News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Face swapping with Python, dlib, and OpenCV by JosephRedfern on Thursday July 30, 2015 @11:03AM (#9975440)
Bleurgh.
Re:Face swapping with Python, dlib, and OpenCV by bsenftner on Thursday July 30, 2015 @11:06AM (#9975453)
Would you rather people spend time developing in this area only to learn they can't use their work?
Re:Face swapping with Python, dlib, and OpenCV by StavrosK on Thursday July 30, 2015 @11:09AM (#9975484)
No, he would rather be free to use the code he wrote.
Re:Face swapping with Python, dlib, and OpenCV by bsenftner on Thursday July 30, 2015 @11:26AM (#9975640)
Which is the exact situation I found myself in: I began developing in this area, and learned of patents I needed to sidestep. Realizing a hole in the patent landscape, I filed to protect what I was doing.
Re:Face swapping with Python, dlib, and OpenCV by TranquilMarmot on Thursday July 30, 2015 @12:59PM (#9976316)
So now other people have to sidestep a sidestep?
Re:Face swapping with Python, dlib, and OpenCV by zo1 on Thursday July 30, 2015 @04:14PM (#9977698)
It's only an issue because the original "sidestepper" sold-off, or was perhaps bullied into selling (theory), the patent to an entity. An entity that will unfortunately just hold it in a "bag of tricks" until they need it, or decide to play with it, or decide to litigate with, or decide to "license" out usage of it to another big player willing to fork over money for it.

Had an innovative tinkerer kept it, then who knows what might have happened. But I'd take a wild guess and say that the odds are more likely that a such an innovator would allow others the use/play/profit off of their novel ideas than would a large entity that sees it as a potential avenue of competition.

Re:Face swapping with Python, dlib, and OpenCV by JosephRedfern on Thursday July 30, 2015 @11:09AM (#9975487)
I'm not saying that. It's just frustrating.
Re:Face swapping with Python, dlib, and OpenCV by bsenftner on Thursday July 30, 2015 @11:15AM (#9975527)
Try doing this 10 years ago, putting your life savings into it, and then VCs and media companies "not getting it", your money runs out, and then you have to sell your IP simply to pay the rent.
Re:Face swapping with Python, dlib, and OpenCV by JosephRedfern on Thursday July 30, 2015 @11:18AM (#9975568)
I'm not meaning to criticize you personally (at all). I'm just saying that the idea of being able to "declare ownership" of what is essentially a series of mathematical operations just doesn't feel quite right.

I realise that people have to make money some how, but developing a useful, competitive, monetisable product that people are able to choose to buy is, in my opinion, the way forwards. Patenting the technology so that you can operate without competition rather than developing your product to stay ahead of the competition "organically" seems like the wrong way of doing it to me.

Perhaps I'm an idealist, and need to get real...

Re:Face swapping with Python, dlib, and OpenCV by bsenftner on Thursday July 30, 2015 @11:41AM (#9975744)
I agree with you. But the patent system exists... A startup has to protect its work. Plus, when pitching for financing the first set of questions include "Is this patented?" If you answer no and don't have a valid reason why not, they tell you to get it patented and come back when that is done.
Re:Face swapping with Python, dlib, and OpenCV by mentat on Thursday July 30, 2015 @05:41PM (#9978392)
So, there are an infinite number of things that are just series of mathematical operations. It's the ones that are useful that matter. Why would we not compensate people for discovering them?
Re:Face swapping with Python, dlib, and OpenCV by harperlee on Thursday July 30, 2015 @12:10PM (#9975957)
This is a good comment, much better than the "Bleurgh" one, so I transferred you a vote (down there, up here).
Re:Face swapping with Python, dlib, and OpenCV by steve19 on Thursday July 30, 2015 @10:22PM (#9979593)
Way to play the victim card, after first playing the everyone-else-was-doing-it card!

"Los Angeles based MBA..."

Makes sense, I guess you learnt this two card trick in MBA 101 :)

Re:Face swapping with Python, dlib, and OpenCV by angersock on Thursday July 30, 2015 @11:14AM (#9975524)
If you and people like you hadn't patented these things, they would've been able to use their work.

Thanks for the warning, at least.

:(

Re:Face swapping with Python, dlib, and OpenCV by sosborn on Thursday July 30, 2015 @02:11PM (#9976838)
> If you and people like you hadn't patented these things, they would've been able to use their work.

Someone else would have done it and you would be in the same position you are now.

Re:Face swapping with Python, dlib, and OpenCV by bsenftner on Thursday July 30, 2015 @11:22AM (#9975613)
The patent system exists. When I filed, there were already dozens of patents in this area. I was simply trying to protect my own work for my startup.
Re:Face swapping with Python, dlib, and OpenCV by ksrm on Thursday July 30, 2015 @12:31PM (#9976091)
Your argument seems to be "everyone else is doing it, so it's fine". I'm not having a go at you, but that doesn't seem like a very strong argument.
Re:Face swapping with Python, dlib, and OpenCV by bsenftner on Thursday July 30, 2015 @01:02PM (#9976332)
I needed financing for my startup based on this technology. After an initial financing search, it became clear it had to be patented to get financing.

To some degree, patents are a mechanism forcing early technology companies into expensive legal engagements, which drain resources from the company, triggering hefty financing requirements, and a dilution of the inventor's equity.

It is a carefully crafted system that benefits the 1% entirely, and the remaining 99% are merely the crop they farm.

Re:Face swapping with Python, dlib, and OpenCV by AndrewKemendo on Thursday July 30, 2015 @01:32PM (#9976533)
Don't worry about the naysayers. I am in the same position as you right now as we are doing work with AR and computer vision that people/investors etc... don't get yet. Maybe we are too early in the market, but probably not. If we are too early then at least we have something that we can fall back on without losing everything we have put into it.

At the end of the day I have to be able to say that I did everything I could to make our technology "win" in the marketplace.

Re:Face swapping with Python, dlib, and OpenCV by angersock on Thursday July 30, 2015 @02:14PM (#9976863)
If we are too early then at least we have something that we can fall back on without losing everything we have put into it.

No, see, what'll happen is your patent will be bought up during your exit event/firesale, and then used to harass other people in the space.

Especially in AR/VR/whatever, there's a huge incentive to patent things which are fairly obvious with just a little applied engineering time, and which will be used to harass a lot of people later.

If you wanted your technology to "win", you should make it open and free (in the software sense) to use--as it is, you've just got some tepid AR entry in the backwards swamp that is AEC.

Re:Face swapping with Python, dlib, and OpenCV by AndrewKemendo on Thursday July 30, 2015 @02:20PM (#9976911)
Ha thanks for all the kind words. Actually our patents don't have to do with AEC and are actually pretty novel in the computer vision realm.

I actually ran the idea of putting our work for "free" by our current investors because I am a fan of FOSS but it's a non-starter when it comes to raising money and it's just a fact of life that we need investment to keep going.

Re:Face swapping with Python, dlib, and OpenCV by angersock on Thursday July 30, 2015 @02:58PM (#9977149)
At the end of the day, business is business. Good luck to you and your team!