That said, you may have a point here. If there is a recurring issue that some founders are too immature for their own good and might be a risk to their own personal safety (e.g., committing felonies out of pure ignorance), YC should probably be intentional about filtering those people out during applications. But this article isn't just about YC candidates and that's not a solution for the whole industry.
If sam is saying YC founders are using terms wrong, doesn't that imply that YC was fine with those terms?
So confused.
Anyway, the simple fix would be to just have a 1-3 day finance bootcamp to make sure everyone speaks the same language. Rather than getting everyone to try to being kinda-sorta competent.
For "declining to do any diligence about illegal behavior"? Of course not. Why did this topic come up in the first place?
Re lack of diligence, it's astonishing how people jump to make mean, false statements without a second's pause to consider the obvious.
> I mean, the whole model of YC is to take kids straight out of college
Isn't the average age of YC founders closer to 30?
The fact that there are financial misstatements indicates that there is more need for this type fake work, or perhaps the whole fake work thing isn't so fake after all.
Why not have a bootcamp for a few basic finance rules/jargon? Assuming they see the same sort of issues crop up, surely a 1-3 day bootcamp is a lot less "fake work" than every founder now needing to figure out what they need to know and then know it?
I think college graduates certainly qualify. If I'm going to call myself "CEO" then I better damn well figure out what that means, and if I don't know, I should study or seek the advice of someone who does.
So why wont they? Because maybe it will open them up for liability? I hope that's wrong because they obviously see the need for such a thing, but are too risk averse(?) to provide value there.
Anyway, why are most of sam's post about how stuff sucks/his disappointment as opposed to: this sucks, and here's how we want to try fixing it? He's running the accelerator and this lack of ownership is really hurting the brand.
Sigh. I'm going to get shadowbanned again. What am I saying that's so disagreeable?
As for what's disagreeable in what you said, let's look at your paragraphs: (1) 100% fine; (2) assumes its conclusion and makes an unfair jab; (3) mischaracterizes Sam's posts on the whole, as well as the recent ones; (4) off-topic posturing about bannage.
Regarding your specific complaints: (2)Assuming conclusion and using that to open up discussion is a fairly standard rhetorical practice. Are you saying that that paragraph doesn't move the discussion forward? Why is it unfair? It's an assumption/leading for sure, but it's as fair as anything else.
3) Ok. So here's the thing: when you put things out on the internet, other people read it. They especially read it when it's the top link on HN :). And, they read the content not the intent. Mischaracterization isn't something I'm trying to do malignantly: but unless I'm missing something recent posts have been very much in the vein of "here's what I don't like" rather than "here's how we are fixing some thing we don't like". Maybe I'm still being unfair? But when these posts are up for consumption for the world, the cop-out that it was only meant for the YC class seems a bit silly. Is seeing that opinion voiced really worth the effort of silencing it? Are only "positive" (fawning) posts the ones that are allowed?
4) Are you saying I'm not shadow/hellbanned?
This is only a problem when you're asking investors for more money. That's when you need an accountant to review what you're telling them. You need an accountant and a lawyer at that point anyway, or you're going to get screwed.
It's about seeing a recurrent problem, then helping people by fixing it
I mean, the whole model of YC is to take kids straight out of college (if not before) and turn them into startup CEOs. If those CEOs come out of that process not understanding the legal obligations of their new position, whose fault is that, exactly? It's not like they're bringing decades of business experience to the gig. The only thing they know about what being a CEO requires is what YC teaches them.
If their only preparation for the post is YC, and they're ending up ignorant of stuff that could get them slapped with a felony charge, I would think that would say more about YC than it does about them.