News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MIT claims to have found a “language universal” that ties... by canjobear on Thursday August 06, 2015 @02:13PM (#10018280)
Yes, I also think dependency length minimization is just a cognitive constraint. (Lead author here.) The idea of calling this a universal in the Chomsky sense is all from the press. The cool thing about it is that (previous work has shown) you can use this constraint in principle to derive a lot of the more substantive "universals" (really, overwhelming tendencies) of language, such as that natural language expressions are usually well-nested, and that in languages where the verb follows the object, the noun also follows the adjective, and the preposition follows the noun, etc.

As for isolated languages, I just finished performing some dependency length preference experiments on indigenous people in Bolivia, but haven't analyzed the data yet, so we'll see :)

Re:MIT claims to have found a “language universal” that ties... by gohrt on Thursday August 06, 2015 @06:11PM (#10019813)
What have you learned about how to talk to the press?

Bad coverage like this reflects back negatively on the research and the institution, sadly.

Uni PR offices are famously bad at twisting and over-selling research results.

Re:MIT claims to have found a “language universal” that ties... by canjobear on Thursday August 06, 2015 @07:55PM (#10020225)
I think I've learned there's not much you can do.

My advisor and I talked to two reporters: one from MIT News (https://newsoffice.mit.edu/2015/how-language-gives-your-brai...) and one from Science Magazine (http://news.sciencemag.org/social-sciences/2015/08/all-langu...). They both communicated with us about all kinds of details in the articles, and let us comment on the drafts. We clearly stated what we did and didn't want to claim, and they did a good job conveying what we wanted while adding extra connections we hadn't thought of for popular appeal.

On the other hand, we had no contact with anyone about the Ars Technica article. I've also seen some other articles cropping up that are copying the original articles, and making claims I wouldn't stand by. I don't think there's anything we can do about that.

Re:MIT claims to have found a “language universal” that ties... by RobertoG on Friday August 07, 2015 @02:10AM (#10021119)
Have you considered demanding a correction?

They are putting words in your mouth. Somebody should keep journalist accountable.

A few days ago I tried to follow the source of an article in an online newspaper. The source was another online newspaper , in a different language, and the source for this one another one. Along the way things were added and removed, just like in a crazy telephone game.

It makes you think about the news we read and take for granted.

Re:MIT claims to have found a “language universal” that ties... by azinman2 on Friday August 07, 2015 @03:33PM (#10024515)
"Scientists notice small trend that may or may not be of importance to language" just isn't a very catchy headline.
Re:MIT claims to have found a “language universal” that ties... by mandor on Sunday August 09, 2015 @03:19PM (#10031221)
A good thing that we did for our last paper [1]: we have set up a FAQ [2] with the most common questions (we updated the FAQ when we received new questions). Thanks to the FAQ, the journalists do not "invent" too much and they have quotes that they can use.

Overall, I think the FAQ helped a lot and it avoided some common mis-interpretations.

[1] Paper: http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v521/n7553/full/nature1... | arxiv version & video: http://chronos.isir.upmc.fr/~mouret/website/nature_press.xht...

[2] FAQ: http://chronos.isir.upmc.fr/~mouret/website/nature_press.xht...

Re:MIT claims to have found a “language universal” that ties... by coldtea on Friday August 07, 2015 @06:51AM (#10021768)
>Bad coverage like this reflects back negatively on the research and the institution, sadly

On the contrary! It's usually assisted by the researchers and the institution, and it helps them get grants and free press "advertising".

Re:MIT claims to have found a “language universal” that ties... by mandor on Sunday August 09, 2015 @03:20PM (#10031226)
Also: do not let the Uni PR office write the press release. Write it yourself and insist they use yours.
Re:MIT claims to have found a “language universal” that ties... by azinman2 on Friday August 07, 2015 @03:35PM (#10024527)
These abstract patterns are interesting (and I'd love to read more about them), butt more so if you can drive some kind of tree that neatly describes all languages. But doing so is essentially solving Chomsky's main theory which so far hasn't been done to my understanding?
Re:MIT claims to have found a “language universal” that ties... by varjag on Thursday August 06, 2015 @05:33PM (#10019612)
Very interesting.

Do you think this constraint would hold in artificial languages (Esperanto, Lojban, Tengwar) as well?

Re:MIT claims to have found a “language universal” that ties... by canjobear on Thursday August 06, 2015 @05:58PM (#10019746)
Speakers of artificial languages are probably influenced by the syntax of their native languages, so yes, I suspect we'd see dependency length minimization when people speak those languages too.