But, if you're an individual trying to decide what works and what doesn't in a field where the popular media is full of misinformation, I have a really hard time seeing the position that counting calories is _completely_ unhelpful.
> "Pitting will-power against metabotically driven hunger ends, in the long-term, with biology winning every time."
Yet, awareness of calories in vs calories out can be a way to plan your strategies, to know from the start whether a given strategy can even work or not, from the point of view of physics. Many people try things that this simple knowledge would rule out. A lifestyle change that does not result in a negative energy balance will not cause someone to lose weight, period.
It's also a framework where you can discover what works for yourself. Does lowering carbs vs lowering fat affect your appetite at the same calorie level? How does burning an extra 500 calories through exercise make you feel vs lowering food intake by that amount? These are valuable things to know, again for an individual on a personal quest, not talking about making public policy or population science.
Some people find an intuitive lifestyle change that successfully allows them to lower their body fat and keep it down. Bravo. Some people also succeed more mechanically with conscious calorie control. I have a hard time seeing the argument that both of these can't be useful and successful.
Then go hungry every now and then once you know the causal link. It's not like it's an irresistible force to which you have no choice but to succumb.
> Pitting will-power against metabotically driven hunger ends, in the long-term, with biology winning every time.
In my experience [sample size: 1] it's entirely possible to ignore hunger for quite some time.
Additionally there are options such as adding filler ingredients that help with reaching satiety with fewer calories. Carbohydrates with a low glycemic index which get absorbed more slowly, thus avoiding a boom-bust cycle as far as your blood sugar levels are concerned are also something you can adjust. This also helps staving off the next hunger for more hours.
It's certainly not an inevitable "I'm hungry, therefore I must eat and grow fat" link that can't be broken.
The grandparent's post seems highly suspect to me. Hunger no doubt plays a role in obesity among some individuals, but the ultimate determinant is how many calories are available to be processed versus how many are expended, regardless of why they have been ingested.
No-one credible denies that.
What the people arguing against CICO are saying is that it's fucking stupid pointless advice to give to a population because while true it's not helpful. We know it's not helpful because we've been saying loud and clear it for many years and obesity rates have risen in almost every country every year.
"We could cure cancer if we just kill all the cancer cells" is true but not helpful.
"We could fix world hunger if hungry people just grew food" is true but not helpful.
> People aren't fat because they eat too much. People (and mammals) eat too much because their fat cells are being metabolically triggered by environmental and/or genetic factors to store fat at a higher than normal rate, diverting calories from operational needs, thus stimulating hunger.
Is hunger really the primary cause of overeating for those who suffer from obesity? This seems unlikely to me.
It's true that calin/calout is a simplification, but there are many who outright deny it. They may not be credible to you, but they are still powerful voices across all media and their gospel is happily accepted by many.
> What the people arguing against CICO are saying is that it's fucking stupid pointless advice to give to a population because while true it's not helpful. We know it's not helpful because we've been saying loud and clear it for many years and obesity rates have risen in almost every country every year.
Posts like yours that deride calin/calout as a useless oversimplification miss the mark; of course it's a very basic fact, not a treatment plan. It's crucial that people understand that this is the mechanism at play if they want to succeed at regulating their weight, and despite your assertion that "nobody credible denies it" there are a lot of big names who will sell you all kinds of solutions that ignore it, and focus on specific distractions rather than looking at obesity as a complex disease with many causes that lead to calorie surplus.
I say this based on my observation and because today I find out I am at risk of obesity (based on this study), yet I slightly overweight.
In my personal circle, I have a lot of overweight friends and like hanging out with them. Some of them are always talking about losing weight, 10K steps, and other diet fads. And some have given up, I guess.
But sometimes it is difficult to eat/hangout with them. Overweight friends who want to lose weight will want to go to healthy restaurant. Then they will get footlong sub with every possible thing at counter. Oh and of course, diet soda and chips. How does it make any sense? I have to bite my lips to stay quiet.
And then other overweight friends/arrogant normal-weight friends, who will only want to eat buffets. And make fun of you if you don't get second refill. Apparently, you have to eat a lot to proof you are a man.
Diabetes medication can cause that. But that's basically a knock-on effect of an already present metabolic issue.
For a healthy adult there shouldn't be any such issue.
People aren't fat because they eat too much. People (and mammals) eat too much because their fat cells are being metabolically triggered by environmental and/or genetic factors to store fat at a higher than normal rate, diverting calories from operational needs, thus stimulating hunger.
Bears don't go into hibernation because they've gotten fat. They get fat because their endocrine system begins gearing up for hibernation, and telling their fat cells to kick into overdrive growing. They will literally burn muscle while simultaneously gaining fat in this stage, like all hibernating mammals. The other side effect of growing fat cells is massive hunger, obviously.
In humans, simple things like not eating sugar can help correct the endocrine factors which, for a lot of people, cause the fat cells to do this. However, genetic factors are going to be a different story.
I say this as somebody who is fit and active, but have had running buddies who are fat. Pitting will-power against metabotically driven hunger ends, in the long-term, with biology winning every time.
Without endocrine/genetic factors taken into account, reduction in calories in simply causes a mammalian body's system to reduce calories out by making the subject less energetic.