News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Financial Misstatements by dang on Friday August 21, 2015 @02:42PM (#10099464)
I think you might be misapprehending Sam's posts. Demo Day just finished and he's advising startups by warning them about pitfalls. YC has a tradition of making these kinds of posts public—pg used to publish his advice to YC startups in the form of essays for anyone. I always thought that was great. (Off topic: I've been inspired by it to (slowly) write some advice for YC startups about what counts as good content for Hacker News, and when it's ready, will make that public too.)

As for what's disagreeable in what you said, let's look at your paragraphs: (1) 100% fine; (2) assumes its conclusion and makes an unfair jab; (3) mischaracterizes Sam's posts on the whole, as well as the recent ones; (4) off-topic posturing about bannage.

Re:Financial Misstatements by mildbow on Friday August 21, 2015 @02:55PM (#10099531)
Thanks for acknowledging/replying.

Regarding your specific complaints: (2)Assuming conclusion and using that to open up discussion is a fairly standard rhetorical practice. Are you saying that that paragraph doesn't move the discussion forward? Why is it unfair? It's an assumption/leading for sure, but it's as fair as anything else.

3) Ok. So here's the thing: when you put things out on the internet, other people read it. They especially read it when it's the top link on HN :). And, they read the content not the intent. Mischaracterization isn't something I'm trying to do malignantly: but unless I'm missing something recent posts have been very much in the vein of "here's what I don't like" rather than "here's how we are fixing some thing we don't like". Maybe I'm still being unfair? But when these posts are up for consumption for the world, the cop-out that it was only meant for the YC class seems a bit silly. Is seeing that opinion voiced really worth the effort of silencing it? Are only "positive" (fawning) posts the ones that are allowed?

4) Are you saying I'm not shadow/hellbanned?

Re:Financial Misstatements by dang on Friday August 21, 2015 @03:21PM (#10099670)
You're not banned. If you want to discuss these other details further we can do so offline ([email protected]).