News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Windows 10 “steals” your bandwidth by striking on Saturday August 01, 2015 @05:35PM (#9988764)
Now, at first I was thinking this was a relatively sane feature like Apple's Software Update Server (which caches and re-serves updates for your local network)[1]. It's a very useful tool, considering the fact that when iOS 7 came out, it took out my entire high school's network because everyone was downloading it.

This isn't transparently helping serve updates to computers on a local network to save bandwidth. It transparently serves updates to the entire world, to eat your bandwidth and conserve only Microsoft's.

Is there a word in English that captures how massively disappointed I am with this being on every Win10 computer and by default?

[1]: http://hints.macworld.com/article.php?story=2007100908224845...

Re:Windows 10 “steals” your bandwidth by Silhouette on Saturday August 01, 2015 @05:44PM (#9988803)
Is there a word in English that captures how massively disappointed I am with this being on every Win10 computer and by default?

"Illegal" would seem to be a good start in many jurisdictions.

For example, as described in the article, I can't see how this behaviour doesn't fall foul of computer misuse and fraud laws in the UK. The best defence might be that somewhere buried in the terms and conditions it's allowed, but I wouldn't like to be the Microsoft lawyer arguing that position before a judge.

Re:Windows 10 “steals” your bandwidth by cma on Saturday August 01, 2015 @06:10PM (#9988880)
Blizzard have done this for WoW updates forever. MS may run into some liability for inducing data overages depending on how up front they are about it and how badly it bites people.
Re:Windows 10 “steals” your bandwidth by Silhouette on Saturday August 01, 2015 @06:29PM (#9988959)
Blizzard have done this for WoW updates forever.

Are Blizzard up-front with their users about what is happening? The covert nature (or otherwise) of the uploads is a significant concern here. The average geek playing with Linux doesn't complain about BitTorrent also uploading the distro image they're downloading, but the average geek playing with Linux knows the deal and decided voluntarily to participate.

MS may run into some liability for inducing data overages depending on how up front they are about it and how badly it bites people.

I would expect that if the report is accurate and if this behaviour was activated without the user's knowledge or consent then Microsoft would be on the hook for any and all damage caused as a result. That could mean a small extra charge from an ISP for bandwidth over a cap. However, if the behaviour means someone's Internet connection didn't have enough capacity left to do something important that it otherwise would have, whether because the uploads themselves limited the spare bandwidth at the same time or perhaps because it triggered some sort of degraded service from the ISP after going over a cap, that could also mean compensation for any consequences of that degraded capacity.

Re:Windows 10 “steals” your bandwidth by plorkyeran on Saturday August 01, 2015 @07:23PM (#9989108)
When I last played WoW there was a rather visible checkbox in the updater that said something like "Disable peer-to-peer transfers", and fairly importantly the updater never actually seeded the torrent; you only uploaded while you were actively downloading the patch, which stopped it from using a bunch of bandwidth at unexpected times.
Re:Windows 10 “steals” your bandwidth by dev-da0 on Saturday August 01, 2015 @06:32PM (#9988965)
The difference being WoW requires massive bandwidth to both download its updates and play. Not all Win10 users are gamers with Google Fiber.
Re:Windows 10 “steals” your bandwidth by rhino369 on Saturday August 01, 2015 @06:25PM (#9988946)
Iirc windows 10 install asks if you have metered Internet. I bet they turn this off if you click no. But that's speculation.

I remember when people thought BitTorrent would revolutionize file hosting. Now people think it's stealing bandwidth.

Re:Windows 10 “steals” your bandwidth by LoSboccacc on Saturday August 01, 2015 @06:47PM (#9989018)
Default setting is disabled for metered connections. One can also set it up to p2p updates locally but not on internet.

Don't know why ms didn't play it safe and put internet resharing as an opt in...

Oh and I don't remeber but I think you can't set a wired connection as metered.

Re:Windows 10 “steals” your bandwidth by rhino369 on Saturday August 01, 2015 @06:59PM (#9989048)
If you cannot set wired as metered then it's bullshit.
Re:Windows 10 “steals” your bandwidth by eli on Saturday August 01, 2015 @05:40PM (#9988789)
It seemed to work out fine for Spotify
Re:Windows 10 “steals” your bandwidth by striking on Saturday August 01, 2015 @05:45PM (#9988806)
That's likely because MP3 files are smaller than Windows Service packs, and because Spotify is a thing you install yourself. Windows comes with the computer, with this turned on. Also, Spotify is no longer P2P anyway, because it only served as a temporary cost-saving measure. And now it's gone. [1]

1: https://torrentfreak.com/spotify-starts-shutting-down-its-ma...

Re:Windows 10 “steals” your bandwidth by rohansingh on Saturday August 01, 2015 @06:13PM (#9988890)
With Spotify, the aim was low latency. If you click on a song, it should start playing immediately. There's no such requirement for software updates.

Back when the only data center was in Stockholm, the only way to meet latency requirements was P2P. Now that we're a grown-up company we've disabled that and use CDN's instead.

Re:Windows 10 “steals” your bandwidth by RKearney on Saturday August 01, 2015 @06:49PM (#9989022)
> With Spotify, the aim was low latency. If you click on a song, it should start playing immediately.

That was not their aim at all. Their aim was lowering bandwidth costs by shifting the content delivery costs over to the end users. This was made clear by the fact that when you played a song, it started downloading the song from AWS S3 immediately to minimize latency, then once the P2P sessions fired up, shifted over to that stream instead of their costly S3 one.

Re:Windows 10 “steals” your bandwidth by kamekai on Saturday August 01, 2015 @06:50PM (#9989025)
I had always assumed that the P2P was to help mitigate the cost of data so that the Spotify team could better use their limited (at the time) funds to secure more music contracts. Were operational costs not as drastic as I might be assuming?
Re:Windows 10 “steals” your bandwidth by pbreit on Saturday August 01, 2015 @06:29PM (#9988960)
Spotify's P2P usage enabled the amazingly fast response times which made every user's life better on an ongoing basis. That's a pretty fair tradeoff.
Re:Windows 10 “steals” your bandwidth by jchomali on Saturday August 01, 2015 @07:03PM (#9989056)
works in a similar way than most services