News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Bright Students Left Behind by nmrm2 on Friday August 21, 2015 @12:27PM (#10098570)
> I feel that he chills intellectual inquiry in this area by calling anyone interested in these questions racists and so forth.

Well, duh? Chomsky's explicitly trying to chill discussion/research into hypothesis.

First because it has no intellectual value -- it's like asking whether red is a better color than purple. Even if there were an answer to such an odd question, it would be useless. Hence, the answer is more likely to be used as a rhetorical sword in political debates than for e.g. effective interventions (which are pretty difficult to imagine short of eugenics in any case).

Second because he doubts it's a sincere inquiry. He questions, I think, whether the outcomes of this research will be scientifically grounded and used for good, or more likely to be taken on face value (no matter how confounded/weak) and become an excuse to validate overtly racist eugenics/immigration policies.

In other words, Chomsky is calling bullshit on this line of "research" being either "intellectual" or a sincere "inquiry".

There are no comments on this comment yet.