News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by qwerty85344324i on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @10:14AM (#10116591)
Serious question for anyone opposes this. What incentive would pharma companies have to publish their secret formulas if Indian generics simply take the IP and drastically undercut prices, preventing the pharma companies from making any profit on the billions they invested in their research? What would compel these pharma companies to invest in any further research?
Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by exelius on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @10:59AM (#10116965)
Very little; which is why pharma research is such a problematic industry. We need to seriously rethink the way we develop drugs:

1. Research does not get funded unless there is a commercial market for the drug. This leads to overfunding of maintenance treatments of chronic diseases like diabetes, because they are widespread and never really go away. Meanwhile, the system does not incentivize investment in things like antibiotics (because the next wide-spectrum antibiotic that gets developed will likely be force-licensed for public health interests).

2. For the vast majority of life-threatening diseases that anyone is likely to catch, the most effective drugs are already off-patent. Unless you can significantly improve outcomes, how can you compete with a generic that works 95% as well as your new drug?

3. The only country currently willing to pay sticker price for pharmaceuticals is the US. Every other country negotiates prices down to a fraction of what the US pays. The idea of a month worth of pills costing $400 is unheard of outside the US. So US citizens are either directly subsidizing the cheap drugs for the rest of the world, or we're getting taken for a ride.

4. The majority of the cost of developing a drug comes in the clinical trial phases. This cost is the same for any drug -- and most of this is marketing budget. Studies are designed to have specific outcomes so they can be listed as bullet points on information sheets given to doctors -- doctors are smart, but they're busy, so if you can do a study saying that "outcomes in high-risk patients were improved by 30% over the leading treatment", the doctors will never look to see what high-risk patients means, whether the study was done correctly, or even what an improved outcome looks like for those patients. Never mind you may have done the study 8 times and this outcome was only observed once.

Pharma is broken. Our current pharma industry is geared towards "lifecycle" drugs that alleviate symptoms rather than fixing any underlying problems.

Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by drabiega on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @10:26AM (#10116677)
I'm not sure why you need to get hypothetical here. Clearly, they currently have sufficient incentive since they're currently investing in research. They are trying to get a likely small amount of additional money (the people in India who could actually afford their prices) in return for an immense cost human cost.(The people who would lose access because of their prices) Why would anyone not oppose this?
Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by saint_fiasco on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @06:38PM (#10119896)
>Clearly, they currently have sufficient incentive since they're currently investing in research

Drug research takes a long time. The drugs that cause this debate are drugs that the pharmaceutical companies decided to research decades ago, when they seriously expected people would respect intellectual property rights more than human lives.

Now that they know better, they will probably go invent a new Viagra or something instead of inventing something useful which can be prematurely generified for the common good.

Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by meric on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @07:08PM (#10120025)
And that's okay. I'll take millions of Indian lives now than thousands of American's and hundreds of Indians in ten years - when a new drug that can save some lives potentially comes onto the market, a new drug not many people can afford.
Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by saint_fiasco on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @07:22PM (#10120104)
I'm not sure where you are getting those numbers. It's very difficult to calculate the costs in human lives of all the drugs that won't be invented in the future.

Lots of people are already dying of antibiotic resistant bacteria, for example, and that's a problem likely to get worse over time.

Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by meric on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @07:59PM (#10120241)
The average Indian cannot afford to take a 1USD per tablet drug once a day. So if that's how all the new drugs are going to be priced - significantly higher than generics, then I say India should go ahead and make generic versions of those drugs, even if it will in future break international law. Who are you to say they should sacrifice their lives so you can have access to better drugs 10 years later that they can't afford anyway?
Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by saint_fiasco on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @10:50PM (#10120761)
India can make generic versions of old drugs. For people who can't afford 1USD a day, having access to bleeding edge medicine isn't going to make as much of a difference as having access to nurses and penicillin. edit: and sanitation, and health education, and so on.

EDIT: Not to mention having their own research and development. I bet it's cheaper to research stuff in India, but evil selfish pharma companies don't want to invest in research in countries with poor intellectual properties protection.

Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by meric on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @11:49PM (#10120938)
Did you know if a pharma company takes an old drug and a new chemical to it to change its effects slightly, the patent is renewed, and that way it it never actually becomes 'old' enough? India will go on and ignore these patents to make generic drugs. Millions of indians have access to affordable medicine today. We can worry about the future benefits when you successfully petition oil companies to stop drilling for oil and invest in renewables instead. The Indian pharmaceutical industry is vibrant and thriving, that is why it has the capacity to reproduce generic versions of patented drugs at will.

You can live a perfectly fine, if frugal, life in India on USD $2 a day, but not if you have to pay for USD $1 tablets.

Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by saint_fiasco on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @01:22AM (#10121215)
>The Indian pharmaceutical industry is vibrant and thriving, that is why it has the capacity to reproduce generic versions of patented drugs at will.

I thought any lab could do that. Isn't the research part the most difficult and expensive part?

>if a pharma company takes an old drug and a new chemical to it to change its effects slightly, the patent is renewed, and that way it it never actually becomes 'old' enough

I've heard about this happening with 'me-too' drugs and bullshit antidepressants. Does it happen as well with essential life saving medicine?

Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by meric on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @01:37AM (#10121266)
I thought any lab could do that. Isn't the research part the most difficult and expensive part?

"The Pharmaceutical industry in India is the world's third-largest in terms of volume and stands 14th in terms of value."

"Indian companies carved a niche in both the Indian and world markets with their expertise in reverse-engineering new processes for manufacturing drugs at low costs."[2]

There is skill involved in reverse-engineering new processes for manufacturing drugs.

Does it happen with essential life saving medicine?

Yes.

"...Glivec, a medicine for chronic myeloid leukemia"[1]

"The Supreme Court defended India’s right to deny patents to incremental improvements. It ruled that Glivec was merely a new form of an older drug and did not constitute a patentable invention. “This is a huge relief,” said Unni Karunakara, the president of Médecins Sans Frontières, which cares for patients in poor countries. Novartis is less pleased, declaring that the ruling “discourages future innovation in India."

Did you previously think pharmaceutical companies care about people's lives more than profit? I'm sorry to disappoint.

[1] http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?client=safari&r...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pharmaceutical_industry_in_Ind...

Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by meric on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @10:28AM (#10116701)
They don't even need the information published - many of the patented medicines are simply reverse engineered in India.
Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by ekianjo on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @10:42AM (#10116829)
You don't need to "reverse engineer" anything. The large majority of the drugs of the market are in the category of small molecules and they are well known and described everywhere. Any organic chemist from any university can draft a synthesis path.

the only thing holding the system in place are the patents, not the knowledge.

Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by 1971genocide on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @10:50AM (#10116892)
As someone who did AP chemistry and then went straight into programming. How would I go about learning more of this knowledge ?
Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by ekianjo on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @10:54AM (#10116924)
Go back to get a Master's in Organic Chemistry like everyone else :) You can find books and online resources, but for actual hands-on practice you need to have labs at hand. (Disclosure: I'm an Organic Chemist).
Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by qwerty85344324i on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @10:37AM (#10116784)
They're investing in research on the expectation that their patents will be honored. If patents are ignored, what do you think this will do to any future research that requires tons in capital expenditures?
Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by newjersey on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @10:50AM (#10116891)
Their patents continue to be honored in the US. I don't think we have any right to ask India to honor US patents unless they are exporting the products to the US.

This is money grab. There is no way to justify it. If they think the money isn't there, they are more than welcome to stop the research.

Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by Thriptic on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @10:33AM (#10116746)
What happens when more countries decide that they're only willing to pay generic prices. The financial incentive to do the R&D will disappear.
Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by fla on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @11:00AM (#10116966)
But up to what point ? What happens when investing into research becomes too risky ? This is a tough problem.
Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by nnain on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @10:38AM (#10116792)
qwerty's question isn't hypothetical. Pharma research indeed is a high stakes game.

What's more appropriate to ask though is how do developing/under-developed countries compete with the money spending power of west. Are the poor people forever destined to look for aid from the west? If they ain't creating all the drugs, they ain't creating all the horrible diseases either. Many tribes were perfectly happy and healthy until the intruders affected their ecosystem.

Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by mjburgess on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @10:45AM (#10116852)
Many tribes were perfectly happy and healthy until the intruders affected their ecosystem.

No. That's just your american white guilt playing up.

Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by joesmo on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @10:16AM (#10116603)
I think billions of dollars in profit should be enough, don't you?
Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by saint_fiasco on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @10:26AM (#10116683)
I think you are focusing on the successful pharma products.

When a company begins an expensive research project, they don't know beforehand if it will be profitable or not.

If little-to-medium pharma were compensated generously for the risks they take, they would make more research in new drugs, but because the risk is not compensated, only big pharma can afford the research.

Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by joesmo on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @12:27PM (#10117628)
I don't see how that changes the fact that these companies have profits in the billions, are still not satisfied, and are willing to contribute to the murder of millions to increase their profits. India should have some fucking balls and stand up for its people and repeal these patent laws designed to make a couple of people rich while murdering so many.
Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by saint_fiasco on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @05:39PM (#10119618)
I don't see how enforcing patents is equivalent to murder.

It's not like if it weren't for the evil pharma companies, everyone would have access to advanced medicine. Quite the contrary, in fact.

We are not talking about software here. Developing medications requires huge investments in developed countries, and no one will develop in the other countries because there is no patent protection in those countries.

Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by qwerty85344324i on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @10:20AM (#10116636)
I don't understand what you're implying. A drug requires billions in investment. Why would a company invest billions into a new drug if they can't make that money back?
Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by noselasd on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @10:33AM (#10116734)
He's implying that they already make their money back, and that billions in investment does pay off, even with the existence of Indian generics - and that will continue to hold true in the future.

Ofcourse from the big pharmacy side, the generics represents lost opportunities, they want to make more money.

Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by hittaruki on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @10:24AM (#10116661)
As an example one of the Pharma companies mentioned Novartis is very much profitable. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-10-28/novartis-t...
Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by qwerty85344324i on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @10:30AM (#10116717)
I am still finding it hard to understand this argument. Why do you think pharma companies like Novartis will continue to be profitable if all of their patents and future patents are ignored? Why would any pharma company invest billions into new research when their IP could just be stolen by an Indian generic and sold for pennies on the dollar?
Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by joesmo on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @12:30PM (#10117657)
Because they're still making billions? But hey, we're not making as many billions as we could. Let's just shut it all down for good. Your reasoning is stupid.
Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by saint_fiasco on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @06:33PM (#10119881)
The drugs that make them billions are things like Xanax, Prozac and Viagra.

We need to incentivize research into important medicine (ie antibiotics, or something to actually cure AIDS and malaria for good), which is hard because as soon as they develop something actually useful, people refuse to honor their patents.

Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by joesmo on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @12:29PM (#10117651)
They make billions regardless of India's patent laws. Why should India let its people die so some company executives somewhere can make a few more billion?
Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by ekianjo on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @10:36AM (#10116771)
> I don't understand what you're implying. A drug requires billions in investment. Why would a company invest billions into a new drug if they can't make that money back?

Well pharma companies tend to spend so much money because they are run very inefficiently in the first place. Plus there's the cost of lobbying...

Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by tim333 on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @10:27AM (#10116688)
They can make the billions back from the US, EU etc, not the $1 a day countries.
Re:‘Pharmacy of the developing world’ under attack from the ... by saint_fiasco on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @06:30PM (#10119870)
Problem is, in the developed countries the more profitable drugs are cosmetics, antidepressants and Viagra.

That means research into important drugs like antibiotics, HIV and malaria medicine is underfunded.