Re:If the Panama Canal gets a rival
by eloff on Sunday August 02, 2015 @11:55AM
(#9991117)
I've been living in Panama since 2006. I've followed a lot of the articles around the Nicaraguan canal to try to get some sense of how it will affect Panama.
My conclusion is a canal in Nicaragua makes no economic sense, there must be some hidden motivation at play here, such as personal glory for Wang Jing or a ploy to secure land rights and tax exemptions. The reasoning is as follows:
1) The possible ROI from a ~$70 billion investment is very low. The same revenue can be achieved by building a third set of locks in Panama for ~$15 billion. Right away it looks like bad business. Most ways you can spend $70 billion will yield a better return with less risk.
2) The Chinese government is not involved. If it were a political thing, it could explain why someone would forge ahead despite the poor ROI, but the government is not financing it and government companies won't touch it with a stick.
3) Wang Jing is a telcom billionaire and neither he nor his company have any experience with construction or engineering.
4) A Chinese construction and engineering company has offered to finance and build a fourth set of super-sized locks in Panama for ~17 billion. This would compete directly with a hypothetical Nicaraguan Canal for the largest ships, but at a much smaller investment.
Given two nearly identical products, the company with lower costs will be able to offer lower prices while still making a profit. That will clearly be Panama. There's just no logic in the Federation's move here. Jorge Quijano, who leads the Panama Canal Authority, has come to the same conclusion.
My conclusion is a canal in Nicaragua makes no economic sense, there must be some hidden motivation at play here, such as personal glory for Wang Jing or a ploy to secure land rights and tax exemptions. The reasoning is as follows:
1) The possible ROI from a ~$70 billion investment is very low. The same revenue can be achieved by building a third set of locks in Panama for ~$15 billion. Right away it looks like bad business. Most ways you can spend $70 billion will yield a better return with less risk.
2) The Chinese government is not involved. If it were a political thing, it could explain why someone would forge ahead despite the poor ROI, but the government is not financing it and government companies won't touch it with a stick.
3) Wang Jing is a telcom billionaire and neither he nor his company have any experience with construction or engineering.
4) A Chinese construction and engineering company has offered to finance and build a fourth set of super-sized locks in Panama for ~17 billion. This would compete directly with a hypothetical Nicaraguan Canal for the largest ships, but at a much smaller investment.
Given two nearly identical products, the company with lower costs will be able to offer lower prices while still making a profit. That will clearly be Panama. There's just no logic in the Federation's move here. Jorge Quijano, who leads the Panama Canal Authority, has come to the same conclusion.
[1] http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-04-23/panama-can...
[2] http://insidecostarica.com/2015/04/14/chinese-interested-fin...
[4] http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/03/26/us-panama-canal-id...