Has RapGenius been getting away with cloaking?
This is a type of URL that RapGenius ranked very well for before the assassination: http://rapgenius.com/35640/The-notorious-big-suicidal-thoughts/I-like-black-timbs-and-black-hoodies
That page, along with many others for every song, 301s back to the full song for a user with an anchor for the specific line/note.
However, Google keeps the URL that redirects as a top search result and keeps a text only cache that looks like this: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://rapgenius.com/35640/The-notorious-big-suicidal-thoughts/I-like-black-timbs-and-black-hoodies&strip=1
If this isn't cloaking, why is Google keeping a URL that 301s in their SERPs, giving it top ranking, and keeping a separate cache?
(
12 comments
| 22 points
| on HN
)
Even if this was a Googlebot-only page, it still wouldn't be cloaking, as they're just showing a more search-engine friendly version of the same content that's in the annotation on the actual page.
http://stackoverflow.hewgill.com/questions/121/108.html
I haven't seen this one done in years.
It would have been legitimate if the user saw the same content as the crawlers, but displaying different content to SE crawlers would definitely be bad.
If confirmed, this could turn a bad situation in to a ghastly one.
I think the 301s are actually their response to Google's ban hammer.
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://...
You'll see that you get redirected. But disable javascript in your dev tools, and you'll see that you no longer get redirected :)
for example TINT
tintup.com
once you create a free account they have the following:
Dear valued Tint customer, Would you like to write a review about Tint? In exchange for your opinions/blog post, we are giving away 50% off FOREVER promo code for our Plus Plan. To learn more, click the button below:
screen shot: http://imgur.com/wDnAJ4c