The article's responds with the nonsensical "Some damage to our theories of physics is an acceptable payoff if we get a working space drive."
EDIT: Let me clarify why it's a nonsensical statement:
First, I think it meant to say "cost", not "payoff". Second, there would be no cost. None of the things we were able to do with our existing theories would be lost. We'd only be pushed to refine the theories (or in rare cases come up with an entirely new theories) that would be at least as accurate as the prior theories and cover phenomenon the old didn't. If anything, we'd be able to go back and do better at all the things to which we'd applied the old theories.
It's like saying "Some damage to Newtonian physics is an acceptable cost if we get a working understanding of relativity and gravity." Einstein did no "damage" to Newtonian physics. He made it better.
People seem to regard scientific progress as this kind of wave function, where some theory comes along and then some other theory or discovery disproves the previous one and so on and so forth.
But if you want to think of scientific progress that way, then you have to think of it as a dampened sine wave (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Damped_sine_wave) -- that is, discoveries and theories tend to refine previous discoveries and theories, and scientific progress over the millenia has been rapidly zeroing in on the truths of our reality.
What is left at this point is mostly things at very large scales -- cosmological stuff like dark matter, dark energy -- and very small scales -- stuff like sub-subatomic particles and the Higgs boson and the nature of mass and so on -- and very complex things like biology and climate science.
What isn't left at this point is a revision of the laws of conservation. It is exceedingly unlikely that anything will be discovered at any point in the future which will do anything other than add perhaps the very smallest of exceptions to those laws, and even then, I doubt very much that will happen.
So, essentially, the age of physics discoveries in garages is mostly over. There will be many more discoveries in physics, but they now require the collective efforts of entire nations.
http://chem.tufts.edu/answersinscience/relativityofwrong.htm
Asimov naturally describes it much better than I could.
You might be correct in saying that humans have characterized particles, objects, and phenomena that are closest to their scale and location, but we have done a poor job of understanding their fundamental nature. We also don't understand and have not even characterized things we've never observed (the 'black swan' problem).
As a physicist I really can't imagine what answer would satisfy you and could be falsifiable the same time. It is what it is, all we can do is to characterize its behavior.
I'm not saying that asking what light is is not an important question. But there is a possibility that there is simply no answer and yet we can have fully working physics. At least nobody will question your theories just because you don't tell what exactly your elementary particles are. They are elementary, we just have them, maybe light is not one of them.
I would also like to be clear that I am not criticizing anyone for making insufficient progress; it is just that there is a lot out there left for us to understand, and not all of it is marginal stuff that's "very big or very small".
Finding the true nature and, whether it exists or not, is the domain of philosophy.
Science builds models. And we do have at this point extremely good models of electromagnetism which can correctly predict results of all experiments done so far.
Whether these models reveal some fundamental truth or not is a matter of opinion (or perhaps religion). It has nothing to do with refining the models or finding experiments that might prove them wrong.
I am not interested in whether these scientists reveal "some fundamental truth or not", but we cannot say that we understand all there is to know about electromagnetic phenomena because we can make a few simple predictions. It would be tantamount to saying that we understand the sun because we know where it is relative to us, and how bright it is, and can predict both of these parameters for a while. Understanding that it is a star, how it was formed, how it will cease to be, that it is made up of a number of elements, and converts large amounts of matter to energy are all very important discoveries, and we must continue to seek this kind of advance in the frontiers of our understanding in electromagnetic phenomena, matter, gravity, and many other areas.
So that leaves me a little bit stumped at what point you're trying to make here. Are you disagreeing with that view of science? Are you trying to say, "well, that's how it's been for hundreds of years, but at some point in the future I believe we'll all discover that physics is completely and utterly and embarrassingly wrong in every way"?
I've gone back and reread your reply to me at least half a dozen times. You seem to be disagreeing with me, but none of the examples you brought up really actually disagreed with me. At best, I chose some poor metaphors and that led you to misunderstand me, but then I still can't figure out what it is that you're actually trying to say.
This is quite an understatement. QED, which is the underlying theory of EM, is the most accurate scientific theory ever. Full stop. It's theoretical predictions match experimentally measured observables out to ten decimal places. By your standards we don't really understand any physical phenomena. To bring up your analogy with the sun: our understanding of QED is like saying that we know the exact chemical composition of the sun to an accuracy of one part in ten billion. I think we would be justified in stating that we understand the sun in those circumstances.
On a related note, QED does provide a lot of context for what "light"(photons) is(are). It's the gauge boson (read: mediating particle) of the electromagnetic force. In my mind it doesn't get much more elegant than that.
Similarly, the current model of the sun is the simplest model that explains some observations (neutrino flux, the fact that some stars seem similar spectroscopically, our knowledge from other branches of science, etc.).
I see no fundamental difference between these two.
> rapidly zeroing in on the truths of our reality
The truths? No, humans are as likely to arrive at the truths as ants an understanding of a microwave oven.
Regardless, how is it relevant whether a large group of people made a mistake (by coming up with an incorrect theory) before an invention that had no basis in existing theory was made? I do not agree with the premise of the post I responded to, as a new drive does not necessarily contravene existing theories (since we do not understand its principle of operation).
I agree that contravening an existing theory is a bit of an odd course for an inventor to take, and may make it difficult to get angel funding, but that's about the only difference I can see.
> I think the last thing anyone wants to see here is "new physics".
I really want to see new physics, because I want to see us get off this rock and far away. I think most people want to see new physics. I think that's why this topic is so popular.
That said, I can understand physicists not wanting to see new physics.
Wait. In a way, that sentence is crazy. In a way, physicists should want to see new physics more than anybody.
Where does the "not wanting to see new physics" sentiment come from? Just not wanting to be wrong?
But if you claim to violate the conversation of momentum, everyone is going to be skeptical and not believe it. We have hundreds of years of experiments and observations that support the law and have looked in many places from small to large and not seen violations. This is what makes people not believe it and thus physicists are going to assume you are wrong and not physics. It's not so much a negative concern, but more of a practical one. But should it be tested in a rigorous manner and reproduced, then physicists will believe it. It's just it hasn't and thus we are going to stick with the established very well understood and tested theory. Like are you sure you have properly counted all the initial momentum? Are you 100% you are not introducing energy to the system? The possible explanations is long and a good experiment will eliminate as many of these as possible.
As an example, look at the OPERA experiment which found to have superluminal signals. New physics? Nope, just a faulty piece of equipment. BICEP showing gravitational waves? Nope, just poor data interpretation and neglecting interstellar dust. So if you want to claim new physics, be damned sure you have ironclad proof.
If physicists don't want new physics, they should stop doing research!
I mean, wouldn't it be really frustrating to find out the law of conservation of momentum is not universal? Exciting, but also frustrating? Maybe even embarassing for physics? It would be like someone proving P=NP.
"Free Energy" is very appealing, so is "10x better batteries", "10x more flash storage", "momentum-defying space thruster", and so on. These modern-day fairy tales are gaining press simply because people want them to be true, not because they actually show a path for progress.
Similarly, a promise of a "miracle cure" is very appealing to the public, and so it may seem cynical to downplay any such claim right away, but it has absolutely nothing to do with actual advances in medicine.
Q. Does the Em drive produce thrust?
A. Undetermined. Several tests from multiple independent labs have reported thrust, including in a vacuum. However several of the labs that reported positive thrust come from a sketchy background.
Q. Does it violate conservation of momentum?
A. Undetermined. There are several competing theories trying to explain the phenomenon, but we lack raw data. I think the last thing anyone wants to see here is "new physics".
Q. Roger Shawyer seems like a scummy kook?
A. Yes. This is why more testing is really important.
Q. What about more tests?
A. A few dozen people have taken it upon themselves to hack together emDrives and test them. The first couple so far were plagued by poor construction, RF interference, and poor experimental design. However, the hacking community is slowly getting its shit together.
Q. Pluto in 18 months?
A. If it works. My intuition screams "its cold fusion all over again", but there is still a chance.