Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat
by engi_nerd on Friday July 31, 2015 @09:09PM
(#9985411)
> Replacing the harrier with the same craft is an engineering nightmare.
This is another misconception. The F-35 emerged from a DARPA study in the 80s to create a stealthy STOVL aircraft. The F-35 as designed started with the F-35B. The other two variants were created through modifications to this design.
Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat
by alkonaut on Saturday August 01, 2015 @03:17AM
(#9986246)
The outcome is the same: replacing the 16/16/18 with a craft that is also the future stovl craft, is an engineering nightmare.
Re:The Marines say the F-35 is now ready for combat
by engi_nerd on Saturday August 01, 2015 @10:58AM
(#9987213)
All aircraft are engineering nightmares from the perspective of the engineers who work on them. It's a very stressful and difficult field.
That's not to really argue for or against your point, but more of a personal observation.
The problem with the F-35 project is mostly that it somehow was decided to replace the Harrier. Replacing the F-15/16/18 isn't a problems. Replacing the harrier with the same craft is an engineering nightmare.
Upgrading old platforms is done continuously, up to a point where an upgrade would be so expensive/radical that a new design is better. Sticking more electronics in an old plane isn't easy, the power and cooling requirements can require big redesigns, for example.
The planes it replaces are certainly near the end of their lifespans and have been upgraded a lot over several decades. What they should have done is not make just one plane. A replacement for the F-15/16/18 would have been much easier.