News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Ihaveaproblem

Re:Has RapGenius been getting away with cloaking? on Friday December 27, 2013 @09:37AM (#6970718)
I have never heard of Google keeping cache's of pages in javascript-disabled states, Googlebot has been processing JS for a long time. And how many users (even considering mobile) really don't have JS these days? This may not be by-the-definition cloaking, but it's right up on the line for sure.
Re:Has RapGenius been getting away with cloaking? on Thursday December 26, 2013 @01:23PM (#6967231)
Ya, I did the user agent testing three weeks ago and got the same results I am getting today. I'm certainly not keeping close track of them, so maybe they did change something, but everything I see is 1:1 as it was when I first saw it. Perhaps they are detecting Googlebot via IP instead of user agent. I dunno.
Re:Has RapGenius been getting away with cloaking? on Thursday December 26, 2013 @12:52PM (#6967079)
Well I can't prove it, but I first noticed this about three weeks ago and I'm 100% positive they haven't changed anything since then. They may have used JS redirects further back in the past, I'm not sure.

Has RapGenius been getting away with cloaking?

This is a type of URL that RapGenius ranked very well for before the assassination: http://rapgenius.com/35640/The-notorious-big-suicidal-thoughts/I-like-black-timbs-and-black-hoodiesThat page, along with many others for every song, 301s back to the full song for a user with an anchor for the specific line/note.However, Google keeps the URL that redirects as a top search result and keeps a text...

( Read More... | 12 comments | 22 points | on HN )