> it can be easy to fool the system and gain free songs
I'm not sure what you mean by this. If you have Apple Music, you already have access to the entire catalog, so there's no trickery to gain "free songs", because they're already available. And if you don't have Apple Music, you can't do this either, because iTunes Match exclusively uses acoustic fingerprinting[1] to ensure you can never download a song you didn't already have.
[1] For non-purchased content. For purchased content they obviously already know you own it.
It definitely does do acoustic fingerprinting since I've never had or continue to have issues with my music being swapped out for something else.
Absolutely. I have a number of mix CDs (above and beyond, mainly) where apple music has apparently looked up the songs by title and artist only and replaced all the tracks in a mix CD with single versions of those songs, needless to say not mixed. I also have other songs which simply refuse to sync.
The article says: If you subscribe to both iTunes Match and Apple Music, then iTunes matches your songs using digital fingerprinting - but I thought Apple Music included iTunes match. Do I seriously have to sign up for another product as well to get this working? Not very impressed.
Some people have mentioned that it can be easy to fool the system and gain free songs, but paying $9/month for Apple Music gives you access to every song either online or offline and you can add them to your library.
iTunes Match however is a different thing and they likely have to be almost sure the song you have is the song you should get access to from the iTunes Store.