News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Need Clean-Energy Innovation, and Lots of It by melling on Thursday July 30, 2015 @08:42PM (#9979261)
Didn't Google drop RE<C because they realized current technologies weren't enough?

http://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/google-engineers...

"Trying to combat climate change exclusively with today’s renewable energy technologies simply won’t work; we need a fundamentally different approach," wrote Google's Ross Koningstein and David Fork in a piece published yesterday in IEEE's Spectrum"

Re:We Need Clean-Energy Innovation, and Lots of It by Retric on Thursday July 30, 2015 @11:25PM (#9979755)
Wind is often < Coal, even some solar can beat coal. (EX: Hawaii) So, they needed a new focus.
Re:We Need Clean-Energy Innovation, and Lots of It by crpatino on Thursday July 30, 2015 @09:40PM (#9979446)
You cannot combat climate change by producing electricity cheaper than coal. If that was the case, the market would find a way not to replace coal, but to consume the extra on top of coal.
Re:We Need Clean-Energy Innovation, and Lots of It by toomuchtodo on Thursday July 30, 2015 @10:10PM (#9979544)
> If that was the case, the market would find a way not to replace coal, but to consume the extra on top of coal.

That's not how PPAs and generation works. Nuclear power is already barely viable in the Illinois market (dominated by Exelon) because wind sells its power so much cheaper.

There's a new generation facility coming online near Vegas that's going to be selling solar at around 4 cents/kwh, the lowest price in the nation.

Cheap renewables don't get consumed above existing fossil generation; cheap renewables push out existing fossil fuel generation. For an example, see Germany and how their utilities can barely keep some generation running because they don't get enough revenue with solar dominating during daylight hours.

Solution: Continue to heavily subsidize solar, wind, utility-scale battery storage. Continue to shut down coal plants. Purchase peaking combined cycle natural gas generators, put them into non-profits (because they won't be profitable) to meet the generation gap until enough utility-scale battery storage can allow renewables to be firmly dispatchable resources (they can be relied on to provide power at a constant rate, vs intermittent resources). Profit (or rather, help stop climate change).

Re:We Need Clean-Energy Innovation, and Lots of It by afarrell on Friday July 31, 2015 @12:49AM (#9979978)
This is true. A lot of people don't realize that bulk electricity prices are paid to all generators based on the price of the marginal watt to be scheduled. Natural gas turbines can turn on and off quickly, so they can respond to the market and are usually the ones to provide that marginal watt.

That means when natural gas prices decrease, so do profits for nuclear, coal, and hydro plants.

Google "location based marginal pricing" to learn more.

Re:We Need Clean-Energy Innovation, and Lots of It by ZeroGravitas on Friday July 31, 2015 @04:39AM (#9980611)
This is true, but so is the comment you reply to.

The changes are not occurring purely because the renewables are getting cheaper and cheaper, but also because of (whisper it) benign regulation of the grid and air quality etc., which prioritises renewable and disincentives dirty coal power.

I approve of your solution (though with a carbon tax I'm not sure that wind and solar need subsidies any more), though I'm not sure why the peaker gas plants need to go non-profit. They already get paid lots of money for short periods operating on an intermittent basis, so it's only a minor modification of their current business model. And if you have a specific dollar value on their use (including a portion for carbon production) then you have a ready made business model for utility-scale storage technologies to replace and a finincial incentive for the tech to be developed.

Re:We Need Clean-Energy Innovation, and Lots of It by danmaz74 on Friday July 31, 2015 @01:13PM (#9982922)
> coming online near Vegas that's going to be selling solar at around 4 cents/kwh

The big problem there is that they'll sell you that energy when they have it, not when you need it. Production is really becoming cheap with renewables; storage is the real problem (and a very big one).

Re:We Need Clean-Energy Innovation, and Lots of It by toomuchtodo on Friday July 31, 2015 @01:47PM (#9983140)
Correct. I mention utility-scale battery storage for that very reason. Until you have utility-scale battery storage, you burn natural gas to make up the difference. Faster response time than coal or nuclear, less carbon output than coal, easier to move across the country, no radioactive waste to store onsite "temporarily" for decades.

Hydro could help, but in places with almost no water (California/Nevada), it can't be relied on.

Re:We Need Clean-Energy Innovation, and Lots of It by shoo on Thursday July 30, 2015 @10:17PM (#9979574)
> a fundamentally different approach

Here are some ideas:

1. adjust the rules regulating the market (e.g. price greenhouse gas emissions correctly)

2. introduce a tax on advertising to discourage unnecessary consumption

3. ensure the price of products and services includes full life cycle costs of disposal and pollution

4. replace the whole "economic growth" philosophy with something else that is consistent and reconcilable with planetary ecological limits

5. encourage non-coercive measures to discourage population growth (e.g. access to contraception, family planning, give women increased options for education and employment), particularly in the more affluent countries which have very high per-capita environmental footprints

6. discourage population growth as above, and provide increased economic opportunities, for people living in less affluent countries, since people are able to move between countries to seek better opportunities for themselves. Or instead invest in the rather less ethical "Fortress $(countryname)" approach to keep out the people unfortunate enough to be born in the wrong part of the globe.

Tangentially, you may be interested in Donella Meadows' "Leverage Points: Places to Intervene in a System" [1].

[1] -- http://www.donellameadows.org/archives/leverage-points-place...

Re:We Need Clean-Energy Innovation, and Lots of It by TheSpiceIsLife on Friday July 31, 2015 @05:57AM (#9980849)
1. Adjusting the rules regulating markets sounds a lot like governments picking winners, which they are notoriously bad at. Also, What is the correct price for greenhouse gases?

2. See 1 above

3. Seems like a sound idea, probably very difficult to determine the correct price of pollution per above.

4. What are the planetary ecological limits? "Replace the whole [whatever] philosophy" is a good example of expecting everyone to agree, which is probably impossible.

5. The more affluent countries tend to have lower birth rates already (a few bordering on being below replacement rate, Japan for example IIRC) probably because they have better access to things like education and contraception etc. So it seems lower birthrates tend to correlate with higher per capita environmental footprints, probably because the same things that cause lower birthrates also cause higher standards of living. Maybe the solution is to simply increase the birthrate, thereby decreasing per capita consumption. Maybe that's the wrong metric to focus on. What a mess.

6. As above.

Sometimes I think it would be better if solutions were as simple as enumerating a list. But what's the fun in that. Heaven forbid problems could be solved so simply, then what would we do.

One thing we can be certain of, probably, is that whatever changes we implement will have unintended consequences. So maybe the solution is to do nothing in an effort to avoid the unintended consequences, thereby leaving us to deal with the obvious consequences of business as usual, whatever they might be. What I'm implying is: maybe the GOP have got it right. Wouldn't that be ironic.

This comment was heavily inspired by P.J. O'rourke, I highly recommend his books. Politics hey, what a circus.

NB: I don't necessarily agree with anything I write, so don't hold me to it.

Re:We Need Clean-Energy Innovation, and Lots of It by eevilspock on Thursday July 30, 2015 @11:26PM (#9979760)
> 4. replace the whole "economic growth" philosophy with something else that is consistent and reconcilable with planetary ecological limits

Sadly Capitalism and the ideology that Americans and now it seems the entire world has bought into won't allow that.

I agree with Jimmy Carter: "The U.S. Is an "Oligarchy With Unlimited Political Bribery"[1]

See also Yes, We’re Corrupt”: A List of Politicians Admitting That Money Controls Politics[2]

-

[1] https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2015/07/30/jimmy-carter-u...

[2] https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2015/07/30/politicians-ad...

Re:We Need Clean-Energy Innovation, and Lots of It by raverbashing on Friday July 31, 2015 @02:49AM (#9980307)
> Sadly Capitalism and the ideology that Americans and now it seems the entire world has bought

Oh the whole world hasn't bough it. North Korea is still free from it. Cuba seems to have regretted it though

Re:We Need Clean-Energy Innovation, and Lots of It by shoo on Friday July 31, 2015 @03:39AM (#9980458)
As an aside from the discussion of capitalism versus other economic systems, Cuba provides a historical case study of a society that didn't collapse after experiencing severe shortages of fossil fuels. See e.g. [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_Period

Re:We Need Clean-Energy Innovation, and Lots of It by happyscrappy on Friday July 31, 2015 @07:10AM (#9981087)
Not believing in capitalism is like not believing in evolution. The fringes on both sides are ridiculous. Both require willful disregard of reality.
Re:We Need Clean-Energy Innovation, and Lots of It by eevilspock on Friday July 31, 2015 @08:08AM (#9981224)
Please, do better than putting up straw men, especially the ridiculous false choice between Capitalism and dictatorship.

And please also refrain from these other logical fallacies:

    - Domination proves superiority

    - Being better than bad solutions proves it is a good or even best solution.
There were times that the whole world bought into a bunch of stupid things:

    - creationism

    - slavery

    - patriarchy, sexism

    - kings as gods

    - gods as gods
Oh snap! Most have still bought into those things. Though in some cases (such as slavery) we've rebranded it (commoditized, capitalized labor).