$100 per customer now to prevent them from locking into the iPhone isn't quite so ludicrous if you also have a long-term strategy to get that money back (and then some) using the advertising in the shipped google services.
Besides, you have a war chest for just such things... but instead of spending it on acquisitions you can use it to help buy customers, they become happy with you too.
http://www.techcrunch.com/2009/03/01/what-an-antitrust-case-...
Over a year, everyone with android will probably have supplied Google with hundreds of dollars of mobile search revenue.
If the Gphone sells for a low price, and in very high quantities, they will probably lose for every one sold, but will make much more per user than the $100-200 lost on production.
It also means more sticky users in the long run, popularizing android and turning more people towards google. More apps would be developed, other android phones will presumably sell more (unless the contrary happens, in which case it is the Gphone that sells, which means even more money for Google).
I reckon that over the course of a year (the average length of time at which users change their phones), you'd generate Google more (if not much more) than $100 in explicit and implicit revenue.
I mean, it's one thing if their big competitor here was Microsoft or, in other words, Bing. But iPhone already uses Google by default.
Just a quick math. Assuming there are about 300mil frequent users of google (i.e more than the occasional search) in the western world. If 4.5 billions came from them, that would be about $15 per user per quarter, so about $60 per year.
Assuming that the google phone user is going to be one of these heavy users, if mobile user are worth $60 per year, then a $100 subsidy doesn't sound that bad, but still, very far fetched.
People would be buying them in droves, and using them in china/india/whatever developing country you think, and there is no way google would be making $60 per year from them.
What I don't believe at all is the 29/mo data plan. There is no way att or t-mobile will put up with this. Remember, the device has to connect to something, otherwise it is just an ipod with wifi.
The other alternative is wimax. Their network would be perfect for something like this, but they are not nation wide yet.
My bet is that android 2.1 will have wimax support.
Mobile WiMAX is still a long ways off.
For that to be an annual number, however, sounds pretty reasonable, especially given Google's asking price for an annual ad-free Google Apps subscription: $50.
Playstation 3, Xbox 360 . . . or are we just talking cell phones here?
Google's source of revenue isn't just selling the phone, similarly Microsoft and Sony's source of revenue wasn't from selling the console. It's all about selling the content and getting people to keep coming back for it.
Perhaps a $99 phone would be absurd for a state of the art smartphone, however making a loss wouldn't be absurd when google is making money off of every search you make, every youtube video you watch and submit.