We pride ourselves to be rational/logical but these interviews are so counter intuitive to every thing we believe in.
Don't these interviewers have a little voice in their heads telling them "this is stupid" when they are going through this?
The only thing I didn't like about the interview was that they compared themselves with qualifying for the Olympics. That I should "consider it an honor" because I made it to the interview, which is like making it to the Olympic Trials. While I understand what they meant, I think it was a very pompous statement.
I think it was meant to draw me in by promising a selective team (he took my resume), but it didn't work at all. It simply felt like he was bragging about his own greatness (because he did have a job there) while telling me they would probably waste my time.
Even if the sentiment is good, any variant of "we're so great that failing is still an honor" feels tacky and self-aggrandizing.
I disagreed with them, but that didn't matter. I looked back on the interview and could see exactly why they thought that. That feedback helped me improve for the future.