Re:How to get gmail.com banned (2011)
by michaelhoffman on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @02:02PM
(#10005097)
What's worse: some sites accept email addresses with + in them and then years later, they stop working, and you can't log in to fix your email address.
Ask me how I know this.
Hah, this happened to me once. Turns out the email validation was occurring client-side though... so a quick edit later and the server still gladly accepted my '+'-enabled email address. :-)
>For the record, the gold standard for email validation is "send a confirmation link and see if they click it". Don't try and get fancy.
But make sure you have some sort of rate limiting set up, so malicious users can't take advantage to spam someone's mailbox (and get your server blacklisted).
Re:How to get gmail.com banned (2011)
by GauntletWizard on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @01:15PM
(#10004775)
My favorite is e-mails with three dots in them. Which is actually not a valid address - the RFC specifies that you must have a valid textual character between dots[1]. However, because of poor decisions by Japanese telcoms, a substantial chunk of their users have 'e-mails' associated with their mobile phones with three dots, breaking goddamn every sensible validation script.
> Which is actually not a valid address
That means validation was working correctly. The email addresses are invalid even if the server will accept email for them.
There's only one sensible validation script: "Send an email with a confirm link".
Taking action with side-effects on entirely unvalidated user input is usually a pretty bad idea.
Re:How to get gmail.com banned (2011)
by GauntletWizard on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @02:07PM
(#10005129)
Sadly, if you're sending e-mail sanely, your mail provider likely validates recipients, and will be annoyed at you if you send them recipients they think are bogus.
Re:How to get gmail.com banned (2011)
by belovedeagle on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @11:36PM
(#10007915)
The relevant rfc (on mobile; don't remember which) specifically states that intermediate servers must not validate mailboxes (local parts). And honestly the domain should be "validated" by the server doing an mx lookup; let dns handle it.
So wait, what now? So you can have an email address like [email protected]? Can you give me a generic example?
Yeah, I'm with the other guy, regardless of whether or not it's a good idea to do validation (it's not), that's not an address that should pass validation because it's not a valid domain or hostname.
I could see it being less of a big deal in the mailbox portion given that it's now kinda kosher to ignore dots there.
Yep, for some reason my wife's emails to her sister[1] always bounce unless she uses the desktop, it's madness.
[1] docomo customer with two dots in email
Re:How to get gmail.com banned (2011)
by brongondwana on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @10:00PM
(#10007647)
This is why we allow subdomain magic at FastMail, so that if you wanted to use [email protected] you can use [email protected] as well, and it works fine. Everyone accepts that form.
I had a [email protected] (though I have a really common name so it was actually [email protected]), but fortunately they also gave us 8 character usernames (which were also our login to our shared hosting on the Sun E6500 machine), but I never used the long form since it was rejected nearly everywhere.
Re:How to get gmail.com banned (2011)
by PebblesHD on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @12:19AM
(#10008000)
My university address at the moment causes similar issues, it follows the [email protected] form which throws off lots of input validators.
Re:How to get gmail.com banned (2011)
by giancarlostoro on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @03:06PM
(#10005522)
All this time I've been telling people my email has a . in it, I had no idea I could remove it and still login.
I used to have a [email protected] address and that one was touch-and-go as well due to the fact that the mailbox had two .'s in it. I actually had to file a support request to get Amazon Student to accept it, even. Nobody from a university with that scheme ever registered before?
For the record, the gold standard for email validation is "send a confirmation link and see if they click it". Don't try and get fancy.
One other trick is that Gmail ignores .'s in addresses entirely. [email protected] is the same as firstlast or f.irstlast.