News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by leshow on Monday August 31, 2015 @01:08AM (#10145540)
There is no starvation mode that makes the body disobey the laws of conservation of energy. Sorry. Your wife is either not in a deficit due to the calories not being low enough (or not exercising enough) or she's simply eating more and not recording it.
Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by grecy on Monday August 31, 2015 @02:51AM (#10145782)
See my comment below. It's widely accepted there is indeed a starvation mode that we (and all mammals) evolved to deal with uncertain food supply.

When faced with severely less calories than it needs, your body can, for example:

^ Run at a colder temperature (ever notice you get cold really easily when you've been hungry for a long time?)

^ Not do such a good job replacing hair and skin cells (notice how hungry people have funny looking skin and "crappy" hair?)

Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by leshow on Monday August 31, 2015 @02:56PM (#10148415)
Sorry but the amount of calories the body is capable of conserving by lowering temperature and cell proliferation is not as significant as you think.

Also the fact that there are processes to conserve energy says nothing about the level of caloric restriction necessary to achieve these conservation measures.

It's far from widely accepted.

If the body was able to go into 'starvation mode' and run more and more efficiently, famine wouldn't be such an issue. The fact that you think a western woman with a large caloric deficit is enough to engage some kind of magical 'starvation mode' laughable.

Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by mistermann on Monday August 31, 2015 @03:42PM (#10148652)
Why is it laughable? I don't at all see the logic here.
Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by leshow on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @10:06PM (#10157046)
It's not a widely held theory in the scientific community.

It's more likely she's underreporting her food intake.

"If the body was able to go into 'starvation mode' and run more and more efficiently, famine wouldn't be such an issue."

Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by mistermann on Monday August 31, 2015 @01:52AM (#10145625)
Do you believe it is literally as simple as calories in calories out, for all people equally?
Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by grecy on Monday August 31, 2015 @02:47AM (#10145773)
The analogy is to a gas tank in a car.

If you put in 5 gallons per day, but only use 4 gallons per day, there is an extra gallon building up each day, and it will be stored somewhere (fat in the body). Some bodies will be more inclined to store this than others, and store it in different places.

If you put in 3 gallons per day, and burn 4 gallons per day, there is a deficit, and the extra will be burned from stored reserves (stored fat). It must, otherwise the machine would be incapable of traveling the distance that 4 gallons requires, and would not function. When that runs out, you die (i.e. starving to death).

Yes, it factually has to be that simple, for all creatures, there is no possible other way. It is extremely simple science and logic.

Notice I said simple, NOT easy. They are two different things.

Also note that for all people the speed at which your body adjusts to eating less than you burn will be different, as will exactly how your body responds to your eating less than you burn. For example, if you seriously under eat calories, it's widely accepted your body will think it's starving to death, and will conserve energy it normally would not - i.e, you'll be cold, your immune system will be weaker, your digestion will not be optimal, your hair and skin will deteriorate and not be replenished well etc. etc. So even though you're eating less than you were burning last week/month, you might not lose (much/any) weight because your body has quickly adapted and changed the amount of calories required as best as it can by shutting down, or minimizing non-critical functions. You could imagine an intelligent car doing the same thing when it realizes it isn't being fed enough energy for the demands being put on it - it might turn off the air conditioning, lower itself, jack up the tire pressures, fold in rear view mirrors and limit itself to a top speed of 30mpg all in the name of more efficiency.

Source: I got involved with Weight Watchers years back - have personally been involved with literally thousands of people losing tens of thousands of pounds combined. WW is by very definition eat less energy than you burn. (well, the new formula gives a little bonus if you eat lots of fiber and another if you eat very little fat, but it hardly makes a difference)

Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by mistermann on Monday August 31, 2015 @09:33AM (#10146701)
Me: Do you believe it is literally as simple as calories in calories out, for all people equally?

You: Yes, it factually has to be that simple, for all creatures, there is no possible other way. It is extremely simple science and logic.

And then you proceed to point out several items (that I agree with) showing that calories in / calories out doesn't fully describe the complexity.

In your "If you put in 3 gallons per day, and burn 4 gallons per day" analogy, the devil is encapsulated within "burn", in that the fuel efficiency of the car can vary - therefore while the energy going in is a constant, the energy being burned will vary. And additionally when dealing with humans, ability to absorb energy from fuel in also varies (many calories come out as waste, how many varies by individual.)

Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by grecy on Monday August 31, 2015 @11:24AM (#10147219)
> then you proceed to point out several items (that I agree with) showing that calories in / calories out doesn't fully describe the complexity.

That's because for 99.999% of people to lose weight, they don't need to understand / deal with anything more complex than calories in / calories out.

When your grandma wants to use a computer, she doesn't need to understand interrupts and CPU instruction sets anymore than a 3 year old needs to understand HTTP and TCP/IP to surf the web.

It really is this simple. Figure out how many calories you should be eating daily to maintain based on your height, weight, age, sex and activity level. (And let's be perfectly honest here, for anyone that's obese or higher, it's an ungodly amount of calories per day - so many that it would be very difficult for anyone to eat that many calories per day without eating massive amounts of fat (fried food) and sugar (soda). So cut out just soda for most people and that's enough)

Eat 200-300 less than that per day, for 3 months, and do a tiny bit more exercise than you normally do - and by tiny bit for someone that does nothing, that means walk an extra hundred yards to your car daily, nothing more. No running on the treadmill, no caring about carbs vs. fat vs. protein. Hell, if you stay 200-300 under what you require, it doesn't even matter if you still eat fast food like you used to.

After 3 months if you have not lost weight, cut down another 200-300 per day, and continue for another 3 months.

Repeat.

You will lose weight, it can not be any other way, and the "complexities" mentioned above need not be considered, because they over complicate the issue.

Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by mistermann on Monday August 31, 2015 @04:01PM (#10148753)
I have trouble reconciling this with my personal experiences - I did keto for several months and lost about 25 pound until I hit a plateau that I couldn't get past after trying for over two weeks, eating the same diet as before, and I know with certainty I was WELL below my maintenance caloric intake.

> You will lose weight, it can not be any other way

I wonder if maybe the logical impossibility people are having trouble with is maybe from not differentiating between calories consumed and calories absorbed?

Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by grecy on Monday August 31, 2015 @06:44PM (#10149576)
> I hit a plateau that I couldn't get past after trying for over two weeks

2 weeks? 2 weeks?

We're talking about changing your eating and exercise habbits for the rest of your life. Two weeks is such a tiny drop in the bucket it's hard to even measure it, and likely too many things were in flux to have settled down.

Continue for 3 months. You will lose weight.

> I wonder if maybe the logical impossibility people are having trouble with is maybe from not differentiating between calories consumed and calories absorbed?

It makes no difference, because you can't absorb more than you ate. Don't think about how much your body is absorbing, because it's too hard to measure and do anything about. Think and focus on the thing you can impact - how much you eat.

You are worrying about what kind of efficiency your car is getting, when all you need to care about is to stop putting so much damn gas in every day because the tank keeps overflowing.

When the tank is overflowing each and every day, put in less gas!!!!

Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by mistermann on Monday August 31, 2015 @08:40PM (#10150037)
> We're talking about changing your eating and exercise habbits for the rest of your life. Two weeks is such a tiny drop in the bucket it's hard to even measure it, and likely too many things were in flux to have settled down.

I had already hit my target so didn't mind quitting. The interesting part of the conversation to me is the plateau itself - according to many people, all people and especially individuals are the same, calories in minus exercise equals weight gained (or lost), there is no such thing as flux, every day is exactly the same, literally the only variable is your weight, and that hardly changes at all day to day. Yet, myself and millions of other people do in fact hit a plateau with no noteworthy change in diet or exercise. I'm just having a bit of fun seeing the variety of ways people twist logic and dance around questions related to this phenomenon while still maintaining this hardline calories in calories out stance. :)

> It makes no difference, because you can't absorb more than you ate.

Correct. However, you can absorb less than you eat! Eat 2000 calories, absorb 1500, poop out the rest, gee, I wonder if that might have any effect on weight loss?

Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by grecy on Monday August 31, 2015 @09:22PM (#10150173)
> The interesting part of the conversation to me is the plateau itself - according to many people, all people and especially individuals are the same, calories in minus exercise equals weight gained (or lost), there is no such thing as flux, every day is exactly the same, literally the only variable is your weight, and that hardly changes at all day to day.

I've never seen anyone claim that calories in / calories out will have an immediate impact and should be visible on the scales within days. On any given day your body might hold onto lots of water, so you don't lose weight. Later you might get really dehydrated on a hot day, so you appear to have lost weight, etc. etc. Times one million variations for why you won't see "results" "instantly".

Don't for one second think that any of this is measured on the scale of days, or weeks. You are completely deluding yourself if you think it is.

A scale of months hardly makes sense either. Do everything for a minimum of 3 months before you expect to see a difference, on the scales or in the mirror. Everything takes time, and you're in this for the rest of your life, so what's the difference anyway.

> Correct. However, you can absorb less than you eat! Eat 2000 calories, absorb 1500, poop out the rest, gee, I wonder if that might have any effect on weight loss?

It won't, because that's how your body has been functioning for a long time.

If you're trying to lose weight, you just have to feed it less, who cares how much it's extracting, it's completely irrelevant.

Like I said, it doesn't matter if you're in a car that gets 30mpg or one that gets 50mpg, as long as you put less gas in the tank than you are using, sooner or later the tank will run out!

Stop trying to make this harder than it needs to be, or more complicated that it needs to be.

Consume less calories than you burn, and in the long run you will lose weight.

Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by mistermann on Monday August 31, 2015 @09:58PM (#10150282)
> Like I said, it doesn't matter if you're in a car that gets 30mpg or one that gets 50mpg

But what if the car adjusts its fuel efficiency dynamically? If that's the case, it might be something worth investigating and understanding, no?

> Stop trying to make this harder than it needs to be, or more complicated that it needs to be. Consume less calories than you burn, and in the long run you will lose weight.

Correct, but if certain levels of caloric deficit can cause physiological changes that affect rate of weight loss, altering the difficulty of losing weight, why be opposed to discussing that idea? Why not maximize efficiency of weight loss?

Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by grecy on Monday August 31, 2015 @11:46PM (#10150613)
> But what if the car adjusts its fuel efficiency dynamically?

And your body does just that. That's why you continually re-evaluate what your calorie needs are and adjust your intake accordingly. Weight Watchers does this every single week. See how much you weigh, figure out what your "maintenance" calories are, and make sure you eat 200-300 less than that.

Then, yes, your body changes, adapts and becomes more efficient, because you're changing things, and it's getting lighter so be definition it needs less calories. So then check-in again a week later repeat. And repeat. And repeat.

> If certain levels of caloric deficit can cause physiological changes that affect rate of weight loss

I wouldn't go there. I mean, if you want to change the rate of weight loss, just eat absolutely zero calories for 6 months. I grantee you'll lose a massive amount of weight. Is that a good idea? absolutely not. There is an amount that's sensible and works well. It's something like 200-300 less calories than your maintenance requires.

> * Why not maximize efficiency of weight loss*

It's interesting to me you're still viewing this as "weight loss", and something to be maximized and made more efficient, and something with an end date. What hasn't dawned on you yet (and usually takes most weight watchers people a very long time to get) is that, at some point in the future, you will weigh your goal weight. When you get there, your calorie requirements to maintain that are going to be massively lower than they are now. Actually, they're going to be right around what you were eating the week before you got to your goal weight. Guess what? That's now what you're going to eat for the rest of your life.

You can't really maximize the efficiency of the rest of your life. So just start working towards it, today.

Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by mistermann on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @12:35AM (#10150751)
> Then, yes, your body changes, adapts and becomes more efficient, because you're changing things, and it's getting lighter so be definition it needs less calories.

This doesn't require any "adjustment" on the body's part, it is a natural outcome of having less mass to maintain. I am speaking of something different, of the possibility of the body sensing starvation and shifting into kind of a high efficiency sustainment mode, perhaps lower metabolism, perhaps more efficient extraction of calories from food. Does this actually happen, I don't know, but I believe from personal experience and reading forums that there is a phenomenon of hitting a weight plateau that is not explained by the simplistic calories in, calories out theory. I don't know why this idea seems so offensive to people.

> I wouldn't go there. I mean, if you want to change the rate of weight loss, just eat absolutely zero calories for 6 months. I grantee you'll lose a massive amount of weight.

Why do conversations on certain topics have to degrade to nonsense if someone doesn't agree with your point of view?

> It's interesting to me you're still viewing this as "weight loss", and something to be maximized and made more efficient

Some people, me for example, can diet for a period, drop <x> pounds, and then I'm good for years with paying very little attention to diet - not everyone has it that easy though. But while I am dieting, I prefer to optimize it so it's over as quickly as possible.

The idea of optimizing things is a fairly common theme on this site, but again, there seems to be something about the topic of dieting that changes the way people think.

Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by leshow on Wednesday September 02, 2015 @03:16PM (#10161362)
> Does this actually happen, I don't know, but I believe from personal experience and reading forums that there is a phenomenon of hitting a weight plateau that is not explained by the simplistic calories in, calories out theory.

It doesn't. People are bad at self-reporting their intake. Reading forums isn't a good source of information.

Even if there was some kind of ultra-efficiency mode, it's worth noting that it doesn't mean calories in/calories out is wrong. It doesn't disprove the law of conservation of energy, I don't see why you think these two concept are opposed to one another.

The reality is that there is no special starvation mode or metabolic damage that makes people ultra-efficient food processing machines. The research doesn't support it and a bunch of forum posts of people self-reporting their intake (badly) or outright falsifying information (but everything on the internet is true!) isn't backing up your case.

Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by grecy on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @10:48AM (#10152685)
> This doesn't require any "adjustment" on the body's part, it is a natural outcome of having less mass to maintain. I am speaking of something different, of the possibility of the body sensing starvation and shifting into kind of a high efficiency sustainment mode, perhaps lower metabolism, perhaps more efficient extraction of calories from food. Does this actually happen, I don't know, but I believe from personal experience and reading forums that there is a phenomenon of hitting a weight plateau that is not explained by the simplistic calories in, calories out theory.

I personally think that what you're describing can happen under certain circumstances, most common when you suddenly under eat calories by a wide margin.. i.e. you've been eating 3000/day for years, then suddenly start eating 1500/day.

So it's important to only go a little below your maintenance requirements.

If you still hit a plateau, just drop a little more, and repeat. You will push through the plateau, eventually.

>Why do conversations on certain topics have to degrade to nonsense if someone doesn't agree with your point of view?

Sorry, that's the Engineer coming out in me - when I'm thinking something through I always immediately think of the minimum and maximum case to better understand what's going on. I didn't mean to offend.

>Some people, me for example, can diet for a period, drop <x> pounds, and then I'm good for years with paying very little attention to diet - not everyone has it that easy though. But while I am dieting, I prefer to optimize it so it's over as quickly as possible.

You're a very lucky person.

>The idea of optimizing things is a fairly common theme on this site, but again, there seems to be something about the topic of dieting that changes the way people think.

I'm all for optimizing, and I personally think the calories in / calories out method is optimizing weight loss. I've never heard/seen a better and simpler way. It's the fundamental starting point of all diets - i.e. eat less energy than you burn.

Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by leshow on Monday August 31, 2015 @03:27PM (#10148564)
thank you. said it better than I would've
Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by leshow on Monday August 31, 2015 @03:03PM (#10148446)
For weight loss/gain? If you're in a caloric deficit you will lose weight, if you're in a surplus you will gain weight. I'm not sure how much simpler I can state it.
Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by mistermann on Monday August 31, 2015 @03:44PM (#10148658)
Ah, so you've changed terms rather than answer the question, ok. People seems strangely emotionally attached to sides in this topic.
Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by leshow on Monday August 31, 2015 @03:49PM (#10148688)
I haven't changed any terms, you added "for all people equally?" and I'm not sure what you mean by that. It's obvious the caloric requirements vary by individual and thus are not equal between people. But there is no magic starvation mode where you stop losing weight even if you are in a deficit.

I'm emotionally attached to people not using their critical thinking skills and thinking rationally, not about food.

Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by mistermann on Monday August 31, 2015 @04:14PM (#10148812)
The change of terms was "calories in / calories out" --> "caloric deficit", which ignores the stomach's efficiency in absorbing calories from ingested food (calories in), as well as individual metabolism (burn rate at rest, efficiency of caloric usage). Some people can absorb calories from food more efficiently than others, one theory with some scientific support is it is due to different enzymes in the digestive system.
Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by grecy on Monday August 31, 2015 @06:35PM (#10149539)
> which ignores the stomach's efficiency in absorbing calories from ingested food (calories in), as well as individual metabolism (burn rate at rest, efficiency of caloric usage). Some people can absorb calories from food more efficiently than others, one theory with some scientific support is it is due to different enzymes in the digestive system.

But that changes nothing.

If you're a person that is bad at absorbing calories from food, then reducing the amount of calories you eat below what you burn will make you lose weight.

If you're a person that is very efficient at absorbing calories from food, then reducing the amount of calories you eat below what you burn will make you lose weight.

There is no difference. We're talking about a car that gets 30mpg and one that gets 50mpg. It makes no difference to each car, the only thing that matters is if you put in more or less gas than you use per day.

Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by leshow on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @10:11PM (#10157059)
the error would be system and consistent and thus irrelevant. it would just appear that you had a faster than normal metabolism.

this has nothing to do with the fact that a caloric deficit will cause weight loss. you're moving the goalpost and talking about something completely different.

[dead]
Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by dang on Monday August 31, 2015 @09:28PM (#10150200)
We've banned this account for repeatedly and badly violating the HN guidelines.
Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by mistermann on Monday August 31, 2015 @06:33PM (#10149526)
Please be civil.
[dead]
Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by mistermann on Monday August 31, 2015 @08:41PM (#10150042)
What facts am I denying?
Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by Evgeny on Monday August 31, 2015 @04:10AM (#10145934)
If a person eats less energy than his body requires to function on a daily basis, where would the extra fat mass come from?
Re:Diet Advice That Ignores Hunger by grecy on Monday August 31, 2015 @03:47PM (#10148675)
The body will burn it's stored fat to make up the energy deficit. The reason it stored fat in the first place is so that it will have energy to function when food supplies are not good.

Where exactly the body chooses to take fat from first, I don't know or care. Like digging a hole, it doesn't matter where exactly you take dirt from.

When there is no (or very little) stored fat, the body will start eating up it's own muscles to survive, but that's bad.