News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Bright Students Left Behind by nmrm2 on Friday August 21, 2015 @10:21AM (#10097626)
There's a nice Scientific American blog post about this hypothesis by John Horgan; the essential argument is that this research question is a pointless area of inquiry because the answer should make no difference in a non-evil society:

>I'm torn over how to respond to research on race and intelligence. Part of me wants to scientifically rebut the IQ-related claims of Herrnstein, Murray, Watson and Richwine.

(for example, the claim it's "extremely well backed" that IQ is both "heritable" and "largely genetic", when both are hotly contested, the former is impossible to have decent evidence for given all of the confounding variables, and the latter ("largely") is definitely not true, even given the necessarily poor state of evidence on this question:)

> For example, to my mind the single most important finding related to the debate over IQ and heredity is the dramatic rise in IQ scores over the past century. This so-called Flynn effect, which was discovered by psychologist James Flynn, undercuts claims that intelligence stems primarily from nature and not nurture.

> But another part of me wonders whether research on race and intelligence—given the persistence of racism in the U.S. and elsewhere -- should simply be banned. I don't say this lightly. For the most part, I am a hard-core defender of freedom of speech and science. But research on race and intelligence—no matter what its conclusions are—seems to me to have no redeeming value.

> Far from it. The claims of researchers like Murray, Herrnstein and Richwine could easily become self-fulfilling, by bolstering the confirmation bias of racists and by convincing minority children, their parents and teachers that the children are innately, immutably inferior. (See Post-postscript below.)

> Why, given all the world’s problems and needs, would someone choose to investigate this thesis? What good could come of it? Are we really going to base policies on immigration, education and other social programs on allegedly innate racial differences? Not even the Heritage Foundation advocates a return to such eugenicist policies.

> Perhaps instead of arguing over the evidence for or against theories linking race and IQ we should see them as simply irrelevant to serious intellectual discourse. I'm sympathetic toward the position spelled out by Noam Chomsky in his usual blunt fashion in his 1987 book Language and Problems of Knowledge:

> "Surely people differ in their biologically determined qualities. The world would be too horrible to contemplate if they did not. But discovery of a correlation between some of these qualities is of no scientific interest and of no social significance, except to racists, sexists and the like. Those who argue that there is a correlation between race and IQ and those who deny this claim are contributing to racism and other disorders, because what they are saying is based on the assumption that the answer to the question makes a difference; it does not, except to racists, sexists and the like."

Re:The Bright Students Left Behind by janlin1999 on Friday August 21, 2015 @11:26AM (#10098111)
Doesn't Chomsky make a pretty big assumption there? I feel that he chills intellectual inquiry in this area by calling anyone interested in these questions racists and so forth.

It seems that there are legitimate questions that could be informed by this line of inquiry. For example, research might affect one's opinion about race-based affirmative action programs mandating that the admitted student body mirror the overall population (assuming that IQ is a relevant factor in college admissions). In the scientific realm, if IQ were indeed heritable and if there were substantive differences across large groups of people, wouldn't people be curious why, and by figuring out the pathway, perhaps be able to design supplements or lifestyle changes to raise people's IQs?

I'm not saying that this area of research should be given priority, but it does seem legitimate. As Horgan concedes, this overall sentiment does seem to go against the grain of freedom of scientific inquiry.

Re:The Bright Students Left Behind by nmrm2 on Friday August 21, 2015 @11:49AM (#10098271)
> For example, research might affect one's opinion about race-based affirmative action programs mandating that the admitted student body mirror the overall population

No, because affirmative action programs operate from an absolute commitment to diversity and/or a recognition of systemic violence against certain communities in recent history. Those commitments hold (or not) regardless of genetic variation.

> In the scientific realm, if IQ were indeed heritable and if there were substantive differences across large groups of people, wouldn't people be curious why, and by figuring out the pathway, perhaps be able to design supplements or lifestyle changes to raise people's IQs

There's a whole field of research called "Education" that studies essentially this question, but not unnecessarily confined to IQ as a sole metric.

And yes, many education researchers investigate the effectiveness of interventions in the context of communities (include racially-defined ones).

The race/IQ correlation question is totally irrelevant to the discovery and evaluation of assessments among subcommunities.

How could knowledge of racial differences in IQ possibly do to push forward education research? Everything we know about differences between subcommunities points to behavioral interventions being effective, and nurture aspects playing a dominate causal role.

And even if you want to go full on eugenics / genetic engineering, we have some comparatively stronger hypotheses about some genetic causes for IQ variation that are absolute (i.e., genes that effect IQ but are not correlated with race).

So even in a crazy futuristic (I would say dystopian) world of genetic engineering for things like intelligence, investigating racial theories is still a waste of time.

Re:The Bright Students Left Behind by nmrm2 on Friday August 21, 2015 @12:27PM (#10098570)
> I feel that he chills intellectual inquiry in this area by calling anyone interested in these questions racists and so forth.

Well, duh? Chomsky's explicitly trying to chill discussion/research into hypothesis.

First because it has no intellectual value -- it's like asking whether red is a better color than purple. Even if there were an answer to such an odd question, it would be useless. Hence, the answer is more likely to be used as a rhetorical sword in political debates than for e.g. effective interventions (which are pretty difficult to imagine short of eugenics in any case).

Second because he doubts it's a sincere inquiry. He questions, I think, whether the outcomes of this research will be scientifically grounded and used for good, or more likely to be taken on face value (no matter how confounded/weak) and become an excuse to validate overtly racist eugenics/immigration policies.

In other words, Chomsky is calling bullshit on this line of "research" being either "intellectual" or a sincere "inquiry".

Re:The Bright Students Left Behind by jmorphy88 on Friday August 21, 2015 @11:20AM (#10098074)
So, in other words, suppress lines of thought that have political outcomes that I don't like? Strong stuff, that.
Re:The Bright Students Left Behind by nmrm2 on Friday August 21, 2015 @11:59AM (#10098349)
> suppress lines of thought that have political outcomes that I don't like?

Do not fund lines of thought where the harms outweigh the potential benefits, and/or where ethical commitments are violated.

That policy is neither particularly strong or particularly uncommon. It's the guiding principle behind IRBs, which are pervasive. (In fact, as Horgan points out, one of the primary motivations for IRBs was racist scientists conducting downright evil experiments on black men.)

There are two components to this analysis.

First, do benefits outweigh harms? This is easy because there are no benefits. Suppose there is a correlation between race and IQ. What non-evil thing, pray tell, would you have us do with that knowledge?

Second, are there any ethical violations? Also easy. Racial superiority theories aren't "political outcomes that I don't like." They are fundamentally Evil; for god's sake, this is one of very situations where the motivation behind Godwin's Law doesn't apply.

Re:The Bright Students Left Behind by temujin on Friday August 21, 2015 @04:20PM (#10099970)
It appears that you consider, among other things, Singapore's rise over the last 50 years to be "evil". This puts you at odds with practically the entire economics profession, and just about everyone else in the world trying to actually improve conditions in poor countries instead of burning perceived witches and warlocks.
Re:The Bright Students Left Behind by nmrm2 on Friday August 21, 2015 @07:55PM (#10100953)
> Singapore's rise over the last 50 years

You mean conducting eugenics experiments on low-income women?

Or did you mean encouraging only educated people to have children?

If you really think sterilizing and performing experiments on the poor without consent constitutes social progress... I don't really know what to say.

Anyways, it's a pretty far stretch to say that Singapore's eugenics program had anything at all to do with its economic performance over the past 50 years. More-over, the changes to reproductive rates in Singapore are pretty uniform throughout the population. So even if population control has helped Singapore, it was just the population control -- not the class-centered eugenics schemes.

And all of this is discounting the fact that it's not even effective when judged on its own terms... turns out governments don't make for very good PD controllers.

> with practically the entire economics profession

This is obviously not true. It is not the case that the majority of practicing ecnomists support eugenics...

Second, even if this were true, it would be irrelevant. Economists are not geneticists, biologists, anthropologists, etc. They are absolutely not trained to make the sort of assessments I'm talking about above.

Re:The Bright Students Left Behind by temujin on Friday August 21, 2015 @10:17PM (#10101222)
Most economists agree that Lee Kuan Yew did a better job at increasing his people's prosperity than almost every other developing-country leader of his era. An increasing number of African leaders (Rwanda's Paul Kagame is an especially vocal example) see him as a primary role model.

You are free to believe that LKY's worldview was totally inaccurate and that he owes his success to a ridiculous amount of luck. (As you note, his views on human group differences were not a random eccentricity, they had a major impact on his policy choices in several domains.) Fortunately, those who are doing the most to increase African prosperity today reject your position, and tens of millions of people are benefiting.

Re:The Bright Students Left Behind by peterfirefly on Friday August 21, 2015 @12:23PM (#10098530)
> Suppose there is a correlation between race and IQ. What non-evil thing, pray tell, would you have us do with that knowledge?

Stop affirmative action? Let it influence immigration policy? Let it inform crime policy?

It is in fact possible to find it evil to NOT do so...

> Racial superiority theories aren't "political outcomes that I don't like." They are fundamentally Evil; for god's sake, [...]

They are exactly "political outcomes that I don't like". Treating people like individuals ought to be considered non-evil but belief in racial equality leads to people NOT being treated like individuals.

Re:The Bright Students Left Behind by nmrm2 on Friday August 21, 2015 @12:32PM (#10098608)
> Stop affirmative action?

Affirmative action is motivated by either an absolute belief in diversity being good (e.g., there are benefits for economic minorities that apply ragardless of race), and/or as an intervention meant to correct for structural violence in recent history.

The racial question is irrelevant to either of those issues.

> Let it influence immigration policy? Let it inform crime policy?

Immigration and crime policy written under the belief that some races are genetically superior to others...

Didn't I ask for examples that aren't fucking evil?

In any case, EVEN IF there is a correlation (after controlling for the hundred of obvious things and god knows what else), other factors (including variation that race doesn't explain and environmental factors) are so extraordinarily dominant that racial variation is more an excuse for racist bullshit than an objective justification for it.

Which is exactly why we don't even need to know the answer to the question.

> Treating people like individuals ought to be considered non-evil but belief in racial equality leads to people NOT being treated like individuals.

I have no idea what this means.

WRT affirmative action this is barely an intelligible position, because anyone with half a brain will realize that there are massive environmental factors that definitely dominate any difficult-to-even-validate racial causation.

WRT crime and immigration policy: writing either informed by a barely statistically significant correlation that's probably impossible to even actually prove because of thousands/millions of latent variables is pretty fucking far from treating people like individuals. Especially when that "science" conveniently validates white superiority theory.

[dead]
Re:The Bright Students Left Behind by dang on Friday August 21, 2015 @07:32PM (#10100876)
> Despite all your church-lady hyperventilation

HN is for comments that are civil and substantive. Please don't post anything more like this, and please don't conduct flamewars on this site.

Re:The Bright Students Left Behind by peterfirefly on Saturday August 22, 2015 @03:25AM (#10101813)
nmrm2 is basically calling me and jmorphy2 evil all the time -- but jmorphy2's rather benign comment gets killed?
Re:The Bright Students Left Behind by dang on Saturday August 22, 2015 @03:59AM (#10101857)
That comment was obviously not benign, and you were all breaking the guidelines—not necessarily equally, but that doesn't much matter. What matters is that the thread is not the kind of discussion we want here.
Re:The Bright Students Left Behind by nmrm2 on Friday August 21, 2015 @02:09PM (#10099229)
First, moral frameworks exist for a reason and aren't the realm of "church-lady hyperventilation". For example, most plausible instantiations of the crime policies suggested above are blatantly unconstitutional.

Second, there are plenty of objective arguments in my posts here that any racialized theory of intelligence is not worth to studying, and you're ignoring all of them. As one small example, over multiple posts, you and peterfirefly have failed to name one concrete policy option for which an answer to this question is remotely necessary.

If anything here is irrational, it is your insistence on studying a correlation that has no value beyond justifying racially motivated policies. If the last 2000 years teach us anything, it's that for any concrete social problem you'd want to solve, a solution motivated by the belief that one race is superior to another is not going to be the optimal solution.

> pretending that race is some utterly inscrutable field

Belief in superiority on a collection of phenotypes roughly correlated to what we call "race" today pre-dates Darwin by 100+ years. AS a matter of historical fact, the "scientific" notion of race today came about as a post-facto characterization of latent racial superiority theories that existed prior to the scientific era.

So yes, race is inscrutable from a scientific perspective because it is not -- at base -- an idea of scientific origin.

Here is what we do know.

We know that Every. Single. Time. any society has made a decision motivated by the belief that one race is objectively better than another race, the result was a social order that could not be described with any word other than evil.

We know that for hundreds of years, crackpots of varying scientific literacy and persuasiveness have evoked the en vogue scientific ideas of the day to claim the inferiority of a group of people with an astoundingly invariant set of latent racial characterizations. And we know that at every point in history, their crackpottery is eventually identified -- even if science doesn't advance enough to demonstrate the crackpottery until years later. (the somewhat pathetic aspect of the crackpottery displayed in this thread that rjkyle is so kindly addressing is that it all has already been disproven, and yet... so don't pretend this is about "scientific truth" or "intellectual inquiry")

We know that even if it were reasonable from to outset to choose a given phenotype over all others to study, it would go against the grain of everything we have learned in the last 2000 years to use any notion of inferiority between races as a basis for decision making.

We know that even if that characterization had a causal link to intelligence, there are far better and less noisy predictors of intelligence.

So, there is no reason to study this correlation. Not today, not yesterday, not tomorrow. Nothing good can come of it. If history is a guide, not even intellectual understanding.

Anyways, I'm done engaging with you and peterfirefly now. The belief that one "race" is superior to another is detestable, and to claim that there could exist definitive scientific evidence for such a claim fundamentally misunderstands what science is and ignores a rich history of such claims in the history of science

Re:The Bright Students Left Behind by peterfirefly on Friday August 21, 2015 @02:47PM (#10099484)
> For example, most plausible instantiations of the crime policies suggested above are blatantly unconstitutional.

No. Perhaps it's even the other way around: police and courts should not be hindered in fighting crime, just because too many of the criminals seem to be black. Don't black people in black neighbourhoods have a right to protection against criminals? Is it constitutional to deny them said protection?

> Second, there are plenty of objective arguments in my posts here that any racialized theory of intelligence is not worth to studying, and you're ignoring all of them.

No.

> As one small example, over multiple posts, you and peterfirefly have failed to name one concrete policy option for which an answer to this question is remotely necessary.

No.

> We know that Every. Single. Time. any society has made a decision motivated by the belief that one race is objectively better than another race, the result was a social order that could not be described with any word other than evil.

We know that ideologies that pretend people are equal have gone terrifyingly off the rails -- especially when they succeeded in controlling what was allowed to be said.

> We know that even if that characterization had a causal link to intelligence, there are far better and less noisy predictors of intelligence.

Absolutely. We can measure it directly, for example, on individuals.

Re:The Bright Students Left Behind by nmrm2 on Friday August 21, 2015 @03:24PM (#10099688)
> No. Perhaps it's even the other way around

What? I don't know what rock you've been living under since the 1960s, but overt and blatant racial discrimination in policing or sentencing is a) a blatant violation of the fourth and fourteenth amendments to the United States Constitution; b) illegal under and number of federal and state statutes; and c) something we've already tried (both constitutionally and unconstitutionally) throughout the years and it's never worked. (BTW, I'm repeating myself and this is called an argument.)

>> Second, there are plenty of objective arguments in my posts here that any racialized theory of intelligence is not worth to studying, and you're ignoring all of them.

> No.

Name one concrete policy proposal motivating this research. One way in which the world would change if we had an answer (which, BTW, we already do -- the effect is negligible even setting aside the fact that the question doesn't even make sense).

I've already explained Affirmative Action is more about reconciliation for pre-civil-rights era structural violence, or just a carte blanc commitment to diversity. Neither of which is informed by the proposed research. (BTW, I'm repeating myself and this is called an argument.)

I've explained numerous times that history (i.e. as close as we get to empirical evidence in societal decision making) suggests that making decisions based upon these beliefs is a bad idea. (BTW, I'm repeating myself and this is called an argument.)

And of course the fact that we've already made racial discrimination in law enforcement both unconstitutional (in multiple ways) and illegal (in multiple ways) because of the observed harm these policies caused (BTW, I'm repeating myself and this is called an argument.)

> We know that ideologies that pretend people are equal have gone terrifyingly off the rails -- especially when they succeeded in controlling what was allowed to be said.

Frist, what harm? The only concrete harm I've heard from anyone so far is Johnny McSuburb (believing he was) turned down for a college scholarship because some black kid from the hood matched his test scores. Calling that a real harm is ridiculous when stacked up against e.g. the "scientifically" justified sterilization programs of the 1950s. And that's limiting ourselves to some of the more benign examples of the policy impacts of racialized "science". Far worse has been done in the name of "scientifically proven" racial superiority theories, even just in the United States. (BTW, I'm repeating myself and this is called an argument.)

Second, restricting IRB approval isn't "controlling what was allowed to be said". It's controlling what federally funded researchers can try to validate using public money. So I fail to see what concrete harm you're referring to. (BTW, I'm repeating myself and this is called an argument.)

The fact is, espousing "scientific proof" of claims that one race is intellectually superior to another is not new. Similar claims have be made and then used in the past to commit outright atrocities. It is difficult to see how the demonstrable harm done by taking these claims seriously outweighs the basically non-existent benefits we would get from having an answer.

Re:The Bright Students Left Behind by dang on Friday August 21, 2015 @07:31PM (#10100869)
> I don't know what rock you've been living under

Personal attacks are not allowed on HN.

Please don't conduct flamewars here either.

Re:The Bright Students Left Behind by nmrm2 on Friday August 21, 2015 @03:46PM (#10099793)
jmorphy88 - You pretend like there's no danger here, but we're short on examples of "scientific" evidence being used as a justification for killing off or harming huge portions of populations, even here in the US.

The attempt to paint racialized theories of intelligence as objective scientific inquiries lacking in prejudice is also not new, and those exact theories whose inquiry was justified in this exactly same way ("you moralizing buffoons, we're doing science!") have been used to justify undeniable evil in the past, even in this country.

So yeah, jeer. But eugenics sterilization campaigns in the 50's had this origin and were Fucking Evil. No other word is fitting for forced sterilization, and those campaigns were justified by "science" that "debunked" people who were overly-"moralizing" societal planning.

Also, the original parent isn't even doing the latest rhetorical trick of not talking about races but about "demarcated populations" or "collections of phenotypes". He specifically mentions "Africans". So, no, this isn't about defending Science. This is about using science to defend overtly and obviously unscientific bigotry.

[dead]
Re:The Bright Students Left Behind by dang on Friday August 21, 2015 @07:36PM (#10100885)
Please stop posting uncivil and unsubstantive comments.