Re:Apes may be closer to speaking than many scientists think
by 1stop on Friday August 14, 2015 @08:18PM
(#10063760)
Then you have changed the point you are making. Intelligence does require communication. You admit that yourself now.
Re:Apes may be closer to speaking than many scientists think
by robotkilla on Friday August 14, 2015 @09:19PM
(#10063930)
>Intelligence does require communication
The claim he made is that people think intelligence requires linguistics - he then goes on to say that aliens may be communicating in some different way that doesn't require linguistics.
At any rate, a number of the arguments made in this thread are absolutely absurd. Of course intelligence doesn't require linguistics - linguistics is merely one of the markers of intelligence.
And of course creatures can communicate without language - it happens in nature every day.
Re:Apes may be closer to speaking than many scientists think
by cscurmudgeon on Friday August 14, 2015 @09:59PM
(#10064025)
Linguistics is about communication. Language is not spoken language. That is the common definition. The absurd comments in this thread are those which confuse communication and linguistics to that involving just sounds.
Maybe we're simply not intelligent enough to realize that our own form of communication is actually very primitive, and a sign of little intelligence, not great intelligence.