News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by gleenn on Friday August 07, 2015 @05:04AM (#10021510)
This is the first time I've heard of a pen register, apparently somewhat broad, modern parlance for things that capture phone data. It seems pretty damning that they spent the time to fax MetroPCS but couldn't, ya know, even get the pen register or ask a judge to ask if they thought it was a good idea.

Maybe the bad guys are really bad, but sometimes I hope that they get off just to make the point that the cops are suppose to do the "right thing", otherwise the cops really are the bad guys.

Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by dbarlett on Friday August 07, 2015 @08:24AM (#10022019)
The term dates back to 19th-century telegraphy [1]. 18 U.S. Code § 3127 [2] defines them specifically:

    the term “pen register” means a device or process which records or decodes
    dialing, routing, addressing, or signaling information transmitted by an
    instrument or facility from which a wire or electronic communication is
    transmitted, provided, however, that such information shall not include the
    contents of any communication, but such term does not include any device or
    process used by a provider or customer of a wire or electronic communication
    service for billing, or recording as an incident to billing, for
    communications services provided by such provider or any device or process
    used by a provider or customer of a wire communication service for cost
    accounting or other like purposes in the ordinary course of its business;

[1] https://nerdsincourt.wordpress.com/2013/06/11/on-prism-smith...

[2] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/3127

Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by fluidcruft on Friday August 07, 2015 @08:57AM (#10022154)
> Maybe the bad guys are really bad, but sometimes I hope that they get off just to make the point that the cops are suppose to do the "right thing", otherwise the cops really are the bad guys

The US way is to exclude evidence and protect the cops--the idea being that cops have no motive to cross lines if they can't use the evidence. More and more I'm leaning towards what I understand is the European way: let the evidence stand, but hold the cops accountable for their actions through parallel civil and criminal proceedings. The feedback for "cop behavior" is direct vs indirect.

Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by baseballmerpeak on Friday August 07, 2015 @09:13AM (#10022217)
Let unconstitutionally acquired exidence stand?

No, let's not let the abuses of a government stand, as we should also go after its agents.

Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by fluidcruft on Friday August 07, 2015 @09:30AM (#10022303)
The constitutionality of actions used to obtain evidence is completely independent of the truth of the defendants guilt or innocence. If the actions are bad, actually prosecute the actions in non-kangaroo proceedings.

A) let the abuses of a government stand

B) go after its agents

In the US we have neither A nor B.

Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by dragonwriter on Friday August 07, 2015 @09:53AM (#10022443)
The Constitution restricts what government may do against individuals. Perhaps the agents that break the rules should be held individually accountable in more cases than they currently are (though, as with most cases of using law to provide accountability for executive agents, there are agency problems that make that unlikely to be effective in many important cases), but that should not be an excuse to void the purpose of the restrictions, which is to limit the power of government, not just its agents individually. The government cannot be allowed to benefit from the it's unconstitutional acts while certain agents are punished as scapegoats.
Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by fluidcruft on Friday August 07, 2015 @10:20AM (#10022614)
Sometimes it's not only about the government. Sometimes victims of crime deserve justice, too.
Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by dragonwriter on Friday August 07, 2015 @11:31AM (#10023030)
> Sometimes it's not only about the government. Sometimes victims of crime deserve justice, too.

When the power of the executive branch of government is being used as the means seek something, its always about the Constitutional limits on government. No matter what you feel you deserve, the Constitution is the deal by which the outer bounds of the scope of your privilege to have the coercive power of government deployed to get you what you deserve is limited.

Government shouldn't get to escape the Constitutional limits on its application of power against those subject to it because "think of the victims of crime", or "think of the children", or "think of..." whatever else.

Otherwise, we're tossing out the concept of limited government in favor of arbitrary power.

Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by fluidcruft on Friday August 07, 2015 @12:26PM (#10023344)
You can view government as an imperfect tool that attempts to achieve the impossible goal of justice, or your can view government as the definition of justice.

It's a question of whether to judge an imperfect tool based on details of how its mechanism works or whether to judge it based on how well it performs the tasks we ask of it.

I'm just saying that within this focus on microtransactions above all else the overall goals are lost and the balance of penalties is wrong. When the government goofs, we let the criminal go and deny the victims justice. The purpose of the justice system is justice. The focus on these microtransactions elevates government as the definition of justice which seems much more expansive than the alternative, IMHO.

Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by dragonwriter on Friday August 07, 2015 @12:33PM (#10023380)
> You can view government as an imperfect tool that attempts to achieve the goal of justice, or your can view government as the definition of justice.

You could also view "justice" in such a way that the claim that a victim of crime "deserves justices" is, to the extent that it is meaningful, completely inapplicable to the concept of criminal punishment.

> It's a question of whether to judge an imperfect tool based on its mechanism or whether to judge it based on how well it achieves the tasks we use it for.

No, even agreeing that government should be viewed as an imperfect tool for achieving justice, its a question of what "justice" means, and whether it can ever be consistent with violating the agreement by which persons are, under the guise of acting in the name of government, granted power over others.

Some would view such violations as, themselves, inherently and fundamentally unjust.

Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by fluidcruft on Friday August 07, 2015 @12:45PM (#10023459)
In the situation where knowledge of guilt has been found by unjust means, how does ignoring that knowledge promote justice.

> Some would view such violations as, themselves, inherently and fundamentally unjust

Exactly. Which is why the government should be held accountable to the victims of that abuse, not accountable to itself.

Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by fnordfnordfnord on Friday August 07, 2015 @06:02PM (#10025283)
>In the situation where knowledge of guilt has been found by unjust means, how does ignoring that knowledge promote justice.

By signalling to police that whatever sketchy things they did to obtain the knowledge won't be available to help them achieve their goal.

Example, police use defective probable cause to search a motorist's vehicle; and I don't just mean search, but really search, as in pull the carpets up, remove interior panels, remove all of the contents of the trunk, break down the tires and look inside; it is destructive. Although the car may be re-assembled, they never are returned to their pre-tossing state. The only thing preventing this from happening more often is the amount of labor involved in tearing the car up. Police (Feds sometimes do) don't have to pay for damaging someone's property when they do this. They don't even have to put it back together. Same goes for your home.

Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by dragonwriter on Friday August 07, 2015 @12:56PM (#10023519)
> Which is why the government should be held accountable to the victims of that abuse

The exclusionary rule holds the government accountable to victims of abuse, by removing the value that the government sought to gain by the abuse and the expense of the victim (it is imperfect, of course, in that it fails where the abuse was targeted at some use other than criminal prosecution.)

Any mechanism that fails to prevent the government from getting what it seeks by the abuse fails to hold the government accountable to the victim of the abuse.

Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by fluidcruft on Friday August 07, 2015 @05:36PM (#10025155)
That argument rests on the asserted non-existence of alternate mechanisms to hold the government accountable when they abuse the general public. Believe it or not letting criminals walk free is actually not the only available mechanism for addressing government abuse. It's just the mechanism our government has chosen for itself.
Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by cjslep on Friday August 07, 2015 @01:37PM (#10023747)
> In the situation where knowledge of guilt has been found by unjust means, how does ignoring that knowledge promote justice.

Because not ignoring that knowledge enables the propagating of injustice. Fighting for justice is a futile effort if delivering justice also delivers one or more instances of injustice (it is a pyrrhic victory). This idea is the root of the biblical notion of "eye for an eye" (also part of a popular quote of Ghandi).

Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by fluidcruft on Friday August 07, 2015 @02:56PM (#10024272)
No, this is not dichotomous-- There are at least five parties experiencing various degrees of harm: victims of crime, law enforcement, actually guilty criminals, falsely accused criminals, and the general public.

The actually hard part is divining the difference between actually guilty criminals and falsely accused criminals. That's the only valid reason for the justice system to act in this space. And that's also exactly what this extra knowledge clarifies.

We can always go full-retard with the utilitarianism. If you're going to allow injustice to happen to the few to the benefit the many, why even bother prosecute anyone for anything? Shut the farce down.

Or perhaps we could remove the bubble wrap that we allow government to hide behind and hold law enforcement directly accountable for its harm to the public and to the falsely accused. We don't have to play moral dominoes.

Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by cjslep on Saturday August 08, 2015 @09:42PM (#10029235)
> We can always go full-retard with the utilitarianism. If you're going to allow injustice to happen to the few to the benefit the many, why even bother prosecute anyone for anything?

That is quite a strawman coming out of nowhere! You can use Kant's Categorical Imperative for all I care to formulate my previous comment with something like:

"It is acceptable to do an unjust action in order to determine a person's possible guilt in a suspected crime."

(And I am sure the proponents of Utilitarianism were not learning disabled).

> And that's also exactly what this extra knowledge [unjust action uncovering evidence of guilt] clarifies.

Sure, but it is also a great way to damage the general public's well-being. I'm ignoring the obvious hindsight bias that is required, though that could be a separate argument. I instead would like to point out that if there is the idea of a "second class citizen" (a non-victim) whose rights are allowed to be trumped in order to bring justice for a "first class citizen" (a victim), society as a whole will shift to be one full of victims. I don't believe such a society would be healthy and cooperative. I posit instead it would be better for a society as a whole to prevent having victims in the first place (through some sort of comprehensive set of methods, e.g.: community building, decriminalization, education, better mental health solutions, etc) while maintaining equal rights. There does not exist a perfect justice system for each individual, but having the net effect across all of society being positive is a worthy goal.

> Or perhaps we could remove the bubble wrap that we allow government to hide behind and hold law enforcement directly accountable for its harm to the public and to the falsely accused.

I agree.

Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by fluidcruft on Monday August 10, 2015 @11:29AM (#10035213)
I disagree about the strawman. You would deny the victims concrete existing evidence of the accused's wrong doing--solely for the purpose of protecting the general public from some potential or abstract future harm. I disagree that this denial is actually necessary for preventing the potential or abstract future harm.
Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by dragonwriter on Monday August 10, 2015 @11:41AM (#10035307)
> You would deny the victims existing and concrete evidence of the accused's wrong

Insofar as it is for the victim (civil litigation by someone harmed by an unlawful act to seek redress) rather than the State (criminal process to impose criminal penalties pursued by and at the discretion of the executive branch of government), illegally obtained evidence is not excluded. The exclusionary rule only applies to evidence illegally obtained by the government which the government attempts to use in criminal prosecution. The victim is not involved.

The State represents the public as an abstract generality, not the individual victim. (Prosecutors like to pretend otherwise, but that's a manipulation technique, not reality.)

Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by Retric on Friday August 07, 2015 @11:06AM (#10022843)
While I don't normally think in terms of slippery slope arguments, this would easily fall into such territory. After all how hard would it be to prosecute a cop whose illegal evidence goes a serial killer off the street? Give it a generation or two and we would end up with cops who only get convicted of the worst breaches, and effectively zero constitutional protection.
Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by BurningFrog on Friday August 07, 2015 @12:46PM (#10023465)
If victimless crimes weren't so dominant in current US law, I would agree with that.
Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by facetube on Friday August 07, 2015 @12:34PM (#10023388)
The best way for police to bring justice to victims of crime reliably is for them to obey the law during investigations, arrests, and trials.
Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by afarrell on Friday August 07, 2015 @09:25AM (#10022275)
But this is in fact what we do http://lawcomic.net/guide/?p=1585
Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by MCRed on Friday August 07, 2015 @09:38AM (#10022349)
"We" don't get to go after its agents, only Prosecutors, and investigatory agencies (like the police) get to "go after" them. And if you look at the history of crimes committed by government employees you see that in almost all cases they are never prosecuted.

This is the fundamental problem with government justice-- it will never hold its own people accountable.

The few examples of this happening pale in comparison to the rampant corruption and crime going on, everything from fraudulent warrants to destroying evidence to violating peoples rights and malicious prosecution.

Look at Aaron Swartz for example.

The problem is that people are gullible enough that they think that "the law is the law" when in practice it is people that make the law more than just paper.

And the incentives for the government judiciary are to cut corners, violate rights and protect their own.

Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by yock on Friday August 07, 2015 @09:44AM (#10022387)
Why let the evidence stand? Shouldn't it be preferable to exclude the illegally-obtained evidence and punish the police for obtaining it illegally?
Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by fluidcruft on Friday August 07, 2015 @10:27AM (#10022639)
I think it depends on whether you think justice should seek truth or some sort of malleable truth theater. Causing an actual criminal go unpunished when extremely convincing evidence of guilt is known (but concealed from the jury) only further harms the victims.
Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by yock on Friday August 07, 2015 @02:38PM (#10024165)
Illegally-obtained evidence shouldn't be inadmissible just because it was obtained illegally, but because it is co-mingled with the motives of the official who broke the law to obtain it. You can't possibly know if the evidence is even reliable and accurate because it could just as easily be fabricated to further those illegal motives.
Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by BurningFrog on Friday August 07, 2015 @12:44PM (#10023450)
As a European, I get a little twitchy whenever people talk about how things are in "Europe", since it is an extremely diverse collection of countries that very little is universally true about aside from their location.

That said, I can confirm that in Sweden, any verifiable information is allowed in a trial. This fits with the idea that a trial is an attempt to find the truth.

Swedish prosecutors are also obliged to seek out and present all objective facts, including those that argues for the accused.

Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by MCRed on Friday August 07, 2015 @09:35AM (#10022325)
For an excellent review of the nature of policing and wiretaps in particular, watch the TV show The Wire. On HBO now and Amazon Prime. (and I think the best TV show ever made.)

It's fictionalized but written by an ex-cop and covers the drug trade in Baltimore.

Re:An Oakland shooting reveals how cops snoop on cell phones by dredmorbius on Saturday August 08, 2015 @05:23AM (#10026775)
David Simon was a former reporter. His lectures -- look for "the audacity of despair" -- are excellent:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nRt46W3k-qw

(Long, poor audio, and lot of verbal ticks, but simply amazing.)