News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by aabajian on Sunday August 16, 2015 @07:52AM (#10068657)
Everyone is saying "Nope". A couple events happened in the US in 2013/2014 - The number of cell phones surpassed the number of computers, and the number of smartphones surpassed the number of basic phones. Both iOS and Android are Unix derivatives, so I'd say Unix is winning the post-PC era.
Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by pjmlp on Sunday August 16, 2015 @08:30AM (#10068731)
Except that both lack UNIX userland, aren't POSIX compliant and have a sandbox design.
Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by the_why_of_y on Sunday August 16, 2015 @10:40AM (#10069002)
... and ridiculous hard coded limits like 128 shared objects per process:

http://androidxref.com/4.2_r1/xref/bionic/linker/linker.cpp#...

This hilarious memset(3) bug was shipping for years:

https://android-review.googlesource.com/#patch,sidebyside,14...

Well, that's what you get when you NIH your libc...

Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by SamReidHughes on Sunday August 16, 2015 @12:21PM (#10069296)
A similar memset bug happened in glibc too.
Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by varjag on Sunday August 16, 2015 @08:57AM (#10068779)
Android is partially POSIX compliant at least, in larger degree than Linux+glibc has been for the first decade.
Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by brudgers on Sunday August 16, 2015 @11:48AM (#10069190)
The major theme of the episode is that the important part of Unix adoption is applications users use. Of course, in the context of 1985, POSIX compliance is an anachronism anyway. The video was recorded on the front side of the Unix Wars [1].

[1]: http://catb.org/~esr/writings/taoup/html/ch02s01.html#id2880...

Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by rbanffy on Sunday August 16, 2015 @11:56AM (#10069215)
You can install your own glibc and run a full Linux userland on top of an Android kernel.
Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by pjmlp on Sunday August 16, 2015 @12:18PM (#10069290)
I can also run a full UNIX userland on Windows, z/OS or OS/400, that doesn't make them UNIX.

And I doubt IPC will work anyway, given that the Android kernel doesn't do UNIX IPC.

Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by cmrdporcupine on Sunday August 16, 2015 @09:37AM (#10068864)
Well and this is not even mentioning that the 'cloud' is overwhelmingly Unix (well, Linux, so Unix with a small-u)

In terms of installed operating systems and the applications people interact with, Unix or Unix-alike systems win. I don't care if the desktops they use are Windows, or if the phones they run (which have a Unix/Linux kernel usually) don't expose a shell prompt -- the applications they run get the largest part of their functionality through server daemons running on systems running *nix.

Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by pjmlp on Sunday August 16, 2015 @12:33PM (#10069345)
Which is quite sad, because now we are kind of stuck in OS design, with only Microsoft, Apple and a few universities pushing the OS research further.
Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by vezzy-fnord on Sunday August 16, 2015 @01:50PM (#10069634)
I haven't seen Apple do anything interesting w.r.t. OS research. Microsoft Research had Singularity, WinFS and some other efforts.

There's definitely some Unixes that are still trying to do something different, like DragonFly BSD, MINIX 3, Genode and so forth.

Most of it is academic efforts, as always.

Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by pjmlp on Sunday August 16, 2015 @02:40PM (#10069815)
The container model introduced with XPC and the app sandbox model.

Being an hybrid kernel, not like the other UNIXes.

Introducing a super root model, where the traditional root becomes a mere power user.

Being an UNIX where Objective-C and now Swift have the spotlight (with a little space for C++ on IOKit), not C.

Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by vezzy-fnord on Sunday August 16, 2015 @03:40PM (#10069997)
XPC is just a layer on top of Mach IPC. Not very familiar with the app sandbox model, but what exactly would be truly innovative about it?

Being a hybrid kernel barely has any significance when you don't exploit that fact, which XNU doesn't. Also, it's a hybrid of Mach, which is heavily anachronistic and clunky. DragonFly BSD, on the other hand, actually does through the vkernel mechanism.

I have no idea what you mean by the third one. Are you saying that the root user's privileges are segmented into multiple subsystems? POSIX has had capabilities for that. They suck and they're not actual capability-based security, but they do achieve logical privilege segmentation. Plan 9 and Inferno are the only ones from the Unix-ish lineage who successfully got rid of root entirely.

You can write applications targeting any subsystem provided there are bindings, which there are. For instance, Python and Vala are heavily used in contemporary Unix-like DEs for application programming.

Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by pjmlp on Sunday August 16, 2015 @04:14PM (#10070114)
> XPC is just a layer on top of Mach IPC. Not very familiar with the app sandbox model, but what exactly would be truly innovative about it?

It is not part of any POSIX compliant UNIX.

It also pushes developers into a micro-kernel style of application development, which isn't common in UNIX.

> Also, it's a hybrid of Mach, which is heavily anachronistic and clunky. DragonFly BSD, on the other hand, actually does through the vkernel mechanism.

Besides FreeBSD, I admit I hardly know any other BSD.

> I have no idea what you mean by the third one. Are you saying that the root user's privileges are segmented into multiple subsystems?

In El Capitan, you can only be real root in safe mode. In normal mode there are paths (e.g. /bin, /usr/bin,...) and APIs that aren't available even to processes running as root.

> You can write applications targeting any subsystem provided there are bindings, which there are. For instance, Python and Vala are heavily used in contemporary Unix-like DEs for application programming.

There is a big difference in being a first class language used in the vendor SDK and IDE, and a third party one used by some developers.

Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by kitsunesoba on Sunday August 16, 2015 @12:58PM (#10069445)
Honest question: When was the last time MS actually did something interesting in regards to OS features/architecture? I read genuinely neat little tidbits about new features in OS X, Linux, and the BSDs on a fairly regular basis, but I can't remember the last time I read about something like that in Windows. The impression that it leaves is that releases of Windows newer than, say, Vista or 7 bring little outside of general cleanup and tweaks to the user-facing parts.
Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by tomku on Sunday August 16, 2015 @03:08PM (#10069894)
If you want to see internal changes in Windows, look at the server versions, not the desktop ones. Over that time frame where you said nothing happened, Hyper-V has gone from a research project to a central part of the Windows server space. Powershell has gone from a tech preview to the recommended way to manage servers. Windows Server 2012 introduced ReFS and Storage Spaces. I'm sure Server 2016 will have a bunch of cool stuff too. The server-side Windows experience is radically different than it was when Windows 7 came out.

Why aren't you hearing about these features? Lots of reasons. Windows is closed-source, so the internal changes you hear about are the ones Microsoft wants you to hear about. Most of the shiny new toys are to support server features that you won't notice unless you're a Windows sysadmin. Most desktop users don't care about internal changes unless they break things, and Windows hasn't broken much on the internal side since Vista. Microsoft's own messaging about major changes has been targeted almost exclusively at Windows server admins.

Edit: That's not even getting into the new app development platform that shipped with 8/10, DirectX 12 adding Mantle-like APIs, first-class support for touch input, hybrid boot, booting from VHDs, etc. Microsoft has been busy over the past few years.

Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by pjmlp on Sunday August 16, 2015 @02:36PM (#10069805)
The research OS: Singularity, Midori and Drawbridge

The attempts to follow OS/400 footsteps with a managed userspace in Windows Phone 7.

The OS architecture of Windows Phone 8.

The way they are transitioning Windows into a App Container model with the WinRT execution model.

Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by arvinjoar on Sunday August 16, 2015 @08:28AM (#10068727)
And not to forget, OS X, which still has significant market share (>5% of desktops/laptops) and is based on Unix (albeit XNU stands for X is not Unix). Looking at wikipedia, it still seems like a majority of web web clients are windows based, though[1].

[1] = https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usage_share_of_operating_syste...

Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by justwannasing on Sunday August 16, 2015 @08:38AM (#10068747)
OSX is not "based on" Unix. OSX IS Unix: http://www.opengroup.org/openbrand/register/brand3607.htm
Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by justinsaccount on Sunday August 16, 2015 @09:27AM (#10068839)
Is the certification from "The Open Group" relevant to anyone?

OS X 10.10 ships with a version of bash from 2007. Without something like homebrew or macports to install an updated userland the "Unix" core of OS X is rotting away.

Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by tomphoolery on Sunday August 16, 2015 @10:53AM (#10069033)
It just means that the operating system ships with the properly-licensed UNIX software binaries and libraries, rather than the GNU free software replacements for said software. If you look in the man pages for any shell command OS X ships with, you'll see it's from the "BSD General Commands Manual". On Linux systems, this originates from GNU. Your example of bash is actually not part of that distribution, it's something additional OS X ships with just for userland purposes. I suppose the point of being a "certified UNIX distribution" is just so they can put the trademark on their website because it looks pretty.
Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by justinsaccount on Sunday August 16, 2015 @11:34AM (#10069149)
Right.. and the actual BSD stuff is frozen in time as well:

  $ strings `which cp`|grep src
  $FreeBSD: src/bin/cp/utils.c,v 1.46 2005/09/05 04:36:08 csjp Exp $
  $FreeBSD: src/bin/cp/cp.c,v 1.52 2005/09/05 04:36:08 csjp Exp $

  $ strings `which ls`|grep src
  $FreeBSD: src/bin/ls/cmp.c,v 1.12 2002/06/30 05:13:54 obrien Exp $
  $FreeBSD: src/bin/ls/ls.c,v 1.66 2002/09/21 01:28:36 wollman Exp $
  $FreeBSD: src/bin/ls/print.c,v 1.57 2002/08/29 14:29:09 keramida Exp $
  $FreeBSD: src/bin/ls/util.c,v 1.38 2005/06/03 11:05:58 dd Exp $

https://svnweb.freebsd.org/base/head/bin/cp/cp.c?view=log and https://svnweb.freebsd.org/base/head/bin/ls/ls.c?view=log

show various fixes and new features added since then.

  $ strings /bin/* /sbin/* /usr/bin/* /usr/sbin/*|grep ,v
paints a pretty dismal picture.

One interesting way to look at this. The first commit from freebsd for ls.c is:

  Added Thu May 26 06:18:55 1994 UTC (21 years, 2 months ago) by rgrimes
  Original Path: vendor/CSRG/dist/bin/ls/ls.c
  File length: 13099 byte(s)
  BSD 4.4 Lite bin Sources

The last commit apple has is:

  Modified Fri Jun 3 11:05:58 2005 UTC (10 years, 2 months ago) by dd 
So apples version is almost closer in time to the original 4.4 sources as to the current version.
Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by bakul on Sunday August 16, 2015 @12:51PM (#10069411)
string `which ls`|grep src shows cvs strings. FreeBSD switched over to svn a long time ago and cvs id strings are not updated anymore. But svn log ls.c on the head branch shows the last change was on 20-July-2015.

In any case, why keep fiddling with the source code if the program does what it is intended to do?

Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by justinsaccount on Sunday August 23, 2015 @10:53AM (#10105630)
Here's a good example. Came up just the other day.

    $ du -hs big.log;time cat big.log  > /dev/null
    199M	big.log

    real	0m0.045s
    user	0m0.002s
    sys	0m0.043s
    $ time gtr a b < big.log > /dev/null

    real	0m0.334s
    user	0m0.182s
    sys	0m0.142s
    $ time tr a b < big.log > /dev/null

    real	0m33.105s
    user	0m31.757s
    sys	0m0.488s
    $
I don't have a freebsd machine around to see if it's just apples tr that is broken.

I'm sure it's related to unicode bullshit, but the usual env var tricks don't seem to help.

Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by 0x09 on Sunday August 16, 2015 @11:07AM (#10069065)
UNIX is a spec. The point of being a "certified UNIX" is that the system conforms to SUS/POSIX and software developed targeting those specifications and their API are expected to run.

One might question the usefulness of SUS/POSIX in a world where most of the *nix ecosystem targets GNU, but saying it has no purpose beyond advertising is disingenuous.

Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by justinsaccount on Sunday August 16, 2015 @11:44AM (#10069174)
Oh, I think its purpose is to make money for the open group.

I tried to download and run their test suite, but they lead to a page that says "For Purchase Enquiries please contact:"

They don't care about standards, they care about selling things.

Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by justwannasing on Sunday August 16, 2015 @12:49PM (#10069405)
Nothing could be further from the truth. Do you think these tests were created and maintained for free? Do you think the certification process happens on its own? Do you think there is no value in the whole Unix standard is stagnant, none-changing, and never reviewed or updated? And it all happens without cost? Do you think no one pays any attention to that?
Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by justinsaccount on Sunday August 16, 2015 @08:00PM (#10070756)
Don't really understand your reply. Linux and GNU and {free,net,open}bsd are created and maintained "for free". Can things only have value if they cost money?

Is the unix certification only for large companies who can afford to throw money at the open group in order to get certified?

According to the wikipedia page:

> By decree of The Open Group, the term "UNIX" refers more to a class of operating systems than to a specific implementation of an operating system; those operating systems which meet The Open Group's Single UNIX Specification should be able to bear the UNIX 98 or UNIX 03 trademarks today, after the operating system's vendor pays a substantial certification fee and annual trademark royalties

Right.. Please tell me how this is not a meaningless certification? FreeBSD is more unix than OS X, and would likely have no problems running the test suite, but is not certified as "real unix" because that certification is about money.

Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by pjmlp on Sunday August 16, 2015 @12:35PM (#10069354)
Have you ever used a proper commercial UNIX (Aix, HP-UX,...)?

That bash version is actually very modern compared with their out-of-box experience.

Re:Will Unix become the next MS-DOS? (1985) [video] by justinsaccount on Sunday August 16, 2015 @08:09PM (#10070777)
I used to use some solaris boxes, that was always painful.

I knew some sysadmins liked it. There definitely was a mindset of some admins that solaris boxes were great. You did a full install of solaris that took up like 8G of disk space. Then you installed oracle. Then you never touched the machine again. As long as you never actually needed to use the machine for anything, solaris was great.

Solid kernel.. terrible userland. Still some very smart people working on zfs/dtrace/kvm, will be intersting to see what the next few years bring.