Bitcoin are inherently bearer instruments. If you can spend the Bitcoin, you own it; if you can't, you don't. MtGOX owned all those Bitcoins, because it had to in order to do anything with them, and its customers owned promises made by MtGOX.
I think the court could have made that a bit more clear in its ruling, but I think there may have been an explicit effort to avoid comparing Bitcoin to banknotes. It doesn't matter if it's tangible or intangible. What matters is that there is no possible evidence of ownership that could be presented to the court to restore the property.
MtGOX customers spent their Bitcoins to MtGOX, and received promises in exchange. It was a nice attempt, but the straws eluded their grasp. They wait and get their pro rata share, just like all the other creditors.
This discussion seems full of misinterpreting a term of art as something closer to colloquial meaning, and then drawing inferences from that. Such inferences by nature will usually be deeply flawed.
Doesn't every Bitcoin have a serial number, similar to the car's license plate?
Here's an example 10BTC transaction assuming no intermediate fees:
A(2) + B(8) ==> X(5) + Y(5)
You can't tell how many of A's bitcoins were sent to X or Y, but you can trace the transactions all the way to the originally mined blocks that each contained 50BTC.
The receivers, who are hired to administer this process, take their pay straight off the top of the money pile. The remaining money pile is divided up among the creditors, depending on how much they've shown they're owed. There isn't enough money to go around (if there was, the company wouldn't be bankrupt) so everyone gets less than they're owed.
When this process is complete the company is gone, and nobody owes anyone anything. This is what "limited liability" means - none of the investors or owners of the company is liable for anything beyond their initial investment.
So if you sold the company a $1000 widget and gave them 90 days to pay, and they go bankrupt in those 90 days, you might only get $10 or $100 back from the receivers.
Just because someone has lost $1000 worth of bitcoins, doesn't mean they'll ever see them again or anyone is legally liable to pay them back - in cash or in bitcoins.
Suppose you lend (not give or sell) your car to a company that then goes bankrupt with the vehicle in its possession, and you go along to reclaim it.
The officials handling the case might say "Okay, let's check the blue book value of the car and you'll get your pro rata percentage of that money when everything is settled."
To which you can reply "No, you don't understand. I'm not saying the company owes me money. I'm saying that's my car, license number such and such, it doesn't belong to the company at all, so it's not part of the bankruptcy proceedings, it belongs to me and I want it back right now." And assuming you have the documentation to prove it, the law will support your case.
In this case the court has ruled that you can't point to a particular bitcoin and say that's my bitcoin, because bitcoin has the properties of money rather than of particular tangible objects, so all you can say is you are owed a certain amount of bitcoins. And so the owner of such will get his pro rata percentage after everything is settled, instead of getting the whole lot right now.
Am I understanding it correctly?