News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by CamperBob2 on Friday July 31, 2015 @10:14PM (#9985583)
You seem to have a dog in the fight. Anything to disclose?
Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by dang on Saturday August 01, 2015 @12:43AM (#9985956)
That's a personal attack and not ok. See my comments below.

I'm detaching this from its original parent (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9985536) and marking it off-topic.

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by enraged_camel on Friday July 31, 2015 @11:13PM (#9985751)
You got downvoted but I agree with you. Reading engi_nerd's comments in this thread, one can't help but notice that he rigorously defends the F-35 and questions the credibility of anyone (e.g. David Axle) who points out major flaws in the plane's design. Even if he's not a paid shill, I would bet money that he's involved in the military-industrial complex somehow.
Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by engi_nerd on Friday July 31, 2015 @11:18PM (#9985765)
I strive for rigor in facts. Look, the fact is that the plane is kind of stubby looking and is not the quantum leap in maneuverability that, say, generation 4 represented from the previous gen. But I get very, very tired of people taking a poorly researched article that takes major sections of a report out of context (yes, I'm aware that Axe published the whole thing, but he still doesn't draw the correct conclusions from it) and then using that to say, "See? The F-35 sucks after all". The F-35 is a complex answer to a complex question, and it cannot be so simply understood. I wish it could. I love engineering simplicity and elegance and strive for it in my own designs, but anything in the military-industrial complex is hairy and ugly.

And yes, I know that from personal experience. Is that a bad thing?

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by alkonaut on Saturday August 01, 2015 @04:58AM (#9986420)
The F-35 could be the best solution to the complex problem (of making a joint stealth fighter with stovl). No one is arguing it could be done much better, but right from the start it should have been obvious that it's a problem without a good solution at all. The problem just shouldn't have been solved!

It should have been two (or even three) different airframes sharing engines, electronics.

Some craft wouldn't need full stealth, some wouldn't need stovl. Cramming everything into the same body and adding stealth just made it expensive, heavy, slow and unmaneuverable.

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by engi_nerd on Saturday August 01, 2015 @10:24AM (#9987111)
Well, look at the graphic here: https://i.imgur.com/WdOZcNF.jpg

Parts in green are identical across variants. Parts that are similar but require slight changes from one variant to another are called "cousin" parts and are shown in blue. Unique parts are shown in purple.

It was originally intended that the three variants share at least 75% of their parts in common. That required a modular kind of construction.

That didn't work out so well. A modular construction requires "holes", right? But holes are heavy because you have to reinforce the structure around them to carry structural loads. Now retired test pilot Jon Beesley says this in this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RQ5gmZ74YBY at 2:57. It's actually less costly, weight-wise, to build the aircraft structure without holes. For background, the aircraft that he's standing in front of is AA-1, which is the first F-35 aircraft. It represented a design that was 5000 pounds or so overweight. Many changes were done before the next F-35 to roll out, resulting in the current overall config.

So in reality we are probably doing much of what you suggested, even though that was not the original intention. They share engines (well, the STOVL variant engine is a different part number because it has to interface with the lift fan, but it's highly similar) and electronics.

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by nickpsecurity on Friday July 31, 2015 @11:20PM (#9985770)
He implied his involvement in this stuff in his own statements. He's clearly got an attachment. That's fine, though, so long as he backs up claims with evidence and we can focus on quality of claims/evidence. An example of that is the F-16 vs F-35 thread we have going on where he's produced useful links.
Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by engi_nerd on Friday July 31, 2015 @11:26PM (#9985795)
I'm a numbers and figures guy, I want to be judged on the quality of what I present. I admit to being passionate about what we're talking about here. But I am trying not to let that cloud my arguments. Apologies if it has been that way.
Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by dang on Saturday August 01, 2015 @12:34AM (#9985933)
You have nothing to apologize for—on the contrary, the users making insinuations should be apologizing to you. Thank you for being a good sport about it.

(This is a procedural comment, not taking sides in the argument.)

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by nickpsecurity on Friday July 31, 2015 @11:45PM (#9985837)
I'm judging you on the quality of what you present so no apologies needed. It's the others that are worried about your background. I evaluate what you say and work from there to figure things out.
Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by nostrademons on Saturday August 01, 2015 @07:12AM (#9986639)
FWIW, when I read the David Axle piece, my immediate reaction was "This is a PR hit piece" based on the tone and emotional manipulation present in it. I don't know the actual facts behind the F-35 program - I'm about as far from the military-industrial complex as you can get. But I've seen PR spin and know how companies manipulate public opinion, and that piece set off some major alarm bells. I think someone else independently commented to that effect in the HN comments, as well.

One should not assume that the first piece you read about a subject is the correct one. It's not abnormal for someone to plant a story with a blogger for political gain, and something like that is actually far more likely than them planting it on a HN commenter (because it reaches a much wider audience and seems a lot more credible). If you're going to be paranoid about shills, astroturfing, and misinformation, at least be paranoid on all sides.

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by fnordfnordfnord on Saturday August 01, 2015 @12:17AM (#9985893)
Yup, and comments in other threads.

>I currently work as an aircraft telemetry and instrumentation engineer,

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9907687

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by dang on Saturday August 01, 2015 @12:29AM (#9985921)
You guys are out of line. You should be grateful that someone with professional expertise is here talking about what they know, not attempting to smear them.

Groundless insinuations of shillage and dishonesty are not ok here. They poison the discourse, and you owe greater respect to your fellow HNers. Please don't do this again.

All: please flag such comments when you see them in HN threads.

engi_nerd likes the F-35, lots of other people don't, that's fine. Have at it with arguments, not cheap shots.

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by engi_nerd on Saturday August 01, 2015 @12:42AM (#9985955)
Thank you. I think I've shown enough...what's an appropriate term, maybe human-ness? to effectively show that I'm not a shill. Nor do I seek to be dishonest in any way. I am not crazy about saying exactly where I work and exactly what I do, but isn't that true for a lot of HNers?

I'm willing to speak to admins if necessary, in private, should they have any concerns they wish to discuss.

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by nickpsecurity on Saturday August 01, 2015 @12:46AM (#9985965)
I agree and this is how I've looked at the situation. The result of focusing on his points led to useful information on the subject which included spotting unreliability in popular sources and filtering down to real, risk areas on F-35 side. An example is below. Best to always focus on the what rather than the who with exception being people that want me to take their word for something. Guard goes way up.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9985044

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by engi_nerd on Saturday August 01, 2015 @12:52AM (#9985981)
Yeah, I'm not big on "appeal to authority" (obviously, as it's a logical fallacy). Don't take my word on any of this. I've tried to link to sources where appropriate. Read them at your leisure, and see what you think.
Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by fnordfnordfnord on Saturday August 01, 2015 @12:42AM (#9985953)
No, it's absolutely not out of line. Gaslighting, astroturfing, and worse are real things that happen on the internet. Note that I never said shill, though I would if I saw evidence that warranted it. I simply pointed out a relevant post from the commenter's history.

If you'll note, I think that engi_nerd and I achieved an amicable understanding of each other at about the same time you were posting your comment.

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by dang on Saturday August 01, 2015 @01:11AM (#9986042)
> it's absolutely not out of line

It's my job to draw the line.

> I never said shill

My comment was addressed to the three of you.

[I deleted an unfair bit here.]

> Gaslighting, astroturfing, and worse are real things that happen on the internet

Yes, I spend my days combating those things on HN and my evenings writing code to combat them on HN.

Something else that's real on the internet, and poisonous, is commenters groundlessly accusing each other of those things, or insinuating them. That affects civil discourse the way salt affects a slug. We're not letting it become a thing here. See https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&prefix=true&page=0&dateR... for countless further explanations.

Anyone with genuine concerns about astroturfing on HN should email them to us at [email protected]. We promise to take them seriously. We also promise to look for evidence.

> engi_nerd and I achieved an amicable understanding of each other

I hope so. I don't believe anyone meant harm or even did anything very harmful, but we've learned that places like HN are vulnerable to tragedies of the commons: small, unintentional slips add up to systemic toxicity. That's the default, so there has to be a countervailing vector. Also, the ganging-up-on spirit that was emerging there was dismaying.

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by engi_nerd on Saturday August 01, 2015 @01:37AM (#9986090)
As I said earlier, dang, I am happy to reach out to you or someone else with HN and address any concerns you might have if you would like. All I wanted to do was discuss an area I have professional expertise in. It's a niche area so I don't get to discuss it much...
Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by dang on Saturday August 01, 2015 @01:49AM (#9986106)
Thank you; I don't think it's necessary. Your comments have been civil and substantive and interesting. We very much want people who work in a given area to be discussing their area on HN. It raises the quality of the threads, often dramatically.

(I don't know who's right about the F-35, and haven't even read the comments from that angle. My point is procedural: debates here must stay factual and not go personal.)

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by engi_nerd on Saturday August 01, 2015 @02:06AM (#9986125)
I believe it is probably like most things in this world. It is far better than its most virulent critics would have you believe, and probably worse than its most ardent defenders would have you believe. The truth is somewhere in the murky middle.
Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by enraged_camel on Saturday August 01, 2015 @01:34AM (#9986084)
>>Indeed, I spend my days combating those things on HN and my evenings writing code to combat them on HN. >>Something else that's real on the internet, and poisonous, is commenters groundlessly accusing each other of those things, or insinuating them.

But you haven't demonstrated why engi_nerd is not gaslighting and astroturfing.

No one is denying that he has experience that's relevant to the topic. What people have an issue with is that he has repeatedly defended major shortcomings in the design of the craft with shoddy reasoning such as "oh, guns won't come into play in most combat scenarios, so it's OK for the guns on the F-35 to not work."

If that's the type of low-quality discourse you want on HN, fine. We'll stop pointing it out. But accusing us of unreasonably calling him out is pretty shitty.

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by dang on Saturday August 01, 2015 @01:43AM (#9986096)
> But you haven't demonstrated why engi_nerd is not gaslighting and astroturfing.

That's not where the burden of proof lies. You can't accuse someone of these things on HN without evidence. An opposing opinion is not evidence.

It's true that working on something professionally biases one. But (a) we're all subject to that, and (b) distance from a situation has biases too. It's a foul to invoke these things as personal weapons, and we intervene when people do it because it tears the fabric of the community.

If what someone says is wrong, refute it. If you're right, you should be able to demonstrate it civilly.

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by enraged_camel on Saturday August 01, 2015 @04:25AM (#9986377)
>>If what someone says is wrong, refute it. If you're right, you should be able to demonstrate it civilly.

That's what I'm saying: it's not about being right or wrong. Engi_nerd has responded to every criticism thrown at the F-35 by using shoddy reasoning and hand-waving, such as "The F-35 is a complex answer to a complex question, and it cannot be so simply understood." I mean, seriously? That sounds like something a politician would say. Or a company spokesperson. So of course everyone got the impression that he has an ulterior motive.

Anyway, I'm going to stop here, but I want to say that I'm disappointed in the way you handled this. I hope you understand. Have a nice day.

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by dang on Saturday August 01, 2015 @12:57PM (#9987710)
There might be a misunderstanding here. I'm not endorsing engi_nerd's arguments. I haven't properly read them. They may be just as you say. But even if they're that and worse, you can't commit the foul of accusing someone without evidence. This is a narrow, procedural point. It has nothing to do with anyone's shoddy arguments, let alone anyone's trillion-dollar fighter plane, but only with the HN community, which we all have to take care of.

Making wrong and evasive arguments is bad, but destroying civil discourse (which such accusations do) is, to use a good military-industrial phrase, an existential threat. That's why we intervene when we see it.

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by engi_nerd on Saturday August 01, 2015 @01:37PM (#9987872)
If my arguments are bad, then people here are free to offer counter arguments. If I am unclear, ask me for clarification, and I'll try to clarify. If I am making an evasive argument, call me on it, and I'll either attempt to refine it to be more substantial or, if I cannot, then I will admit my error and move on. I think that kind of discussion is what you are trying to preserve here on HN, and I'm all for it. I really do love this site.
Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by engi_nerd on Saturday August 01, 2015 @10:33AM (#9987148)
...It's the answer of a guy who is familiar with the hairy reality of engineering systems because he has years of engineering experience and wrestles with those systems every day. A few days ago someone was talking about John Gall and his classic work, "Systemantics". The principles described there closely relate to what I'm talking about.

1) Everything is a system. 2) Everything is part of a larger system (ex. the military industrial complex) 3) All systems are infinitely complex.

The F-35 is an infinitely complex system of systems operating in a system of systems (the MIC) that, to pull an analogy from Cantor, is a higher order of infinite complexity.

I didn't elaborate enough on that original point for you. You could have asked me for clarification and I would have been happy to try, as I have done here (look at my interactions with nickpsecurity -- I don't think I'm such a bad guy as you are portraying).

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by engi_nerd on Saturday August 01, 2015 @01:46AM (#9986100)
Well, if you really want to go there, the gun itself works, as I pointed out. It fires in the aircraft, on the ground, as I posted a video of. And as others said and I do not argue with, the software for full integration of the gun isn't implemented yet. I did say that the program -- rightly or wrongly -- chose to work on the gun after making sure lots of other weapons work first. Clearly this is a choice that you disagree with. That's fine. Ideally everything would be working and things would go smoothly.

While I may not be the most fuzzy warm or eloquent guy in the room, I try to stick to facts. I am more or less successful, as humans tend to be. I deeply resent my discourse being called "low-quality" and would hope to correct that impression in the future.

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by nostrademons on Saturday August 01, 2015 @07:05AM (#9986626)
Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by swah on Monday August 03, 2015 @06:43AM (#9994862)
I like this - is it similar to c2.com?
Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by nostrademons on Monday August 03, 2015 @01:37PM (#9998094)
Yeah, Meatball was/is another one of the pre-Wikipedia forks of C2, focusing on the dynamics of online communities and social forces. It was a fair bit more touchy-feely than C2, because instead of the technical aspects it includes a lot of applied psychology and sociology and observances on how groups behave.
Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by fnordfnordfnord on Saturday August 01, 2015 @01:50AM (#9986108)
It's my job to draw the line.

Yeah well umm... Fair enough, you got me dead to rights on that one.

>You tried to dig up dirt on someone from their history. Not that it was dirt,

I was looking to see if the poster ever had anything to say about any other topic. It wasn't dirt, it was a fact. It was the poster's own words. Words to the effect that they are employed in aerospace, which was disclosed elsewhere ITT, and was directly responsive to the parent, and isn't worth concealing in any case.

>but the intent to use it personally makes it so.

Now you're being unfair to me. It's not personal. Authentication and trust are hard in a plain ASCII message board, even harder in Unicode; it's just a condition of discussion boards. Think of it as diligence.

>Indeed, I spend my days combating

Gratzi, and bless you for it. (in the non-theistic sense, or by a deity of your choosing).

>I don't believe anyone meant harm or even did anything very harmful...

No, and you're right. I am grateful to have smart people to argue with, and grateful that this place isn't a wasteland.

>There has to be a countervailing role, and for the time being that's me.

Thanks for reaching out instead of reaching for the banhammer & enjoy your weekend.

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by dang on Saturday August 01, 2015 @02:10AM (#9986135)
> Now you're being unfair to me.

In that case, I'm sorry. I wasn't happy with how I worded that bit, and I've deleted it from my comment.

I don't agree with you about diligence, though. There's something not right about searching through someone's personal or posting history for ammunition in an argument. It seems to me a foul in the local sport. But I don't yet know how to express this precisely.

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by fnordfnordfnord on Saturday August 01, 2015 @02:43AM (#9986185)
No worries. This is the first time I've interacted with you, and I don't completely agree with everything you've said, but I do think you've been completely fair. I don't mind if you're a bit more pre-emptory than I might have been if it keeps the knives put away in these threads.

>There's something not right about searching through someone's history

But those are things that the person posted publicly. Why is there anything untoward about browsing a person's public comment history (for relevant posts)? What else is it there for? They can and should delete it if they don't want it to remain. Sometimes a quick check of a comment history is all that's needed to see a pretty consistent bias (or other problems). I'm talking about really obvious stuff. It's a reddit reflex, and not all that useful here compared to there.

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by engi_nerd on Saturday August 01, 2015 @02:52AM (#9986197)
I think your comments, in conjunction with enraged_camel's, might have given the impression that you were preparing to gang up on me.

I'm a little perplexed. Had this discussion been about the more normal HN fare, it would have been quite different. It's, as another user said, about the miilitary/industrial complex elephant. What would you have me do? You seem to be a decent enough person. Would you have me email you and let us have a discussion there, privately? Even then, you would still have no way of really knowing that anything I told you is true (although I would not lie to you, you have no way to verify, really).

I do tend to comment on aerospace matters. Primarily because that's what I do. I am a recreational programmer and do write some code at work...So my interests overlap a bit with what HN finds interesting. But I don't solely restrict myself to them...

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by fnordfnordfnord on Saturday August 01, 2015 @11:07AM (#9987256)
>I think your comments, in conjunction with enraged_camel's

It wasn't coordinated, I can't even recall if I have ever replied to camel's posts before today.

>I'm a little perplexed. Had this discussion been about the more normal HN fare, it would have been quite different.

If it involves politics, surveillance, defense/aerospace, criminal or civil law, securities trading, feminism/women in tech, encryption, Linus Torvalds, etc, there is a likelihood of a spirited debate. I've probably forgotten a few subjects, but the F-35 is not the only issue that people get [perhaps too] excited about.

>Would you have me email you and let us have a discussion there, privately?

No thank you, I have no desire to have an argument in private about the F-35. I'm not even sure why I spend any time at all on the subject other than I like tech and flying, and in attempting to be an informed consumer of government. My email is easy to find if you need to for some reason but I really prefer having these discussions in public.

>It's, as another user said, about the military/industrial complex elephant.

There's more than one elephant. There are plenty who object to the fact that we put any effort into killing people. Various degrees of us who'd just like to kill a lot fewer people. And then those who don't mind killing people, but want it to be done efficiently. And, I think those who are indifferent to the killing of people, as long as they can get rich off of it (no, that's not meant to be a cheap-shot at salary-people who work in defense).

>What would you have me do?

As I said previously. I think you should disclose your association with the defense/aerospace industry, and you should do that when you join a discussion. I would feel the same if you were employed in most any other industry, and commenting in a similar manner. You don't need to reveal your location or employer or anything like that; and frankly, you need to tolerate or at least expect some skepticism about your motives.

>I do tend to comment on aerospace matters. Primarily because that's what I do.

Then you must no doubt be familiar with the fact that the F-35 project is controversial both inside and outside the .mil and the defense industry. The internet is lousy with these kinds of discussions; it's the greatest peanut gallery the world has ever known. In some of these discussions are a few people who'd apparently like to have us all believe that the F-35 is going to win all of the battles against any adversary anywhere, any time, at any place, ever; do it all for cheap, and then precision-airdrop hot-buttered toast and letters from mom to the ground troops on its way home. I'm glad that you've attempted to constrain your posts to facts which can be confirmed, but also remember that the facts are suspect where it involves next-get .mil-tech. The .mil may or may not [probably won't] release info that could damage the project, and they won't release full performance specs, either; under the naive notion/excuse that potential adversaries can't get that kind of information.

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by engi_nerd on Saturday August 01, 2015 @11:17AM (#9987311)
> As I said previously. I think you should disclose your association with the defense/aerospace industry, and you should do that when you join a discussion. I would feel the same if you were employed in most any other industry, and commenting in a similar manner. You don't need to reveal your location or employer or anything like that; and frankly, you need to tolerate or at least expect some skepticism about your motives.

Yes, I am an engineer in defense and aerospace. I haven't hidden that fact on HN (as you saw) but I didn't mention it explicitly in this thread because I didn't think it was necessarily relevant. I'm very conscious of "appeal to authority" and I don't want to make it seem as though I am saying that I must be right because of what I do for a living. And I thought I had been fairly tolerant.

Edit: I should clarify "necessarily relevant with respect to the facts". I link to public sources where appropriate. Anyone can do so, no matter who they are. Strictly in this context, my affiliation doesn't matter.

> The .mil may or may not [probably won't] release info that could damage the project, and they won't release full performance specs, either; under the naive notion/excuse that potential adversaries can't get that kind of information.

Why make it easy for them? And yes, I'm very very aware that the F-35 is very controversial. But I see so much misinformation that sometimes I feel compelled to point out where/how the correct information can be found.

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by engi_nerd on Saturday August 01, 2015 @12:22AM (#9985904)
Correct. No denying this. But I'm not here to be a jerk or a shill. Just talking about things I have some experience with.
Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by fnordfnordfnord on Saturday August 01, 2015 @12:32AM (#9985928)
You've got a connection to the industry, and an apparent emotional response to F-35 criticism. (but who wants to about a subject which they are indifferent to? That's no fun.) For all we know your livelihood may depend in some way upon the F-35. I'm not saying you're always wrong, but I am going to naturally skeptical.
Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by engi_nerd on Saturday August 01, 2015 @12:37AM (#9985942)
I have admitted my passion elsewhere in this thread. Is the population of HN not passionate about things? This is, from my years long lurking of the site (I have lurked here since at least 2009 that I can clearly remember) one of the places on the internet where passion can be shared in a responsible way. I do not seek to bash those who doubt the plane on a personal level. What I would hope is that I address their objections from fact. Now, if the facts support their arguments, then I would like to think that I would be the first to admit that. But if the facts are otherwise, then I hope I've done a good job of linking to and explaining public information.

And this interaction has sort of confirmed why I am always hesitant to talk about what I do (aside from the obvious reasons why people in this industry are encouraged to not say much), because people see that and make some disparaging remarks. I am not thrilled.

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by nitrogen on Saturday August 01, 2015 @12:54AM (#9985990)
I am not thrilled.

Only quoting final sentence since I'm typing this on a phone... Without excusing the behavior of your accusers, I think it's probably motivated by the association between the incredibly fascinating engineering work, and the military "work" to which that engineering will later be applied. It's always going to be difficult to converse productively with such an elephant in the room, but your patience in the thread is exemplary.

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by engi_nerd on Saturday August 01, 2015 @01:20AM (#9986057)
To be blunt: you wind up working on things that are explicitly designed to kill other human beings. That is what you are saying. That's the elephant. Many here would find such a thing immoral and unethical. I know that. I have my own personal reasons for doing what I do. They make sense for my own life.

So fnordfnordfnord already linked to a comment where I mention working on sounding rockets (in addition to the aircraft/telemetry) Those are for purely scientific research. I've done the peaeceful engineering thing, I guess.

And the program does some good science! But if you look at my comment history more, I have some comments where I talk about working in a really bad environment. Guess what? Same place, the sounding rocket program. So I left and changed jobs. To be honest, I try not to worry about all of this so much, mainly because I'm actually happy to go to work now. I am, however, usually happy to discuss this seeming contradiction of trying to be a moral/ethical person while working in aerospace... Just because I don't think about it every day doesn't mean I haven't examined and reflected upon it.

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by fnordfnordfnord on Saturday August 01, 2015 @01:05AM (#9986025)
>Is the population of HN not passionate about things?

Of course. And by the way, my skepticism of your motives isn't meant to be taken personal. Apologies if you're insulted.

Maybe it's just me, but I think it's appropriate/proper to disclose in advance that you work in aerospace if you're going to argue pro or against a huge aerospace defense project.

Since the disclosure of the existence of things like JTRIG and some of the HB Gary antics I don't think it is too far-fetched that one might encounter some sketchy things in discussion forums.

>(aside from the obvious reasons why people in this industry are encouraged to not say much)

I'll tell you that a comment you made earlier made my spidey-sense tingle. You mentioned not linking some already-leaked to the public report because it is ITAR controlled, and that pretty much makes you as a person who has a clearance/connection to military/defense work.

>because people see that and make some disparaging remarks. I am not thrilled.

You can't make everyone like you, especially if your identity is tied to a politically polarizing industry; and you definitely can't make everyone like tremendously expensive weapons projects. Even then, it's not personal. Some of the people who are unabashedly critical of defense/aerospace may well have some very good reasons for it.

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by engi_nerd on Saturday August 01, 2015 @11:11AM (#9987273)
I don't expect everyone to like me. I don't expect everyone to like the plane, either. There are days when I don't like it very much.

What you did seemed very personal to me in the moment I read your comment. I got a sinking feeling in my chest. Because I don't know who you are, and what your motives are. Now, from seeing further discussion with you, I don't think you mean anything malicious, but I had that little momentary stab of unease.

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by fnordfnordfnord on Saturday August 01, 2015 @11:40AM (#9987412)
>I don't expect everyone to like me.

You're just some random person who comments on the same message board. I doubt I've ever met you, or will meet you in person; but if we were at a backyard barbecue, who knows, we might become pals. I don't require my friends to be a facsimile of me. Like I said it wasn't personal.

>What you did seemed very personal to me in the moment I read your comment.

I found that comment on the second page of your HN history. If you don't want anyone to know it you need to rethink the kinds things you post here.

>I got a sinking feeling in my chest.

Why?

>I don't think you mean anything malicious

What could possibly have been malicious about my perusal of two pages of your post history and my post. Another poster suggested that you might work in defense/aerospace (and therefore may have an ulterior motive). I posted a snippet from your history that suggests that you may indeed be employed in defense/aerospace. Those were your words. I made no remarks disparaging defense/aerospace workers, and I don't make moral judgements against people who choose that as a career.

>I had that little momentary stab of unease.

What end do you think I was trying to achieve?

Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat by engi_nerd on Saturday August 01, 2015 @11:58AM (#9987496)
I do not try to hide it -- see other comments. I have no problems saying that I am an aircraft instrumentation engineer, nor am I under any obligations to hide that fact.

I got that feeling because it seemed as if you might have been trying to say that my affiliation with the industry made anything I say suspect. Not all of us are shills, or have some ulterior motives. I just have knowledge of what's being discussed, and I wanted to share it.

What could have been malicious? I didn't know. Probably nothing. These are emotional responses I had, they do not have rational bases.

I have no idea what you were trying to achieve, to be honest. But you have addressed that you meant nothing personal, and I accept this.