News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by littletimmy on Sunday August 16, 2015 @12:14PM (#10069275)
I don't know why the poor just don't kill the rich, to be honest. I'm not poor, but if my child was suffering because of abject poverty and lack of healthcare while some asshole was buying a $50000 Birkin bag, I'd probably tear up the person with the bag. Why do the poor not just revolt?
Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by jeremyt on Sunday August 16, 2015 @12:26PM (#10069314)
Because people have an innate sense of right and wrong. The concept that you should not kill someone else in order to take with they have has been shown to be almost universal across time and culture.
Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by 13of40 on Sunday August 16, 2015 @12:55PM (#10069426)
I don't think that's the whole story. I read a really eye-opening book a while back that was essentially an insider's guide to surviving in prison, and one of the things that stuck with me was the idea that people behave themselves (for the most part) in that environment because there's always somewhere "further down" in the system they can send you as punishment. It's the same on the outside. In the US, at least, you have to be really, really poor before being in prison for the rest of your life is a better option. Most poor people have lives, friends, family, a daily routine, freedoms, possessions, etc., that they'd be putting at risk if they decided to start murdering random rich people. Especially at scale.
Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by johnchristopher on Saturday August 29, 2015 @05:12PM (#10141362)
I really want a citation for that.
Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by littletimmy on Sunday August 16, 2015 @04:05PM (#10070083)
That is not true. That standard has historically applied only to people who are "in your group". People throughout history have had no problem killing a neighboring tribe and taking over their stuff (including women and children).

I doubt any poor person sees a rich person as a part of their extended social group. The psychological barrier does not exist.

Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by zo1 on Sunday August 16, 2015 @12:59PM (#10069452)
I'm more curious why the poor, and the rich aren't calling for more consequences for the politicians. The rich, and the poor alike understand that one of the main reasons for a government is to protect those who can't protect themselves (from circumstance, even).

The money is there. The food is there. The shelter is there. It's all there, yet you see individuals suffering left, right and center and even dying. Meanwhile, we can't even get the politicians to provide basic housing, food, healthcare and jobs for society's bottom rung.

Perhaps, the reason you question the use of violence as a solution to this problem is because you feel that there is no other recourse. We've been doing the "democracy" thing for a while, yet we can't get the basics right. Hell, we can't even up and call for a country-wide referendum on basic hotly-debated topics. It's all a circus, and the poor are barely getting enough bread to get by.

Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by blfr on Sunday August 16, 2015 @12:35PM (#10069357)
People who have the capacity to start a revolution have the capacity to start money-making organizations and usually are pretty well off. This is how revolutions do happen: when capable, rising groups are blocked from advancing further.
Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by BerislavLopac on Sunday August 16, 2015 @01:53PM (#10069651)
Of course they do. When they do it individually, they quickly get arrested and thrown in jail. When they get organized, you get revolutions, which when successful end up by someone else becoming rich.
Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by evanpw on Sunday August 16, 2015 @01:56PM (#10069660)
World GDP per capita (PPP) is about $13,000 / person [1]. So if the poor rose up, killed the rich, and distributed everything equally, then, assuming that the rich produce literally nothing and compensation has no effect on work effort, everyone in the world could make slightly less than the US minimum wage.

[1] http://www.indexmundi.com/world/gdp_per_capita_(ppp).html

Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by reasonishy on Sunday August 16, 2015 @12:17PM (#10069286)
Isn't that pretty much why we have welfare - to give the poor protection money to stop them attacking? Sure, you could spend more on police, but it's probably more cost effective to just give poor people money to keep them a bit more docile.
Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by hyperpallium on Sunday August 16, 2015 @12:57PM (#10069440)
Bread and circuses. Basic income could work even better, by giving more certainty. There's probably a better version of circuses too - it was TV, now the mainstream internet, but at least there's more opportunity to use the net to move forward.
Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by praptak on Sunday August 16, 2015 @01:34PM (#10069577)
Probably same reasons that keep them poor like being too busy with the day to day effort to stay afloat.
Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by informatimago on Sunday August 16, 2015 @03:11PM (#10069909)
Really this is an important point, expressed in the other answers.

There is a game and there are rules of that game, and almost everybody adhere to those rules and play the game, winners or losers. Killing somebody, notably the rich, is a game move, and there are rules about it, like go to jail, don't get the $20,000.

The question you're asking is why don't the poor just stop playing the game? Even rich people realize the game is no fun, and the losers of that game have a hard time, and I guess, some of them wouldn't mind stopping the game.

The thing is that the game is rigged to ensure that you don't realize it's there, and to ensure that you run and run all the time to catch up, without time to stop and think about the game.

Really, the majority in the middle can't take the time to think about it, and they still think they can win! Or if not them, their children. Only a few winners and losers could realize that. The losers, if they realize it, before they die, they can't do anything about it anyways, having to work hard to survive. The winners, they can't du much about it either, even with all their money, because everybody else wants to play the game.

You could hope to try to change it thru education, but now it's obvious that education is rigged to maintain people in ignorance and have them keep running for the game. http://www.amazon.com/John-Taylor-Gatto/e/B001K7S0AE/?_encod...

You could hope to try to change it thru the political system, but now it's obvious that it is rigged by the winners to maintain a winning game for them. http://web.stanford.edu/~gentzkow/research/tv_turnout.pdf http://home.bi.no/fag89001/TV.pdf

As mentionned in another answer, a revolt only lead to the reproduction of the game, with another set of winner (or often just the same), and this arguably comes from the fact that the formal rules are written down by the same set of people designated by the winners, instead of by the people doing the revolt. I'm talking here of the constitutions. So one way would be to educate people to teach them constitution writing so that they could write their own consititution next time they revolt, and not have the same bunch of goonies write it for the ex-winners so they can be the new winners again. But see the problem with education above. On the other hand, here is a little light, with the Internet, people could educate themselves. Learn about true democracy at http://le-message.org/?lang=en and write constitution articles with your friends!

But more than just the consitution and formal rules (laws) aspect to the game, it also exists in an informal way in the mind of people, culturally.

The notions that you have to work to survive, the notion of money (and how it has been transformed in the recent centuries by the banksters), have to be changed. It's true that for a long time scarcity made it rather difficult to envision those changes. And the winners know it, since they are even today sending propaganda about a so called "Earth Overshoot Day" and other bullshit like overpopulation and climate "change", http://www.footprintnetwork.org/ to program deeply into your mind the notion of scarcity.

http://www.amazon.fr/L%C3%AAtre-contre-lavoir-Francis-Cousin...

Instead, people we have to free ourselves from this mind set, learn about alternatives, and prepare for a real "revolution", where we will be able finally to get rid of the psychopaths "winners" of games, and of any "game" that pits man against man. https://www.thevenusproject.com/en/ http://www.thezeitgeistmovement.com/

In the meantime, and pushed very hard by robotization and automation of enterprises, the establishment of a universal income, basic revenue, whatever you name it, should ease the transition and perhaps let us avoid a bloody revolt.

There's also another dimension to take into account, that the poor are actually not in the same country or even the same continent as the rich. Some of those poor, pushed by war (resulting directly or indirectly from the USA and Europe action!), are migrating "refuge" into our countries; thus they are getting closer to the "rich", but most of the time they just start to run to play the game, happy of being already richer or more alive than their cousins they left home. Fighting fewer wars, killing fewer "dictators", and instead having some kind of international cooperation that would transform those countries into something less than us as we are now or were in the past couple of centuries, but instead more like what we'll be in a few centuries, could greatly help with this. Instead of killing a dictator, installing Internet in his country ought to be much more efficient. Instead of accepting the Internet filters of China, India or UK, promiting a free Internet everywhere could make it easier to resolve poverty everywhere.

Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by GFK_of_xmaspast on Sunday August 16, 2015 @01:12PM (#10069502)
Who do you think own all the guns.
Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by zo1 on Sunday August 16, 2015 @01:49PM (#10069631)
The government.
[dead]
Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by RodericDay on Sunday August 16, 2015 @12:22PM (#10069303)
It's a perfectly legitimate thing to ponder, even in movies like Denzel Washington's "John Q", and Amazon Billionaire Nick Hanauer's essay "The Pitchforks Are Coming (For Us Plutocrats)" [0].

If you bury your head in the sand and pretend that people will never break the social contract because "inequality doesn't matter" and "macroeconomic indicators look fine", you're going to miss a big part of the picture.

[0] http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2014/06/the-pitchfork...

Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by ChuckMcM on Sunday August 16, 2015 @12:41PM (#10069373)
Yes and no, the pitchforks come out when people are prevented from achieving their full potential by others who feel threatened by that. For now, this isn't the case in the USA. Sure you have a harder time getting lift off if you are born into a dysfunctional family living on welfare, but there are exits and many people work very hard to help illuminate the pathway to the exit for those kids.

The question of "Why not just kill the people who have what you want?" is fundamentally a dystopian one. Feudalism, warlords, not a way to move forward. There are plenty of examples in the world today, just look at Syria which has millions of people who could be productively running shops, writing books, learning about the world, developing new products, and instead they displaced in refugee camps in Turkey by war between fundamentally ideologically disjoint groups.

So while it may be uncharitable to suggest someone seek psychological help for asking the question, the fact that the question is even considered as a possible "solution" (and it is presented that way in the GP post) raises a bigger question which is "What exactly does the poster expect to be the result of people just going out and killing other people they don't like?"

Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by EliRivers on Sunday August 16, 2015 @12:56PM (#10069431)
More importantly (in fact, only importantly - reality doesn't matter in this case; perception is everything), the ruling classes manage to continue to perpetuate the idea that if you just work hard you can join them. Over the last few decades (in the US and many other places), the wealth you are born into has become ever more correlated with your own success in life, but as long as the underclass believe they can get there, they'll keep playing inside the system. We don't need to actually provide a route out of poverty to keep them from rising up; just make people believe it's possible.
Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by joshuapants on Sunday August 16, 2015 @12:26PM (#10069313)
Not advocating the murder of innocents is burying my head in the sand? Fascinating.
Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by tomp on Sunday August 16, 2015 @12:41PM (#10069375)
He/She posed it as a question worthy of discussion, s/he wasn't actually advocating murder. That's like saying, "How come bank tellers don't just rob the bank a bit every day?", a perfectly legitimate question.
Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by joshuapants on Sunday August 16, 2015 @12:52PM (#10069413)
> I don't know why the poor just don't kill the rich, to be honest

> I'd probably tear up the person with the bag

"I would literally murder a random innocent" is a bit different from what you suggest.

Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by tomp on Sunday August 16, 2015 @12:58PM (#10069447)
Well, if I had to choose between having my child die and letting a rich person keep their $5k bag, I might do the same.
Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by joshuapants on Sunday August 16, 2015 @01:09PM (#10069491)
> Well, if I had to choose between having my child die and letting a rich person keep their $5k bag, I might do the same.

Where on earth did you pull this dichotomy from?

Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by zo1 on Sunday August 16, 2015 @01:59PM (#10069669)
It's a very common theme, actually. I'm not the OP who mentioned it, but I've heard the same basic form rehashed in many different ways.

Essentially, morality and right/wrong are seen as "relative". Thus, you get situations where basic, very simple morals are thrown out the window by some sort of superseding narrative. Unfortunately, we're conditioned into it every day. Long story short: "it's okay to do bad things to bad people" is glorified and romanticized. While the opposite, absolute moral of "doing bad things is bad" is ignored.

It's hard to not take this sort of discussion into the realm of politics. But, again, long story short: If we were ever to use absolute morals, we'd very quickly run into a slew of problems with most political systems every created or envisioned.

Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by dang on Sunday August 16, 2015 @08:40PM (#10070859)
Comments like "where on earth did you pull this [...] from" and "please seek psychological help" break the HN guidelines, which ask you to comment civilly and substantively. Please don't post any more comments like this to HN.

littletimmy's comment was a good occasion to apply the Principle of Charity: http://philosophy.lander.edu/oriental/charity.html. An easy plausible interpretation was that he was asking why violence doesn't happen more often—not advocating it.

Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by joshuapants on Sunday August 16, 2015 @09:01PM (#10070931)
An easy and plausible interpretation of my post is that I was concerned for the psyche of my fellow human being, and for the people he might be around. In the future please respond more civilly and substantively instead of dismissively.
Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by kachnuv_ocasek on Sunday August 16, 2015 @12:57PM (#10069441)
They might not be innocent from the poor person's point of view.
Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by joshuapants on Sunday August 16, 2015 @01:10PM (#10069495)
Abortion doctors might not be innocent from the fundamentalist Christian's point of view.
Re:What Poverty Does to Your Brain by littletimmy on Sunday August 16, 2015 @03:38PM (#10069989)
I was wondering about the amount of hardship it would take for a person to reject the social contract. That is not psychopathy.