Fascism has no perfect definition but the conflation of race, nation, and morality that is implicit throughout Tolkien is pretty much at the core of fascism (it's also responsible for many of the worst fantasy tropes).
Calling Tolkien a crypto fascist is a bit much — I doubt Tolkien had a fascist agenda — but Tolkien's tacitly assumed worldview is pretty disturbing upon examination.
Either that or he's perfectly well aware that Toklien was no kind of fascist and is using the term as a goad. If he said he thought that Tokien was a conservative, nobody would pay any attention and we wouldn't be having this debate. But now we are and I think that was probably his aim, to provoke people into thinking about the differences between their work.