News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by superuser2 on Saturday August 15, 2015 @03:07AM (#10064599)
Sobriety is one of the conditions of the social contract you sign (literally, on your license application) in exchange for access to society's roads.

Jail time is not really appropriate. Really, you should just lose access to public roads. But license revocation is adulthood revocation for all but the privileged few in SF, NYC, and maybe Chicago. In most of this country you can't get groceries or primary medical care without driving, and you certainly can't hold a job or provide a normal life for your children. A five-figure fine and even a month or two in jail is many times less severe than permanent loss of driving privileges; that's life-destroying (pretty much your only option is to drop everything and move to a high-cost-of-living area of a high-cost-of-living city to get adequate public transit coverage).

Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by titanomachy on Saturday August 15, 2015 @09:46AM (#10065350)
> license revocation is adulthood revocation for all but the privileged few in SF, NYC, and maybe Chicago

This is almost certainly true in America, but keep in mind that some other societies view driving somewhat differently. America represents less than one twentieth of the world's population. In major European cities, at least, car ownership seems to be the exception rather than the rule.

Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by nmrm2 on Saturday August 15, 2015 @11:09AM (#10065568)
It's not really true in America, either. The (small) European cities I've lived in have far better transit than even major US cities, but any American city with a "greater metro area" population in the millions will have enough public transit that you can survive without a car and without living in an extremely costly area.

It requires some walking and biking, and some employment options do disappear. But most of those employment options are recoverable because the salaries (e.g. at suburban office parks) pay well enough to cover the cost of a cab from the nearest bus stop to the office every morning.

IME the lack of public will to walk a half mile, ride a bike in the rain, or wait ten minutes at a bus stop is by far the greatest barrier to use of public transit in America.

Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by plonh on Saturday August 15, 2015 @11:13AM (#10065577)
Using the word "salary", and talking about paying cabs to drive to buses shows that you ignoring the reality of a huge segment of the working population, who work hourly, and have childcare needs.
Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by nmrm2 on Saturday August 15, 2015 @11:27AM (#10065618)
No, I'm not. I was giving two conditional scenarios, and dismissing the "salary" one precisely because the people you're telling me I'm ignoring are unlikely to work in those locations.

To reiterate:

IF you are not working in an office park off an interstate near an affluent suburb, most mid-sized American cities have enough transit to get by.

IF you are working in an office park off an interstate near an affluent suburb, then you're probably making enough that you can stitch together a combination of public transit and taxis to get to work from a low-rent area.

And yeah, long commutes suck when you're paying for child care. Which is why a lot of people choose a child care facility close to work.

Basically, my point was that I know a lot of Europeans whose commute involves > 1/2 mile of walking. And also a lot of Americans who live in cities that "don't have any public transit" because they have to walk 1/2 - 1 mile to get to a stop that takes them directly to work.

I'm not saying American public transit doesn't need to improve. Just that if Americans always demand door-to-door service, then public transit will never be good enough. And, more over, will always suck because that's an impossible demand.

Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by mikeash on Saturday August 15, 2015 @02:07PM (#10066205)
Car ownership rates in European countries are not vastly lower than in the US. In some, it's actually higher. On average the rate is a bit lower, but it's not anywhere close to "the exception rather than the rule."
Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by scott_karana on Monday August 17, 2015 @01:40PM (#10074740)
Median commuting mileage per capita are higher.[1]

Japan, for example, has reasonably high per-capita car ownership, but the yearly mileage is less than half of US usage.

I think it's reasonable to suspect that the standard deviation in the US is much higher too.

1 https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/ohim/onh00/bar4.htm

Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by gnaritas on Saturday August 15, 2015 @10:39AM (#10065478)
> Sobriety is one of the conditions of the social contract you sign (literally, on your license application) in exchange for access to society's roads.

Travel via the common means is a right, not a privileged; such laws are unjust. That driving requires you make such promises is absurd.

Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by nmrm2 on Saturday August 15, 2015 @11:03AM (#10065551)
> Travel via the common means is a right, not a privilege

Rights aren't unconditional.

> That driving requires you make such promises is absurd.

Here's why driving requires you to make these types of promises:

http://www.who.int/gho/road_safety/mortality/traffic_deaths_...

Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by gnaritas on Saturday August 15, 2015 @11:47AM (#10065680)
> Rights aren't unconditional.

Conditions would make them privileges.

> Here's why driving requires you to make these types of promises

Not relevant, that it's dangerous doesn't change my opinion that it's absurd.

Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by nmrm2 on Saturday August 15, 2015 @12:06PM (#10065743)
> Conditions would make them privileges.

This is a common misunderstanding.

Rights are unconditional is the sense that they apply to everyone equally. But almost all are conditional in the sense that they don't give carte blanc permission without exception.

It might help to think of rights like axioms. (A & (A -> B)) -> B is true unconditionally. It is an axiom. But it is also conditional. It is universally true, and yet, B is not universally true.

Nearly all rights we have are unconditionally conditional in this way. They always apply to everyone (universally), but that doesn't mean there aren't conditions (that get applied universally).

For instance, being convicted of murder triggers conditions on most of the rights we have as citizens. Not all of them, but most.

Privileges are different from rights because they don't have to apply to each person equally in the way rights do. The two are separated by the fact that rights are extended universally and privileges aren't, not by the presence or absence of conditions.

Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by gnaritas on Saturday August 15, 2015 @12:10PM (#10065759)
Yes, I'm aware of that, I'm disagreeing with it as a matter of principle. Just because things are a certain way doesn't require that I accept it. Driving should not require a license and an annual fee to the state; the conditions we've accepted our on rights have destroyed many of our once long held freedoms. It didn't require a license to ride a horse or drive a buggy, licenses are just another way for the state to make money and restrict my right to travel via the common means of the day.

Beyond that, you understand what I'm saying, so rather than try to redefine what I mean when I use a word, how about just understanding my point. We're not in court, I don't need a lesson on the legal meaning of the word right.

Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by nmrm2 on Saturday August 15, 2015 @12:27PM (#10065808)
> you understand what I'm saying

Obviously, I apparently did not.

Therefore:

> I'm disagreeing with it as a matter of principle.

Please don't do that. Redefining words for yourself and then using your secret meanings in discussions is both irritating (because it wastes other commenter's time) and comes off as arrogant (because it demonstrates a clear disregard for other's time and a willful unwillingness to communicate effectively).

If you know something is a Right in the conventional sense even though it has conditions attached, state that you disagree with those conditions. Don't call it "not a right" to make a point. Doing so derails the conversation and wastes other's time.

> licenses are just another way for the state to make money and restrict my right to travel via the common means of the day.

That's obviously not true. You really think your $20 license fee pays for... anything? It's probably not even offsetting the cost of the licensing regime.

And restricting your travel obviously is not the goal of a driver's license. Where did you even get that idea?

"The State" doesn't require licensing because it wants to screw you out of money or keep you down. We, the people, require licensing because driving is dangerous and we don't want idiots to kill us.

> Driving should not require a license and an annual fee to the state

Of course, assuming you live in a democracy, you're free to try to change that.

I think you'll find this an impossible reform because given the danger of driving, licensing is an extremely important first step toward making roads safer.

> It didn't require a license to ride a horse or drive a buggy

Yeah, right, because horses and buggies didn't kill millions of people a year.

As an aside, in almost every state you can still ride horses on most public roads without a license.

Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by gnaritas on Saturday August 15, 2015 @12:38PM (#10065843)
I didn't redefine any words, I used the word in the common sense of the word, you're trying to use it in the legal sense. I made myself clear when I said applying conditions makes it a privilege, if you didn't understand my meaning after that, well then I can't help you, it couldn't have been clearer.

We used to live in a democracy, we now live in a plutocracy, the government hasn't represented the will of the governed in quite a long time, that's why voter turnout is abysmal.

We're done here, we obviously won't come to any agreement.

[dead]
Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by gnaritas on Saturday August 15, 2015 @12:44PM (#10065872)
Well I'm glad you're granted the insight to speak for everyone, you must be so full of yourself it just hurts.

An edit, what you're so brilliant you can't even figure out how to bypass the post time restriction? Do you just run around being pedantic?

Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by dang on Saturday August 15, 2015 @04:31PM (#10066755)
Come on, you know this isn't allowed here, regardless of how provocative or annoying someone else is being.
Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by Dylan16807 on Saturday August 15, 2015 @01:51PM (#10066135)
Are the downvotes not clear enough? Stop being so stubborn about wording and consider arguing your actual point. Don't call names.

I'm curious, how would you feel if unlicensed drivers were limited to 20mph?

Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by gnaritas on Saturday August 15, 2015 @01:52PM (#10066145)
I did, and I'm not the one being stubborn about wording. He's the one being pedantic.
Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by Dylan16807 on Saturday August 15, 2015 @01:55PM (#10066153)
You said it was unjust because it was a right, he explained why it was just, you started the semantics argument with "Conditions would make them privileges." and then when you were proved wrong you started with personal insults.

You didn't even address the argument that "being convicted of murder triggers conditions on most of the rights we have as citizens"...

Edit: 'it' being the very concept of restrictions on rights, not really this particular variety

Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by gnaritas on Saturday August 15, 2015 @02:05PM (#10066193)
No he didn't explain why anything was just, he got pendantic about the meaning of the word right, and no I didn't start the semantics, I clarified my meaning. And I wasn't proven wrong nor did I start with any insults. Read much?

> You didn't even address the argument that "being convicted of murder triggers conditions on most of the rights we have as citizens"...

No, I didn't, because at that point the debate had already turned sour with his pedantics so it wasn't worth addressing as there's no point in continuing such a discussion with someone so anal about every word.

Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by Dylan16807 on Saturday August 15, 2015 @02:07PM (#10066204)
The only argument you have presented is that restrictions on [rights or whatever you call them] are fundamentally wrong. No matter what words you choose to use, he disproved that argument and you have presented no other.
[dead]
Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by Dylan16807 on Saturday August 15, 2015 @02:19PM (#10066254)
The idea that rights can never have restrictions is not an opinion. It is objectively wrong. The old quote about swinging a fist comes to mind.

You can disagree with these restrictions, but you have not presented an argument that's actually focused on driving.

If you really think I'm trolling to explain such a simple thing, I'll leave. Good luck in the future!

Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by gnaritas on Saturday August 15, 2015 @02:37PM (#10066329)
That was not the point being made, the whole focus on what rights meant was him being pedantic and obtuse about what was being said. That was the diversion, that you think it was the main point just shows he ruined the discussion by ignoring the point. Why would I partake in a hijacking of the thread when my comment was about what constituted justice? Don't bother answering, it was rhetorical.
Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by scott_s on Saturday August 15, 2015 @02:39PM (#10066335)
Please stop.
Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by DanBC on Saturday August 15, 2015 @02:05PM (#10066185)
> It didn't require a license to ride a horse or drive a buggy,

Horses were taxed. Carriages were taxed.

http://www.genguide.co.uk/source/taxes-miscellaneous/177/

Etc.

Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by gnaritas on Saturday August 15, 2015 @02:07PM (#10066202)
Taxed != license. No one ever lost their horse riding license.
Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by plonh on Saturday August 15, 2015 @11:10AM (#10065572)
Driving is not the same as traveling . being a passenger is a right.
Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by gnaritas on Saturday August 15, 2015 @11:48AM (#10065682)
Driving is the common means, my point stands.
Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by kwhitefoot on Saturday August 15, 2015 @08:51AM (#10065246)
Fines should be related to one's income. In Finland you can be unlucky enough to be fined a quarter of a million Euros for speeding if your income is high enough, same in Switzerland I think.
Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by charles2013 on Saturday August 15, 2015 @05:40PM (#10067020)
the proliferation of driverless cars could make the debate about losing access to public roads (i.e. losing one's drivers license) much more interesting.
Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by serge2k on Saturday August 15, 2015 @05:34AM (#10064847)
So don't drive drunk.

Oh look, problem solved.

Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by gnaritas on Saturday August 15, 2015 @10:40AM (#10065481)
No, not solved; DUI applies to more than alcohol, the issue isn't so simplistic.