News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:State of the Common Lisp Ecosystem by melling on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @08:22PM (#10120302)
The standard copy and paste work for me. Just use the arrow keys and page up/down keys to navigate. Skip the complicated stuff and pretend you're using Notepad.
Re:State of the Common Lisp Ecosystem by WalterGR on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @08:37PM (#10120342)

   Skip the complicated stuff and pretend you're using Notepad.
No?

Being a beginner to Lisp doesn't imply being a beginner to programming. Why would an experienced non-Lisp programmer find being subjected to a Notepad-like development experience worth even the slightest consideration?

(EDIT: And non-experienced non-Lisp programmers also have a preferred tool-set, which is likely superior to Notepad.)

Emacs can be great - to some people. The "You have to use Emacs to program in Lisp" meme is not great.

Re:State of the Common Lisp Ecosystem by lispm on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:34AM (#10121427)
> Emacs can be great - to some people. The "You have to use Emacs to program in Lisp" meme is not great.

You don't have to use GNU Emacs to write Lisp code.

It just happens that a popular Editor written in Lisp and extensible in Lisp is somehow the natural choice for Lisp developers.

Re:State of the Common Lisp Ecosystem by pvaldes on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @09:58PM (#10120581)
"you have to use Emacs to program in lisp..."

You don't. Nobody stops you to use vim and fire a clisp repl instead if you want. Older but much friendly to start than sbcl.

Emacs as a barrier to lisp is an interesting concept. To me was exactly the opposite.

Re:State of the Common Lisp Ecosystem by WalterGR on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:24AM (#10121057)

   You don't. Nobody stops you to use vim and fire
   a clisp repl instead if you want.
Of course. And there could very well be a service that accepts handwritten source code via the post, transcribes it, executes it, and mails you the output.

In context, I'm responding to the following:

• the article's preference for beginner-friendly suggestions (e.g. don't overwhelm beginners with an abundance of choice)

• the specific text I quote in my original comment above, and

• the fact that Emacs+SLIME is the de facto standard answer to every Lisp beginner who asks for an IDE.

Re:State of the Common Lisp Ecosystem by pvaldes on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @07:20AM (#10122188)
"Emacs+SLIME is the de facto standard answer to every Lisp beginner who asks for an IDE"

Is a good advice because emacs is awesome, multipurpose, and free.

But, you have choices. You could use also slimv, the "slime for vim" for example. And Vim is also awesome, multipurpose and free.

If you are a total beginner that do not want to learn neither vim nor emacs (something that you will regret when you finally learn one of them some years later) just forget all about superior modes, fire a clisp repl in bash and use your favourite text editor to write and copy-paste. If you want a simple plan to start, is pretty simple

If you want it more simple, just save some bucks and buy a commercial lisp, like allegro for example that comes with a nice IDE: allegro-composer. You obtain what you pay for.

Re:State of the Common Lisp Ecosystem by WalterGR on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:05PM (#10124892)

   But, you have choices.
Correct. It would be nice if they were appropriately presented to beginners.

   like allegro for example that comes with a nice IDE: allegro-composer.
Do you... use Allegro? Do you find it good? Have you used LispWorks?

In the past couple/few years, Franz introduced a single-stepper.[1] They released a video alongside the new feature, demonstrating it. Literally, by 20 minutes into the video, the narrator was still mucking about with configuration and such and hadn't gotten to the point of being able to single-step through Lisp code.

(Also, Allegro's licensing terms require a runtime license fee for every unit of software developed with Allegro that you distribute. LispWorks' do not.)

[1] (It's unconscionable to me that that could be a new-ish feature. I don't even know that I had heard of the term "single-stepper" prior to that - I always just assumed it was a natural v0.1 part of a debugger that didn't bear even mentioning. But what can you do...)

Re:State of the Common Lisp Ecosystem by pvaldes on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @06:08PM (#10126332)
Is only an example (but your experience with lispworks is appreciated).
Re:State of the Common Lisp Ecosystem by doanyway on Friday August 28, 2015 @03:19PM (#10137359)
Re:State of the Common Lisp Ecosystem by aidenn0 on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:28AM (#10121071)
"Why would an experienced non-Lisp programmer find being subjected to a Notepad-like development experience worth even the slightest consideration?"

Is this any different from other IDEs? As a vim user, Eclipse certainly feels more-or-less like notepad.

Re:State of the Common Lisp Ecosystem by melling on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @08:49PM (#10120377)
So don't use it like Notepad. Give it the full hour.

And I doubt if you have to use Emacs to write in Lisp. Let me Google it for you:

http://stackoverflow.com/questions/94792/using-vim-for-lisp-...

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19891

Re:State of the Common Lisp Ecosystem by masukomi on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @08:52PM (#10120386)
use what's possibly the world's most powerful editor... but pretend you're using notepad...

...

Re:State of the Common Lisp Ecosystem by melling on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @09:39PM (#10120516)
Just to get started. Many people are intimidated by Emacs because there is so much to learn. If it scares you, start off simple then let your knowledge grow organically.
Re:State of the Common Lisp Ecosystem by fein on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @10:51PM (#10120763)
I've been coding in emacs for years and still have no idea what I'm doing. Lisp makes sense, but I'm aware that there are thousands of features in emacs that I'm unaware of.

It makes life MUCH worse switching from linux to osx emacs and back though.