News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by hippo8 on Thursday August 13, 2015 @07:05AM (#10053316)
Can someone explain why oracle is doing this? This is not good for their brand name, this is not good for Java. A large number of people use Java because of android app development, what is oracle trying to gain out of all this?
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by andyjohnson0 on Thursday August 13, 2015 @07:34AM (#10053404)
Almost anyone who cares about this lawsuit is automatically someone whose opinions don't matter to Oracle. Oracle only cares about executives at large orgs with large budgets to spend on Oracle's enterprise software. And those people don't care about Java or Oracle's reputation among people outside their community.

To understand Oracle's motivations it is necessary to review what Bryan Cantrill said about the company:

"As you know people, as you learn about things, you realize that these generalizations we have are, virtually to a generalization, false. Well, except for this one, as it turns out. What you think of Oracle, is even truer than you think it is. There has been no entity in human history with less complexity or nuance to it than Oracle. And I gotta say, as someone who has seen that complexity for my entire life, it’s very hard to get used to that idea. It’s like, ‘surely this is more complicated!’ but it’s like: Wow, this is really simple! This company is very straightforward, in its defense. This company is about one man, his alter-ego, and what he wants to inflict upon humanity — that’s it! …Ship mediocrity, inflict misery, lie our asses off, screw our customers, and make a whole shitload of money. Yeah… you talk to Oracle, it’s like, ‘no, we don’t fucking make dreams happen — we make money!’ …You need to think of Larry Ellison the way you think of a lawnmower. You don’t anthropomorphize your lawnmower, the lawnmower just mows the lawn, you stick your hand in there and it’ll chop it off, the end. You don’t think ‘oh, the lawnmower hates me’ — lawnmower doesn’t give a shit about you, lawnmower can’t hate you. Don’t anthropomorphize the lawnmower. Don’t fall into that trap about Oracle." [1]

Nothing that Oracle does makes sense without understanding this.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-zRN7XLCRhc&t=33m

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by simi_ on Thursday August 13, 2015 @07:38AM (#10053415)
For me this just puts into perspective how much it sucks to have Java as the language powering Android. Would a rewrite in (say) Go even be possible? I guess you could machine translate a lot of boring stuff like support for a gazillion devices, and the memory footprint savings would be quite substantial.
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by bad_user on Thursday August 13, 2015 @07:51AM (#10053455)
Oracle tried their hand with copyright infringement, because copyright is far stronger than anything else that's IP-related. However, here's the thing:

1. Oracle is basically arguing about APIs being copyrightable and if APIs are deemed to be copyrightable, we're fucked as an industry ;-)

2. Oracle, because of the Sun acquisition, has many, many interesting patents related to programming languages and virtual machines. Consider that Sun was involved in the research for making Smaltalk VMs fast and they also developed Self. The IP for all the fancy techniques used in Java's HotSpot VM? Well Sun owned it. Do you think Go is safe because it's not based on Java, or because it doesn't have a Java-like VM? Think again, at the very least it has a garbage collector ;-)

Thing is, if Google would have cloned OpenJDK, they would have been safe because of the GPL license. But they didn't, they used Apache Harmony instead, a project that never passed the Java TCK because Sun never allowed it to.

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by noir_lord on Thursday August 13, 2015 @09:34AM (#10054001)
> 1. Oracle is basically arguing about APIs being copyrightable and if APIs are deemed to be copyrightable, we're fucked as an industry ;-)

In the US, in Europe where we are somewhat more sane on this issue I'd look forward to a boom in software development the like of which we've never seen.

The implications for the US software industry are pretty horrify though, it makes software patents look mild.

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by fauigerzigerk on Thursday August 13, 2015 @10:42AM (#10054542)
Why a boom in software development?
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by toyg on Thursday August 13, 2015 @10:56AM (#10054653)
parent thinks the industry will flee to safer European shores, because the local legal climate is much more liberal than the US when it comes to software (for example, patent trolls are very rare over here).

In practice this is unlikely for a number of reasons, in particular the fact that Europe is way too expensive for the industry that spearheaded third-world "offshoring".

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by fauigerzigerk on Thursday August 13, 2015 @11:24AM (#10054896)
It's not just unlikely, it's completely nonsensical from a legal perspective. If Google's Android division were located in Europe, that would make zero difference for their legal fight against Oracle.

The only way to avoid US law is to not trade in the US at all, otherwise someone should have told Samsung and SAP before they paid hundereds of millions to Apple and Oracle respectively.

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by noir_lord on Thursday August 13, 2015 @11:16AM (#10054825)
That would be the case except if you where a US software company fleeing a legislative climate that made it hard to do business are you going to put your HQ/major business units in Berlin/Paris or a third-world country.

These are large primarily sales driven organizations so first world transport links and infrastructure matter.

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by mikekchar on Thursday August 13, 2015 @09:50AM (#10054115)
I always think is is somewhat interesting given the Java trap [1]. In some ways RMS was very prescient (not entirely surprising), but had Sun not released Java under the GPL, we could easily be having this discussion about IceTea.

The "Don't be ridiculous, nobody is going to sue you for using/implementing Java/C#/whatever" attitude was always frustrating, but I have to admit I didn't actually expect it to really happen :-P

[1] http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/java-trap.en.html

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by throwawaykf05 on Thursday August 13, 2015 @09:59AM (#10054188)
APIs are pretty much confirmed to be copyrightable, as far as I can tell. The SC denying cert to review this appeal essentially confirms the Federal Circuit's interpretation. All that is left is to decide on fair use, which could still let Google off, but that defense assumes copyrightability.

But I disagree "we're fucked as an industry", though there could be some inconvenience. The Sega etc. cases still hold, and they essentially say that copying interfaces for binary compatibility / interoperability is fine. As far as statically compiled languages are concerned, that's all we need. If some API creator sues, we can always create / adopt a different API and map it to the binary instructions in the SPI.

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by tzs on Thursday August 13, 2015 @11:26AM (#10054913)
As far as I've been able to tell, the Federal Circuit's decision sets no precedent. It is only binding on the trial court in this particular case.

Their decisions on patents set precedent, but for copyright they are supposed to follow the precedent of the numbered circuit that the trial court is in, which would be the 9th in this case. Future copyright cases in the 9th will still be appealed to the 9th Circuit, not the Federal Circuit, unless they are also a patent case.

I think there needs to be a change to the way appeals work in cases like this. In federal trial courts, there is a thing called supplemental jurisdiction which allows a court to hear claims that they would normally not have subject matter jurisdiction to hear if they are part of a case with other claims that they do have jurisdiction to hear.

For example, suppose a business deal goes bad, and ends up spawning a lawsuit involving federal copyright claims and state contract claims. Copyright claims must be heard in federal court. Federal courts normally would not have jurisdiction to hear state contract cases, but because of supplemental jurisdiction the federal court will hear the state contract claims too. If the case was just a state contract case, it could not be brought in federal court.

The idea behind supplemental jurisdiction is that in case like my hypothetical business deal gone bad it really is one case that just happened to generate issues that fell under different jurisdictions. If tried separately there would be much overlap in witnesses, documents, and other evidence. It would be an inefficient use of judicial resources and unduly burdensome on the parties and the witnesses.

At the appellate level, the court is examining the trial court's application of the law, not the trial court's determination of the facts. The appeals court works off the transcript and documents from the trial court, and the only people that have to appear physically are the lawyers arguing for the parties.

I think it would make a more sense to let appeals from multi-issue cases to go to multiple appeals courts, each appeals court only getting those issues for which it sets precedent. So in a case like Oracle vs. Google, tried in the 9th Circuit, copyright issue appeals should go to the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, and patent issue appeals should go to the Federal Circuit. In cases like my hypothetical copyright and state contract case, if tried in the 9th Circuit, appeals on copyright issues should go to the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, and state contract issues should go to a state appellate court.

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by Oletros on Thursday August 13, 2015 @07:59AM (#10053481)
Oracle failed to assert any patent related to virtual machines
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by dozzie on Thursday August 13, 2015 @08:02AM (#10053495)
> Think again, at the very least it has a garbage collector ;-)

...which was not invented by Sun. GC is like twenty years older.

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by bliti on Thursday August 13, 2015 @07:57AM (#10053473)
Was openjdk a feasible option at the time?
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by pakled_engineer on Thursday August 13, 2015 @08:14AM (#10053532)
Yes but Android's policy is avoid GPL whenever possible, which is why they rewrote their own Dm-crypt mod and other standard tools also Oracle already tried and failed to sue over Android http://www.infoworld.com/article/2615512/java/open-source-ja... (2012 article)
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by jsingleton on Thursday August 13, 2015 @10:04AM (#10054241)
It's not just Android. Google is a massive Java shop and a lot of their stuff is written in it. They have plenty of Java expertise in all areas.

It's also the main language taught at universities, which helps with hiring. I've heard that Google's public use of Python is more for PR. If you want to change this then the way is to change what educators are teaching.

Java is probably one of the reasons why they acquired Android. Possibly even one of the reasons Android is written in Java.

I once knew a senior Java architect who turned down a job at Google. This was back in the "who needs another Yahoo!" days. Needless to say they regretted that decision.

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by aikah on Thursday August 13, 2015 @09:45AM (#10054076)
> Would a rewrite in (say) Go even be possible?

The problem isn't rewriting Dalvik in Go or language X,Y,Z.The problem is the APIs used by Google -- and Oracle copyright claims on them.

Furthermore Dalvik supports most languages of the JVM so do you really want to impose a single language in place of Java, Clojure, Kotlin, Scala, Jruby, Jython and many more ? do you think all the programmers using these languages would be happy if forced to migrate to Go ?

Ask yourself that question.

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by drivingmenuts on Thursday August 13, 2015 @11:00AM (#10054681)
They probably wouldn't but then again, they're taunting the lawnmower (mentioned above) and seem to forget that the lawnmower has a lot of money and willpower.

I'd say it's time they dumped that lawnmower and came up with something to replace it.

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by aikah on Thursday August 13, 2015 @11:56AM (#10055126)
They also had the money to buy Sun Microsystems , they didn't. They had the money to use something else than Java on Android , they didn't. They're not going to move to Go, they'll just pay and make a deal if Oracle wins.
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by fauigerzigerk on Thursday August 13, 2015 @11:06AM (#10054743)
Is it really more difficult to compile to Go source code than to Dalvik/ART byte code? Using Go as a compilation target would allow other languages to benefit from structured value types and goroutines.
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by aikah on Thursday August 13, 2015 @11:52AM (#10055090)
> Is it really more difficult to compile to Go source code

And who's going to write a Java/Clojure/Scala/Jyton/JRuby/Kotlin/ to Go compiler ? when Google couldn't even write their own language for the android plateform at first place ?

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by fauigerzigerk on Thursday August 13, 2015 @03:51PM (#10056764)
If a platform is popular, language creators will want their languages to run on it, especially if that platform solves some of the problems the old platform has (like excessive memory consumption in the case of Java).

Rich Hickey has complained about the lack of composite value types for instance, and I can imagine that many language creators would love to use green threads based concurrency without actually having to write the low level code for it.

Go is a minimalist language. Many people want more sophisticated type systems and other modern features. So there's a great opportunity for other languages to stand out without having to compete with Go itself. Every time Java adds some functional programming support, the Scala community has to defend its raison d'etre. There would be no such issues with Go and that alone would be a real incentive for language designers to put work into a compiler.

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by aikah on Thursday August 13, 2015 @11:00PM (#10058401)
> There would be no such issues with Go and that alone would be a real incentive for language designers to put work into a compiler.

I don't know what you're talking about.

You can use Go to write android apps already so let the people that like other languages already supported by Android do the same. Nobody's going to rewrite Java or Scala in Go. As I said earlier, if Google wanted to do that it would have done that 5 years ago. They are clearly not interested in betting all their mobile strategy on a niche language.

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by fauigerzigerk on Friday August 14, 2015 @04:14AM (#10059108)
I'm not saying it is going to happen or that it has no drawbacks. What I'm saying is that Go has some benefits as a compilation target.

And no, you can not write Android SDK apps entirely in Go today. What you can do is write a library or command line tool and call it from a Java app.

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by bliti on Thursday August 13, 2015 @07:55AM (#10053466)
Main issue is making people move away from one language to another. You'd have to let people use their existing code base with the new language (like apple did with swift). Could it be possible without another similar lawsuit?
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by simi_ on Thursday August 13, 2015 @07:58AM (#10053478)
Call them "legacy apps" and run them over a compatibility layer. Hardware will gradually get good enough to run the old Java apps without hiccups, and the apps that get translated to Go will run about as fast as the Java-Android versions [citation needed], but with oodles of memory to spare.
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by toyg on Thursday August 13, 2015 @08:17AM (#10053538)
if the API is copyrightable, your "compatibility layer" would also infringe.
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by userbinator on Thursday August 13, 2015 @11:08AM (#10054759)
Nicely summed up as "ORACLE: One Rich Asshole Called Larry Ellison."
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by rjbwork on Thursday August 13, 2015 @07:08AM (#10053323)
Money, market exclusivity. Oracle is a big, dumb, litigious beast that pursues IP and money at the exclusion of everything else. See the Solaris/OpenSolaris/Illumous situation, and anyone who has ever worked somewhere with big Oracle databases.
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by creshal on Thursday August 13, 2015 @07:23AM (#10053374)
And their CSO's attitude towards security: https://archive.is/iz4H2
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by quarterto on Thursday August 13, 2015 @07:10AM (#10053341)
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by modoc on Thursday August 13, 2015 @07:54AM (#10053464)
I could go on for hours about the myriad ways Oracle keeps shooting themselves in the foot with amazingly short sighted policies. However, Larry Ellison is hanging out on a yacht many times larger than any house I'll ever own, so really I guess they aren't that dumb....
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by scrollaway on Thursday August 13, 2015 @07:57AM (#10053476)
> However, Larry Ellison is hanging out on a yacht many times larger than any house I'll ever own, so really I guess they aren't that dumb....

If the CEO's money is a metric in measuring this, maybe. But maybe that's also what's wrong with that attitude.

Contrived example: "Yes, the guy did rape and murder 7 little girls, but he's also taking champagne baths in a tub larger than the city I live in, so he has to be doing something right".

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by modoc on Thursday August 13, 2015 @08:13AM (#10053530)
I guess my point is that I can arm-chair quarterback all I want, but their business doesn't seem to end up hurt by their tactics (which look self-destructive to me), so perhaps my view is not 100% accurate.
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by scrollaway on Thursday August 13, 2015 @08:33AM (#10053612)
And my point is that you can make more money than god and still be evil and your existence be a net negative on the world. I don't think we should judge them by the money they make.
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by rayiner on Thursday August 13, 2015 @09:15AM (#10053890)
Oracle has had a really fundamental impact on databases, being one of the first relational DBs and the first one in widespread use. I think it'd take a lot more than suing Google over Android to make Elison a "net negative" to the world. It's like Google Seach. Google could launch a bullshit patent war against Facebook to help Google+, but the negative effect of that wouldn't outweigh the positive contribution of Google Search.

I note this not to defend Oracle so much as point out that the history of computing is long and a lot of important stuff happened before this latest Android/Twitter/Facebook era.

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by modoc on Thursday August 13, 2015 @08:51AM (#10053726)
I guess we're talking cross-purpose. I'm not trying to say Oracle is "good" or "evil" or weigh in on their moral value to the world. I'm just pointing out that business decisions they make, that seem to be illogical or self-harming, never appear to actually harm their overall business long term.
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by krisgenre on Thursday August 13, 2015 @09:49AM (#10054103)
I think the point was that he earned his money with the business he's doing. In your analogy, the person did not earn by raping, they are two different things.
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by pas on Thursday August 13, 2015 @11:03AM (#10054722)
There are unethical business practices too. Sure, maybe every decision Larry/Oracle every did was legal, they are still in the business of vendor lock-in based extortion aided by their reputation as the transaction processing vendor. Because early on they teamed up. A great salesman with a brilliant software engineer guy.
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by FilterSweep on Thursday August 13, 2015 @09:56AM (#10054172)
Your example is spot-on, but unfortunately that is the way America works in 2015. :ED: to clarify, they are not held to the same accountability standard as we are.
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by toyg on Thursday August 13, 2015 @08:37AM (#10053645)
The Oracle/Sun perspective (let's not forget that the whole argument predates the acquisition, although it hadn't reached the court yet) is that Google "stole" Java and should pay something for it. They want a piece of the Android action, preferably a lot of money.

In order to do that, in pure Ellison style, they will use any tactic, no matter how ruthless or disparaging. Ellison does not care about style or manners, he only cares about winning and cashing in; in many ways he's very similar to his great friend Jobs (who did not care about anything but his products, basically).

(Not that Google comes out squeaky-clean, from all this. They clearly piggybacked on the java ecosystem while explicitly avoiding to grant any attribution...)

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by Zigurd on Thursday August 13, 2015 @09:15AM (#10053889)
There is no Java inside an Android handset. Dalvik isn't Java. Dalvik bytecode isn't Java. The two Android runtimes have similar semantics to Java, but there is no Java technology in either one. There is no JavaCompiler API in Android.

Google "uses" Java in the toolchain, for some definition of "use." But They don't sell anyone any Java. It will be tough sledding for anyone trying to show there is Java IP inside Android.

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by toyg on Thursday August 13, 2015 @10:18AM (#10054362)
> Dalvik isn't Java. Dalvik bytecode isn't Java.

... but all apps are "written in Java", in practice, and one could argue that Android would not have obtained such a large ecosystem without this play. This is all but admitted in Google emails from the Sun days. Whether this means Google has to somehow credit Oracle/Sun, it's for the courts to decide, and as of now, the score is 1-1, so not really clear-cut.

> It will be tough sledding for anyone trying to show there is Java IP inside Android.

This has already been considered in the original trial and the appeal. IIRC, a few secondary files were reused or copied verbatim at some point; regardless, Oracle's position is that the API itself is copyrightable, and as such any implementation has to acknowledge the original rights.

(Note: I don't think Oracle should win, I just acknowledge that neither party really has any higher ground, moral or otherwise.)

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by Zigurd on Thursday August 13, 2015 @11:20AM (#10054862)
> "but all apps are "written in Java", in practice"

That's not strictly true. And if it is or not, it can't be relevant. If you take a JVM language like Scala, compile it to Java bytecode, and run it on a Java(tm) runtime you downloaded from oracle.com, does Oracle have any IP rights in Scala? In the toolchain? In your code?

What if you wrote it in Java? Same answers.

What if you translate that code to Dalvik bytecodes? Same answers.

When I say "There is no Java in Android" I mean the runtime in Android is not Java. Everything else is code that was written in Java and translated to Dalvik and runs in those runtimes that are themselves not Java.

So either Oracle has IP rights all over the place, in everything that is in source code that a Java compiler compiles, or that at some point in the toolchain is in Java bytecode, including stuff like Scala, or not.

Google, and Android, make and sell none of the things in which Orcale has plausible IP rights.

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by toyg on Thursday August 13, 2015 @12:03PM (#10055185)
> it can't be relevant

That's what the courts have been asked to decide. You can argue with me until we're both dead and this will not change.

> If you take a JVM language like Scala, compile it to Java bytecode, and run it on a Java(tm) runtime you downloaded from oracle.com, does Oracle have any IP rights in Scala?

No. But if you build a like-for-like JVM exposing the same API calls as the official runtime, Oracle's position is that you are infringing their IP rights (unless you do stuff for binary compatibility and yadda-yadda-Sega), since your are "copying" the "intellectual work" that the API design is.

At least one court agreed with them, and the US Supreme Court "refused to disagree", so it can't be so out-of-this-world as a concept.

Say you design a language called Foobar, and build a great runtime for it. It gets wildly popular and you even release it as GPL. Google decides that it really likes the language, and really needs all those developers who use it, but "screw you and screw the GPL": they implement a brand new runtime that will run your Foobar programs mostly unchanged. They refuse to acknowledge any of your work and will not work with you on anything -- it's not Foobar anymore, it's "Googlebaz".

Wouldn't you be a bit pissed off? Isn't that actually copying stuff?

Unfortunately, this sort of "emulation" is often necessary in our industry, and for the best of reasons; now, just because Google acted like total assholes (note how they made their choice when Sun was still alive -- I strongly doubt they would have done it with Ellison on the other side), we risk losing the right to it.

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by Zigurd on Thursday August 13, 2015 @12:20PM (#10055312)
The only APIs called from Java are implemented in Java, even if they are just a layer over a JNI. So the questions about Oracle having IP rights in those implementations are the same as for other software.

How did Google act like assholes? Android has the same Apache license as the base class and other library implementations they used, which had been open source for many years at that time.

I am not assuming the answer to what's being litigated. I am pointing out that if Oracle has an IP interest in something inside an Android device, it also has exceptionally dangerous and disruptive IP claims all over the place, including things like Scala and all code written in the Java language.

Regarding your example about runtime environments: No, I don't see how inventing a language, which is generally not protectable, and someone inventing a different runtime for a language should make anyone think their IP has been ripped off.

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by throwawaykf05 on Friday August 14, 2015 @09:50AM (#10060081)
1. Sure, Google could have chosen Scala for Android dev and removed any trace of the Java API. But they didn't. Ask yourself why.

2. As was noted in various trials (Oracle, MS antitrust) "Java" is not one thing, it's multiple. It can refer to the language, the dev environment, the runtime or the API. This case is specifically about the API. Similarly, Android is not just the software that runs on the handset, it also includes the dev environment needed to make that software.

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by throwawaykf05 on Thursday August 13, 2015 @09:43AM (#10054067)
You certainly write Android apps using the Java API, which is Sun/Oracle IP. The argument there is no "real" Java in Android actually hurts Google's case. Because Dalvik uses non-Java byte code, these apps are not interoperable with "real" Java apps. This completely undermines some of Google's legal arguments as a defense for API copyrightability, because the cases they cited (Sega etc) explicitly held that copying certain things was OK for maintaining binary interoperability.
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by Zigurd on Thursday August 13, 2015 @09:56AM (#10054169)
> "You certainly write Android apps using the Java API"

So Oracle should go after Eclipse and other IDEs? Or Apache Harmony?

> *" This completely undermines some of Google's legal arguments as a defense for API copyrightability, because the cases they cited (Sega etc) explicitly held that copying certain things was OK for maintaining binary interoperability."

That binary compatibility is required by javac, which is in the toolchain. Then the Java bytecode gets translated to Dalvik bytecode and packaged as an APK.

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by throwawaykf05 on Friday August 14, 2015 @09:36AM (#10060013)
Oracle can go after who ever they want as long as the law allows them to. I don't see how they can target IDEs, though. IDEs don't provide the Java API.

One way translation of byte code is not interoperability. Android apps cannot interoperate with "real" Java apps.

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by dragonwriter on Thursday August 13, 2015 @09:46AM (#10054081)
They are trying to get control of and/or money from Android, as well as prevent other people from creating similar Java-alike but not Java-by-Oracle's-terms platforms.
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by vbezhenar on Thursday August 13, 2015 @07:08AM (#10053328)
I guess that's their way to monetize Java.
Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by throwawaykf05 on Thursday August 13, 2015 @09:49AM (#10054107)
While some people may use Java "because Android", rest assured that far, far more people do Android development "because Java". The reason Google chose Android was clearly because they needed a large number of people writing many apps as quickly as possible for their platform to compete with the iPhone.

Google got a much better deal out of Java. Sun/Oracle got nothing in return.

Re:Oracle Adds New Android Versions to Copyright Battle with... by Oletros on Monday August 17, 2015 @07:06AM (#10072309)
> they needed a large number of people writing many apps as quickly as possible for their platform to compete with the iPhone.

Android was bought before the iPhone existed