These apprenticeships are for like $500/week. That's not a good opportunity for some in a four-year CS program.
I'm saying that the alternative models proposed are even worse fits for the problem than the model considered lacking. This isn't a field currently structured for a relatively short training period to lead to a typical career.
Maybe medicine should be the goal model. Doctors and nurses, code monkeys and software engineers.
You don't need to relearn imaginary numbers or assembly programming to be a good software developer.
You could start them with a job. They'd have, by their standards, a great job. What they almost certainly wouldn't have is a typical career in software engineering following that job and the obsolescence of their skillset.
But for most of the programmers I know, they're just writing code that runs a business which is certainly not IT.
I think the situation we're in is an uncomfortable one. Basically, the tech world needs people, and the four-year approach seems too slow. Sadly, nothing I've seen - and I've been affiliated with a bootcamp - seems to both provide the people required and give them the grounding for a career.
We as an industry have this burning need to believe that there must be something better. However, I submit that this is the equivalent of protesting "There must be a better way!" when confronted with an uncomfortable policy decision. In both cases the sentiment is laudable, but fails to conjure the alternative into being.
It is a good opportunity for somebody. As near as I can tell, that somebody is the four-year CS programs of the world.
The only alternative I can see is bifurcating development work into high-skill people who know CS and low-skill code monkeys. I'm uncomfortable with this, but I suppose it could be workable. We'd just have to disabuse all those code monkeys of the illusion that they're going to become computer scientists.