News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by JeremyMorgan on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @11:53AM (#10048410)
It's likely they felt it's not worth the time since most Linux users are using the CLI for everything else, and likely wouldn't be interested in a GUI. Personally I've never used the Github GUI and have no plans to, running the commands is fast and easy.
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by zxcvcxz on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @12:10PM (#10048558)
I think it's a myth that Linux users aren't interested in GUI tools. According to stack overflow statistics, Ubuntu is the most popular Linux based OS amongst developers, which is an OS that is much more GUI based than say Arch linux.

According to the same stats, Linux and OS X usage is statistically tied at ~21%. If you take into account the fact that only about 2% of computer users run Linux at all it's pretty clear that programmers disproportionately prefer Linux (and to a lesser extent OS X) to other systems.

I personally have already moved away from github, but I still wish they would build some tools that work on Linux.

Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by chimeracoder on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @08:45PM (#10051691)
Let me preface this by saying that I am a full-time Linux user and have been for several years. I run Debian on my laptop and Arch Linux on my home machine. Both use i3 (no DE), and I do all my work at the command line or in applications that I launch from the command line[0]. I love the Linux terminal. I don't even own a non-Linux machine, not counting the various OS X devices I've used at work when one is required.

> I think it's a myth that Linux users aren't interested in GUI tools.

It's definitely a myth, and a very dangerous and self-fulfilling one. I would strongly appreciate a GUI option for many common command-line tools. I like the command-line, and do most of my work there. But sometimes GUI tools are nice to have. The problem is that most GUI tools on Linux really suck, and most Linux tools don't even have a GUI at all[1]. Contrary to popular belief, it's not due to the inadequacy of GUI toolkits on Linux, but simply due to a lack of time actually spent developing these tools.

This ends up being self-fulfilling, because it raises the barrier to getting started on Linux, which keeps out people who would be otherwise very comfortable on Linux as an OS, but simply dislike being forced to use the command-line exclusively.

[0] Never bothered with dmenu, never really felt the need to set it up.

[1] I'm not counting ncurses-based interfaces as GUIs for these purposes.

Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by yhager on Friday August 14, 2015 @09:20PM (#10063935)
> I am a full-time Linux user and have been for several years. I run Debian on my laptop and Arch Linux on my home machine. Both use i3 (no DE), and I do all my work at the command line or in applications that I launch from the command line[0]. I love the Linux terminal. I don't even own a non-Linux machine, not counting the various OS X devices I've used at work when one is required.

Wow, that's exactly my case as well :). I could've written this, almost word for word (except I run debian on my servers, and archlinux on my laptop/home machines).

Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by ryanlol on Thursday August 13, 2015 @08:49AM (#10053716)
I for one feel very uncomfortable using other OSes due to the lack of text UIs. And it seems pretty likely that a vast majority of linux devs feel similarly, considering how few softwares start out with just a GUI instead of the other way around.
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by etwigg on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @02:14PM (#10049565)
Shameless plug: I recently built a new linux GUI git client. The people who use it really like it. Still working on docs to better explain what makes it different. Like GitHub's client, it's more than just a wrapper around the CLI, but unlike GitHub's client it exposes git's full power (tags, cherry-pick, rebase, etc.) If you'd like to try a new linux gui client, give it a spin!

Video in action: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X4UQpGk1Ry8

Free download Win/Mac/Linux: https://secure.diffplug.com/versions/1.6.1

Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by zamalek on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @06:57PM (#10051314)
Your diffing doesn't suck! That alone is really valuable. What really sucks on Windows is merging: there are very few products that deal with merging at a basic competency level (the git merge markers usually wreak havoc).

One criticism: that jgit tab needs a serious UX pass. It's extremely scary looking to someone who has never used it (me).

That being said, I'll be keeping a very close eye on your kickstarter. Very close.

Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by etwigg on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @07:46PM (#10051506)
Thanks for the feedback! On the spectrum from "iOS" to "airplane cockpit", I think GitHub is trying to be iPhone, but I think git has enough inherent power (like an aircraft) that you leave a lot of functionality on the table if you constrain yourself to a "no training required" interface. It's certainly something to aspire to, though! If there's anyone out there who thinks they can clean this up, I'm always looking for partners :) Based in SF, open to remote collaboration, contact info in my profile.

The differ / merge resolution story is gonna get a whole lot better real soon.

Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by Nux on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @02:19PM (#10049592)
You should publish some screenshots of it.
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by etwigg on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @02:30PM (#10049678)
100% agree! Was hoping to have the full manual done today, but it's not ready yet. Kinda worked out - I'll spend today ducking as the GitHub goliath whooshes over me for HN readership's attention ;-).

The rest of the product's docs are complete and full of screenshots:

https://docs.diffplug.com/1.6.1/ViewerDiffers/TextViewerDiff...

so the git client will be too. This client animates changes to the DAG, so I'm experimenting with animated gifs so that the manual can capture the feel of using it.

Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by craigds on Thursday August 13, 2015 @01:07AM (#10052350)
I don't think it's a myth, but it definitely is self-fulfilling (since it puts off users who would otherwise use Linux, but don't because they don't want to exclusively use the CLI)

Personally I use a mac nowadays but still use and prefer the command line for this kind of thing. I tried using Github for Mac but quickly gave up the first time I had to do something vaguely complicated.

I guess I'm still a linux person at heart - you can tell if you prefer to 'brew install everything and have never actually used the App Store except to install Xcode :)

Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by girvo on Thursday August 13, 2015 @04:14AM (#10052800)
My discovery of `brew cask`[0] has meant that the App Store is avoided at nearly all cost. I'm a Linux user at heart, too -- one of the only reasons I use OS X is that it feels like "Unix, but with nice powerful GUI apps as well"!

[0] http://caskroom.io/

Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by JeremyMorgan on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @05:00PM (#10050580)
I wouldn't try to speak for everyone who uses Linux of course, it's just been my observation. With my "roots" in computing being in the command line driven 80s, I still feel way better using command line stuff and likely will never change. It doesn't mean I am opposed to GUIs in general, there are certainly things I would never consider doing from a command line, but git isn't one of them.
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by vinay427 on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @12:11PM (#10048562)
The problem with this attitude is that it makes it far more difficult for Linux distros to gain more varied users. Specifically those who are new to development, or (not really relevant in this case) not developers at all. Instead of pointing to a CLI for everything, which I personally love and support for what it is, it might be worth encouraging companies to develop more cross-platform software that allows for a choice of operating system without many sacrifices.
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by JeremyMorgan on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @05:03PM (#10050595)
I agree 100%. More GUI tools will most certainly attract more people to Linux and something that shouldn't be overlooked. For the record I was just guessing the reasoning GitHub overlooked it, there could be other reasons I'm unaware of.
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by em3rgent0rdr on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @01:30PM (#10049230)
It's rather embarrassing that github would consider it too difficult or too troublesome to release Linux builds. Very insulting towards a huge chunk of its user base.

Regarding GUI, how do you initiate a pull request on the command line?

Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by joshuacc on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @04:37PM (#10050455)
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by em3rgent0rdr on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @05:47PM (#10050875)
thanks.
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by enraged_camel on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @04:21PM (#10050353)
"Embarrassing"? "Insulting"?

Aren't you taking this a little too personally? I mean, it's a software release for christs sake.

Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by em3rgent0rdr on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @05:35PM (#10050786)
It demonstrates a lack of concern/acknowledgement of the diversity of its user base. Especially if they are going to be promoting this on the front page of their website and in my dashboard upon login, which presents me with the broadcast:

"GitHub Desktop is now available The new GitHub Desktop is now available"

And then I click on it to install it, I feel marginalized and hence a little insulted, when discovering I can't.

In this day, there are a great variety of cross-platform gui toolkits (e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_platform-independent_G...), that could have been used. It is embarrassing for such a large organisation with all sorts of users using all sorts of machines to not release cross-platform tools. It if was just someone's personal project, or if it was a company's specialized toolkit for their specific customer base, the lack of cross-platform tools is excusable.

Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by eropple on Thursday August 13, 2015 @12:23AM (#10052243)
> I feel marginalized and hence a little insulted, when discovering I can't.

I feel you; I used to be a Linux desktop user and an advocate thereof. But that's the price that you pay for using the distant, distant third most-used OS for a company trying to drive user engagement with their product. You (the collective you) have to be an attractive market if you want commercial entities to consider you worth marketing to, y'know?

Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by rimantas on Thursday August 13, 2015 @03:40AM (#10052731)
Or maybe, just maybe, they are very aware of their user base and that's the reason there is no version for Linux? Should I get upset that they don't have Lithuanian version of the app, and hence demonstrate a lack of concern/acknowledgement of the diversity of its user base?
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by em3rgent0rdr on Friday August 14, 2015 @05:57AM (#10059344)
That's not a comparable anaolgy. I can't find data on the number of linux users vs the number of lithuanian users, but the number of linux users is orders of magnitude higher.
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by igravious on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @05:29PM (#10050756)
No. Github is built on git. Git was written by Linus Torvalds. You see where this is going? Oh, we'll build our tech on your side project but ignore the user base of your main project. Nice.
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by JeremyMorgan on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @05:03PM (#10050600)
I was just guessing, I really don't know. There could be other reasons I'm unaware of.

http://git-scm.com/docs/git-request-pull

Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by em3rgent0rdr on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @06:02PM (#10050989)
thanks, but the context was how to create a new pull request to github from commandline, which I don't believe git request-pull can do. Another comment mentions https://github.com/github/hub#git-pull-request which seems to be what I am looking for.
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by scottjad on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @06:07PM (#10051015)
git pull-request

Using https://github.com/github/hub

Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by em3rgent0rdr on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @06:09PM (#10051037)
thanks, that's what I'm looking for!
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @05:19PM (#10050689)
I'm sure most hardcore Linux users would consider using a GUI to use git would be embarrassing / insulting TBF.

I mean git add, git commit, and git push/pull is 95% of what you'd do with git and it's not rocket science.

Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by sirtaj on Thursday August 13, 2015 @03:32AM (#10052712)
Linux has been my primary desktop OS for almost twenty years, and no, I have no problems using good GUI tools when they're available. I'm happy to use a Git GUI to review changed files and selectively choose text hunks from them for a specific changeset, for example. Often I'll just do it from with Vim with Fugitive, but that's a GUI too, by any definition.
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by em3rgent0rdr on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @05:47PM (#10050869)
right. But it is a nice clean GUI, that handles the 95% percent without any fluff. The git program is very complicated, designed to handle large projects, and it does have a learning curve (especially to keep all the commands straight e.g. git branch -l, git branch -d, git checkout -b, git "reqeust-pull"???). When I was first learning git, I was a little overwhelmed at its variety of commands in the man, and would have preferred this GUI where I'm able to simply click on repos, click to create a branch, and click to create a pull request, to handle 95%+ of use cases. Even hardcore linux users like to use simple GUI tools, sometimes.
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by barnacs on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @01:16PM (#10049120)
But it's not about git itself. Issues, PR comments, the wiki and such things make github what is. Personally, I'd prefer a nice graphical desktop app to handle these, and either have a terminal embedded or run it alongside the gui to handle the git commands.
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by harel on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @06:11PM (#10051055)
I use the CLI. Still, that's not the point. Mac users use the CLI too. Some Windows users as well I'm sure. We now live in a Triple-Platform world. Linux is not a sideline project. Its a major Operating System. If OSX gets it (BSD), surely it can be compiled to Linux. Its multi platform anyway so why not go the full distance?!
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by victorhooi on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @09:37PM (#10051866)
I believe they're using native libraries on each platform though - the OSX app is using Cocoa, and the Windows app is using WPF.
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by yellowapple on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @04:29PM (#10050412)
> It's likely they felt it's not worth the time

This seems strange. Did they not use Electron or Atom Shell or whatever it's called to build Github Desktop? If so, then is it not relatively trivial to create a GNU/Linux (or at least non-OSX-centric Unix) tarball of all the Javascript or whatever? If not so, then why not?

Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by kitsunesoba on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @05:32PM (#10050770)
Because Electron is heavy and clunky. It makes no sense for a simple wrapper around a tiny (less than 1MB) commandline tool to have memory and CPU requirements on par with those of an instance of Chromium with a javascript-laden page open in a tab.
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by yellowapple on Thursday August 13, 2015 @12:10AM (#10052212)
If it's really just a wrapper around the git command, then I suppose I'm not really interested anyway, then, seeing as the existing Git GUIs for Linux provide that rather well. I was assuming it was like the Mac client where it provides Github-specific functionality (adding "Clone in Desktop" buttons to repo pages, managing pull requests, etc.).
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by kitsunesoba on Thursday August 13, 2015 @01:51AM (#10052454)
I was assuming it was like the Mac client where it provides Github-specific functionality (adding "Clone in Desktop" buttons to repo pages, managing pull requests, etc.). It is like the Mac client, but that functionality still doesn’t justify the resource usage than a Chromium wrapper would bring.
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by yellowapple on Thursday August 13, 2015 @01:36PM (#10055878)
Right; my point with that was more around the implication that it's just a git wrapper.

Regardless, my ultimate point is that Github went through all this trouble to make this Electron Shell thing and they don't even bother using their own tool. That seems surprising, Electron's merits and troubles aside.

Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by onewordnowait2 on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @10:11PM (#10051940)
Downloaded it, libcef.dll + many other MBs of browser. But no nodejs. Weird.
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by angdis on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @01:52PM (#10049405)
Haven't tried it yet, but the history visualization looks very cool. It can be useful to actually SEE branches sometimes. As for why its not on linux desktop? Probably too much work to adapt for many different flavors for a small number of people.