Shouldn’t there be some kind of exponential back-off after failures? If after the first 1000 failed keys it would only accept e.g. one new try every few seconds, it would then take 2–3 orders of magnitude more time to brute force.
The attack works by overhearing the exchange between the car and the key fob, and then doing an somewhat brute-force analysis to calculate what the secret key on the fob must have been.
I tried reading the paper (not an expert). In the recommendation section, it does not suggest implementing a delay either. Is it just not physically possible with RFID?
I mean, a 4 digit pin with a 5 second delay would take 14 hours for all combinations (better than the half hour with Megamos)???
I have to be missing something.....It can't be this easy.....
My guess is that they're then doing the brute-forcing "offline", not against the vehicle's system. If you know the algorithm and the keysize, and you can see one successful authentication, you could ship the work of workig out which key replicates the authentication you just saw off to AWS or custom hardware (I wonder how readily Bitcoin mining ASICs can be tweaked to attack embedded or IoT authentication?) (Though it seems there's flaws somewhere in the crypto anyway - they somehow broke a 96bit key with under 2^18 attempts...)
Security is about trade-offs, after all.
Stranded in hostile environment (middle of nowhere in the arctic or a desert) could be a death sentence.
I think a more realistic exploit would be a corrupt tow-truck driver / mechanic targeting an area where tourists stop.
That's true. On the subject of movies, though, a plot point based on an actual vulnerability would be way better than typical Hollywood hacking.
We’re not talking about a website here.
Nope. Just a high-gain antenna.
> Couldn’t the car start blaring an alarm or something in that case?
It could. But that might not help.
For example: you're driving your Mazerati down the road when it suddenly stops and the alarm goes off. The next day you get a letter saying, "If you don't want yesterday's little incident to become a regular event, send BTC500 to the following address...."
I had it happen without me leaving the seat (e.g. my wife has the keys in her bag/pocket, I had been driving, and she gets off the car to unarm the home alarm). The car is turned on by pressing a button, not by turning the key.
You can make up for car thefts with dollars.
So there's no discernible event from the fob, as far as I can see. It's just a "this is me" signal.
You're right, that might be it.
the unlock button was on the fob rather than on the car door
Let me clarify: the fob does have buttons for lock, unlock, panic, and open trunk. But I don't normally use them. My normal usage is as I described: just walk up with the fob in my pocket, and press the button on the door handle.
2 communications isn't much at all. Getting something from your car and locking it back up is all it takes.
Even worse, they get it down to 48 bits.
Only one of those three is the correct answer, and it is the third one.
Your car does not need a wireless network - since you have a newer, nicer one in your pocket every 18 months.
Neither does your refrigerator nor your smoke detector.
These are self-inflicted problems and they're easy to solve - just remove the gratuitous complexity.
Where every single thief had to be a skilled lockpicker before, now you just need a few specialized crackers and then you can mass-produce user-friendly hacking devices or even downloadable software.
Where a thief had to spend several minutes in a compromising pose near the car, often carrying suspicious tools, now he can just sit on a bench nearby, wait for the magic click and then choose the right moment to stroll in. A passerby might as well think he's the owner.
A couple of weeks ago I saw someone using a slimjim, and I did nothing. I have never done anything in reaction to a car alarm. I'm not sure that thief's pose is sufficiently compromising.
Mechanical locks imply that each individual thief needs to learn how pick locks. With computerized locks, you only need one hacker to crack the security for each model of car, and then a bunch of two-dime thugs will only need to download the app and get going in with the car-thief franchise.
It'll be interesting to watch the fallout from these obviously-present vulnerabilities. I see three possible outcomes, in decreasing order of likelihood: status quo, where they just "fix" the bugs as they hit the news; some sort of massive push towards real computer security, in this and other industries; or a massive reduction in features to avoid the flaws.
This is really just another symptom of the current state of computer security, best described as "a joke." My guess is in 50 years we'll have decent computer security. There's nothing that precludes it in theory. But it's going to be an ugly, ugly couple of decades while we pay off the wave of computer-security-debt that we have been riding.