News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:VW Has Spent Two Years Trying to Hide a Big Security Flaw by danielweber on Friday August 14, 2015 @12:03PM (#10060876)
The article isn't about people remotely taking over cars or disabling cars. It's that the anti-theft system has a flaw. That's not nothing, but it doesn't put anyone's safety at risk.
Re:VW Has Spent Two Years Trying to Hide a Big Security Flaw by AnimalMuppet on Friday August 14, 2015 @01:27PM (#10061436)
In particular, it's not necessarily worse than the status quo ante. Cars had mechanical locks, which were pickable. A "slim jim" could unlock many cars. Once you were in the door, you could hotwire the ignition. So to be able to defeat a computerized anti-theft system... no gain from the computerization, but is there any loss from it?
Re:VW Has Spent Two Years Trying to Hide a Big Security Flaw by toyg on Friday August 14, 2015 @02:21PM (#10061835)
The difference is that physical attacks require 1) individual skills and 2) prolonged physical contact in compromising pose.

Where every single thief had to be a skilled lockpicker before, now you just need a few specialized crackers and then you can mass-produce user-friendly hacking devices or even downloadable software.

Where a thief had to spend several minutes in a compromising pose near the car, often carrying suspicious tools, now he can just sit on a bench nearby, wait for the magic click and then choose the right moment to stroll in. A passerby might as well think he's the owner.

Re:VW Has Spent Two Years Trying to Hide a Big Security Flaw by CWuestefeld on Friday August 14, 2015 @03:42PM (#10062413)
a thief had to spend several minutes in a compromising pose near the car

A couple of weeks ago I saw someone using a slimjim, and I did nothing. I have never done anything in reaction to a car alarm. I'm not sure that thief's pose is sufficiently compromising.

Re:VW Has Spent Two Years Trying to Hide a Big Security Flaw by JoBrad on Friday August 14, 2015 @02:39PM (#10061982)
Exactly. And it's insanely easy to physically break into a car. If you have the chance, watch a pop-a-lock guy. They essentially bend your car door backward at the upper portion, and then stick something into your car to pull the lock up. Not difficult.
Re:VW Has Spent Two Years Trying to Hide a Big Security Flaw by spdionis on Friday August 14, 2015 @01:37PM (#10061503)
No gain implying that lockpicking a car and hacking it is of the same level of difficulty.
Re:VW Has Spent Two Years Trying to Hide a Big Security Flaw by crpatino on Friday August 14, 2015 @01:45PM (#10061557)
Its not a matter of difficulty, but of reproducibility.

Mechanical locks imply that each individual thief needs to learn how pick locks. With computerized locks, you only need one hacker to crack the security for each model of car, and then a bunch of two-dime thugs will only need to download the app and get going in with the car-thief franchise.

Re:VW Has Spent Two Years Trying to Hide a Big Security Flaw by AnimalMuppet on Friday August 14, 2015 @01:40PM (#10061522)
True, and they probably aren't. So which do you think is harder?