I quit on the spot twice when a company was dickish.
Once I had a friend, previous co-worker, that would visit. He'd come into my office and we'd play games (this was a game company). This had happened about once every month or 2 for a year or so. One time I had to go to the restroom. I came back and he was gone. The new boss had escorted him out of the office. I quit on the spot. Saw that boss at a trade show years later. He apologized.
Another time a boss at a company that was flex and who and never missed a deadline decided it doesn't going to be flex anymore for the next project. I was late one day 45 minutes and he got in my face. I brought up that I'd been an hour and a half early the previous day. He didn't care. Claimed if I worked at "The Gap" I'd have been fired. It was like "this isn't the Gap, I'm not an hourly employee". Arguments escalated, I quit.
Apparently he then laid now the law for the remaining employees with strict hours and strict lunch hours and that you were not to leave the building outside those hours and threatening to doc people's pay if they were late. Of course he probably didn't realized that's probably illegal, at least in the USA. If you dock salaries employees by hours worked they become non-exempt meaning by not letting them choose their hours they are effectively hourly employees that have to be paid by the hour and paid overtime. At least in the USA. Of course IANAL but that's my reading of the law.
I'm not really happy with the way I handled things and it's a life long work in progress to not get heated but I am proud that I didn't take shit and moved on from those situations when I did.
Don't be afraid to stick up for yourself. This is a golden age for developers. Learn your worth and don't ask, demand it. To do anything less is doing yourself a great disservice.
One job in particular I should have called their bullshit was when the CEO had one (in a long line of) hissy fit and said he was quitting in a month's time. I was trying to keep the company together, but what I -- the senior developer and the sole maintainer of the company's one revenue-generating product -- should have done was send out an email saying "I am taking a leave of absence and will reporting back to work in one time, after the CEO has left. The new CEO is welcome to contact me about an earlier return time."
Because that probably might have actually gotten the CEO out, instead of him running the company into the ground for slow-motion over the next 8 years. (I had a significant ownership stake.) Oh, he stuck around after threatening to quit. It was his only management technique besides yelling.
Yep. Me too. Thanks for distilling something I have often thought.
Even then it's after they have put up with lots of BS and are used to status quo that they rarely ever quit.
Did the company learn from this? no.
We built a new team, built a new product, and by february of the next year we had all quit.
They are now on their third team.
Nothings changed .
Management complains about how hard it is to find good employees though.
They're terrible managers, and they just can't figure it out. Because its inconceivable to them.
The team now is made up mostly of people whose programming experience is a 6 week boot camp designed to take non programmers and teach them how to program... led by two people who seem to be also-rans who never learned anything after the java boom of the 1990s. Continuos integration? Why would we need that?
They aren't a startup- they are a subdivision of a much larger company, and that's the source of the problem- that larger company has no technical capability, or care, and the management is... incompetent, to say the least.
Supposedly the executives heard about the complaints that their best engineers were ready to walk out, and promised to change the way things were run - I got word recently that they were still continuing the same overpromising, which led to unsurprising unstable backend & frontend issues of various degrees. One product manager described it to me as setting everyone up for failure.
I'm increasingly convinced that it is the sign of bad leadership, and people with no business being in management or an executive position.
Most people spend too much time putting up with BS or even rationalizing that it isn't BS they are putting up with (a lot of people at Amazon are doing this right now.)
Work on your temper if you want.
But if you can be fired on the spot, you can quit on the spot.
And you should. Every engineer should have their terms, and if the terms are violated, quit.
If you join a company that is flex-- changing it to not flex is changing the terms of employement!
Companies change your manager all the time, but how are you supposed to evaluate a company work environment if you can't count on the manager you interviewed being your manager when you get hired... but they think nothing of it because they think you're just a replaceable cog.
Allow them some flexibility, but don't give into this idea that it's a foregone conclusion that you have no say in your work environment.
Quitting on the spot sends a message. But that doesn't matter- they will rationalize. They aren't interested in learnign- and they won't learn from one person leaving.
The second manager sounds like a particularly unique combination of dickish and clueless.
He could have stayed with the outsider ("escorted" them) until the employee came back from the restroom. That's what I would do if I found a random person in my work building who had a visitor's badge and claimed to be there escorted by an employee.
When I go back, the things that most angered me about managers or companies hasn't been "big stuff" (crunching time, low pay, etc...), but those kind of "stupid serious conversations" (not liking the amount of time spend for lunch, that's just "behold! I need to MANAGE because I don't have anything better to do!" of the worst kind) Even in good jobs, those things infuriate you in a way that may make you resign just on the spot... And the current situation in tech it's not like you're afraid of not finding something else...
PD: Part of the manager's work is to say sometimes "Oh! Don't worry about it, I'll talk to him/her and take good care of that" and then do NOTHING.
1) Manage schedules.
2) Set expectations for performing well and be motivational (optional in my case but appreciated).
3) Prevent corporate politics and bullshit from getting in the way and keep the team in the loop about potential bullshit that is bound to come our way.
4) Manage or help manage hiring/firing process and promotion process.
A manager should act as a background process that steps up only if things are very obviously wrong or you directly ask for help related to the above. If they are in the foreground without it being required than they are creating the political bullshit that results in team members becoming weary and quitting.
They don't respect you and they won't respect you when review time comes around or when raises and bonuses are handed out.
Thus it's not really blowing them out of proportion to react negatively to them. They're honesty leaking out.
A pretty similar act of insubordination with drastically different results. My situation improved after that for the remainder of my time in the group.
As a manager, one of my highest goals is to get people to be usefully insubordinate. So many people, thanks to controlling bosses or color-inside-the-lines education, will just do whatever they think powerful people want. But I think we all do our best work when we're thinking for ourselves about how to best serve our users and treat our colleagues.
Good for you! I hope you keep being "insubordinate" wherever you go.
Within 1 week of me leaving my boss was promoted!
Not because he was good at his job, but because he was a bad manager. He was promoted to a position that didn't require him to have a team under him.
In fact, we need something like Glassdoor but where bad reviews don't magically disappear.
This became evident to me when I went on my lunch break after working there for about 4 months. Each employee was given 1 hour for lunch. I spent ~15 minutes walking to the local burrito place, grabbed a burrito which took about 10 minutes and then walked back. I was gone roughly 45 minutes.
The next day I was called into my managers office because someone didn't like the amount of time that I spent on my lunch break. Lucky for me I had my receipt and logged my work time so I showed him how much precious company time I spent galavanting to the burrito place.
I said something that I definitely should have. "Maybe the person that reported me should have been doing work instead of worrying about my lunch break. If this company can't treat its employees like humans, I don't plan on working here much longer"
I got written up for insubordination.
I was pissed.
I went back to my desk and typed up my 2 week notice.
Good riddance.