If a candidate feels that there is a very good, publicly available demonstration of their knowledge (be it a project they're involved in, some open-source software, or participation in a technical forum or mailing list), they already have the ability to simply point that out to me in their cover letter, or other communications.
> It's meant to provide another dimension to assess the candidate
This is precisely the problem. It creates an additional dimension, but one that exists only for a subset of candidates and isn't easy to evaluate fairly. That seems likely to create an imbalanced hiring process.
Why should I pay for that? (or implicitly ask the candidate to pay to give it to me?)
Asking a candidate to effectively pay money to apply isn't "the way to their heart". It isn't necessarily legal or ethical either. Joel has described what high demand there is for the "great programmers". Is it plausible that these same great programmers are going to be paying money to be found?
I like Stackoverflow. I spent a month getting 1000+K reps and then realized I should stop and do some work.
I like the idea of integrated SO to job search. It's just that direction that this integration has been problematic, indeed it could plausibly called evil.
Also, life isn't fair. I don't see what fairness has to do with anything.
Uh, I wouldn't want to work for a company which showed blatant unfairness in its hiring. Similarly, most worthwhile companies don't want to show such unfairness. The companies that are unfair in hiring probably would be unfair in their treatment of employees once they get hired, etc..
The fact that someone spends time on the website answering questions shows they are passionate about programming and might be helpful people. Generally these are considered good traits.
It would be worthwhile to spend some time figuring this stuff out because it help you make a better choice. Good luck!
I agree that a raw number means very little, but the info gleaned from looking up their stackoverflow account can tell you quite a bit.
Do you really see that much value, versus simply asking all candidates 'Are there any publicly accessible technical forums or mailing lists that you participate on a regular basis? If so, are you willing to share your username?'
I prefer the latter, because it's a question I can ask all candidates, and it doesn't cost me $5,000 to ask. Nor does it cost you $99 to answer.
The reality is that I'd never just use StackOverflow to find candidates, so these are people who have other ways to find out about the positions, and apply.
I'd rather see the candidate spend the money on an ACM membership (or similar professional development) than spend it simply trying to reach me.
That said, I think I now have a pretty good idea of the value proposition as it might exist for other employers, but it seems clear that the equation doesn't balance for me. Thanks for clarifying your argument, I appreciate it.
Joining ACM: just a plain bad idea. Only value is older papers not available ungated on citeseer or elsewhere.
If suddenly 20% of my candidates have a CV that includes some "reputation" score, and other information from a programming website, what am I to do with that?
Does it mean they spend time on stackoverflow instead of working? Does it mean they're a genius who knows all? Does it mean they simply ask and answer a lot of simple questions, but are useless on complex matters? Do I really want to try to figure that out?
In the end, I want to do apples to apples comparisons, and I'm not sure how SO Careers fits in there.
Are there suggested Best Practices for how to integrate SO Careers into a candidate search? Perhaps somebody can enlighten me if I'm missing something, but I don't get it.