News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chisel: Constructing Hardware in a Scala Embedded Language by nickpsecurity on Sunday July 26, 2015 @01:12AM (#9950212)
That's what people said about going to 3GL's. I'm glad, for my day-to-day computing, that most went in the other direction (pro 3GL's). Software people can't get the kind of results hardware people can while using HLS techniques. That's obvious. Yet, the existing research shows they should be able to get quite a bit of results with little knowledge of hardware. EDA tools actually solved most of the hard parts. Only thing that's lacking are tools to accomplish this and at prices most people can afford.

Two paths developed in parallel. One for those trying to boost their software with hardware generation. One for hardware designers trying to improve their own craft. And with the benefit that one's tools can integrate the other. Best of both worlds.

So, I look for both.

Re:Chisel: Constructing Hardware in a Scala Embedded Language by gluggymug on Sunday July 26, 2015 @01:57AM (#9950305)
I think maybe the HLS can get you a core design but then when you try to use it and integrate into an FPGA you will have to deal with the low level issues of registers and combinatorial logic. This is fine for the experienced HW person, but not for the beginner. In other words, the HLS is better for the experienced HW designer than the beginner even though it looks like its easy.

Unfortunately there is no infrastructure for you to build onto. It's like a blank slate. All the I/O needs to be done right. It's very seldom just instantiating wires unless your design is blazingly simple. And if it were simple you wouldn't need an FPGA in the first place. A generic coprocessor would kick most FPGAs butts.

Re:Chisel: Constructing Hardware in a Scala Embedded Language by nickpsecurity on Sunday July 26, 2015 @10:38AM (#9951152)
Ok that all makes more sense. One of my potential flows was actually having the amateurs build lost of functionality (eg accelerators, device protocols) with HLS tools that a hardware engineer could finalize for FPGA. Would save on the rare labor. What do you think of that model vs exclusively leveraging HW people?

Far as ASIC's, I'd just get HW people, haggle on the tools, use free one's if possible (see Qflow), and do a MPW run for prototyping/production. eASIC's 90nm maskless stuff, potentially. Start it on 180nm-350nm, though, as there's lots of cheap masks and fab capacity there.

Re:Chisel: Constructing Hardware in a Scala Embedded Language by gluggymug on Sunday July 26, 2015 @11:33AM (#9951311)
What do you think of that model vs exclusively leveraging HW people?

Sounds good.

Cheap fab I am not sure whether the costs make sense. Depends on the project I guess. I don't have a lot of experience with those manufacturing processes.

Re:Chisel: Constructing Hardware in a Scala Embedded Language by minthd on Sunday July 26, 2015 @01:59AM (#9950311)
Still , Cx - lang is having a real hard time to find customers. So what's missing ?
Re:Chisel: Constructing Hardware in a Scala Embedded Language by nickpsecurity on Sunday July 26, 2015 @10:47AM (#9951173)
That's part of what I'm trying to find out. To be fair, most open-source, high-level synthesis tools don't have a lot of customers. Even Chisel doesn't have near as many users as its successes deserve. That's common for ASIC or FPGA tools that aren't the big name.

For now, my preliminary answer is that people: (a) just use Altera and Xilinx HLS tools for FPGA because they're cheap and work well with their products; (b) use HLS tools from big three EDA companies on ASIC design; (c) straight up do HDL (majority probably) for ASIC as experienced HW engineers are used to doing anyway and use good RTL synthesis. Against the competition, there's no comparison of free/open synthesis tools except in price and subversion risk. Those are my reasons for investigating them, though, so I continue to get feedback on what I find.

Note: Not sure of your HW expertise. If you're not a HW person, I'll note that anything synthesized for ASIC's needs to have a rock-solid method because mistakes are expensive. Even older processes still cost hundreds of thousands for the masks that print an instance of a design. Production engineers are hesitant to use unproven technology when $$$ are on the line.

Re:Chisel: Constructing Hardware in a Scala Embedded Language by MootWoop on Sunday July 26, 2015 @11:26AM (#9951293)
Matthieu, co-founder of Synflow here. Maybe I could help? Don't hesitate to send me an email!
Re:Chisel: Constructing Hardware in a Scala Embedded Language by nickpsecurity on Sunday July 26, 2015 @10:33PM (#9953070)
I probably will soon since you took the time to show up. :) I think what I'll do is form a list of questions to assess the nature and capabilities of your method. These will represent what a lot of different kinds of people would ask. Then, your answers might get packaged up in FAQ's, blog posts, whatever that clarify things for more people than just me. How's that sound?
Re:Chisel: Constructing Hardware in a Scala Embedded Language by MootWoop on Monday July 27, 2015 @04:47AM (#9954083)
Sounds great! I'll do my best to answer all questions :-) My email is [email protected]