My conclusion is a canal in Nicaragua makes no economic sense, there must be some hidden motivation at play here, such as personal glory for Wang Jing or a ploy to secure land rights and tax exemptions. The reasoning is as follows:
1) The possible ROI from a ~$70 billion investment is very low. The same revenue can be achieved by building a third set of locks in Panama for ~$15 billion. Right away it looks like bad business. Most ways you can spend $70 billion will yield a better return with less risk.
2) The Chinese government is not involved. If it were a political thing, it could explain why someone would forge ahead despite the poor ROI, but the government is not financing it and government companies won't touch it with a stick.
3) Wang Jing is a telcom billionaire and neither he nor his company have any experience with construction or engineering.
4) A Chinese construction and engineering company has offered to finance and build a fourth set of super-sized locks in Panama for ~17 billion. This would compete directly with a hypothetical Nicaraguan Canal for the largest ships, but at a much smaller investment.
Given two nearly identical products, the company with lower costs will be able to offer lower prices while still making a profit. That will clearly be Panama. There's just no logic in the Federation's move here. Jorge Quijano, who leads the Panama Canal Authority, has come to the same conclusion.
[1] http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-04-23/panama-can...
[2] http://insidecostarica.com/2015/04/14/chinese-interested-fin...
[4] http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/03/26/us-panama-canal-id...
It's also worth noting that the reason the canal was put in Panama over Nicaragua was due to earthquake activity which Panama did not have.
- Horrible ecological impact (fisheries in Caribbean are already [1]
- Many think this is an excuse for the politicians to get cushy land/resort deals along the proposed route and near the entrances to the canal [2]
- Some think it is really never going to materialize, but Chinese owned resorts will pop up on each end.
- Nicaragua doesn't have the infrastructure to undertake such a big engineering project (human talent, electrical, etc)
- The public hasn't had any say in this so far [2]
1. http://e360.yale.edu/feature/nicaragua_canal_a_giant_project...
2. http://www.csmonitor.com/World/Americas/Latin-America-Monito...