/yr would be sustainable in the US - for the record, I don't.