If the US can enforce their laws on the web, why should France, China, etc not be able to do so, too?
We have to be on a web where stuff like nude boobs is considered NSFW, where sites that allow users to sell used digital goods are instantly sued to death, etc.
These things are all based on a US-centric moral framework.
The whole web is full of that. And Google, a company that, until recently, was legally headquartered in Ireland, applies only the US moral standard for their products.
Even if I am in europe, I can’t upload a movie to YouTube that is allowed to be shown on TV in Germany during daytime just because the US moral standard says nude boobs are not okay.
If the US and its companies want to force their moral and legal standards upon us, we will force our standards upon them, too.
Which is one of the reasons why TTIP contains the "local IP" part: Only sparkling wine made in France may be called Champagner from then on, only Parmesan made in Italy may be called this, etc.
This is incredibly silly reasoning. Google enforces the standards it chooses (generally American standards, in this case, as it is an American company) on its own properties. That's quite a far cry from imposing your own set of values on a third-party service provider.
The equivalent would be to start your own service which imposes your own set of standards (which, I'll point out, exists in the form of DailyMotion and LiveLeak, among others), not to say "well if you get to apply your standards to your service then I get to apply my standards to your service."
If a German company operates within Germany with German customers completely legal according to German law, and then gets fucked over by US institutions forcing US banks to seize the money of that company just because the actions (which happened solely under German law) were not according to US law...
Then it is the exact same situation. If the US can dictate our companies laws, we can dictate their companies laws, too.
The Euro was made also to reduce the influence of the dollar for international trade, and especially the countries within the EU have almost no contact with the dollar anymore, nor do most companies here. Which makes sure the US can’t just seize their assets (like they used to seize assets of companies because "if they trade in dollar, they operate under US law")
If the argument is that the German population doesn't want them, then that's an internal issue and not the US' problem, as we negotiate with state actors, not citizens.
It's just like the NSA affair. And the fact that in the Microsoft case a US judge stated that, even though the servers in question were in Europe, the US could seize them because the internet was a US invention and the company had made business in the US just shows the issue: the US legal enforcement consistently oversteps nations boundaries.
A documentary that shows nude boobs can’t be uploaded by our state television to YouTube because Google forbids that.
Such a documentary DEFINITELY doesn’t belong on LiveLeak or PornHub or whatever either, though. It belongs on a platform like Vimeo or YouTube, where it’s forbidden due to US-American moral standards.
So upload it somewhere else. Google is a private company and as such is perfectly within its rights to allow or not allow activity based on arbitrary rules.
This argument is incoherent so it's not worth a further reply.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_and_survei...