Like a situation of economic freedom where millions of individual actors and entrepreneurs can dynamically change the landscape of city transportation instead of imposing a one size fits all scheme?
Medallions don't come close to solving the issue of people free-riding on roads - most of the cars on NYC roads are neither taxis nor ubers.
http://www.citylab.com/commute/2015/05/debunking-the-myth-th...
Why? You can't build a close competitor to 9th Avenue (making up a street name) because A) there are buildings in the way beside it and B) building above it is prohibitively expensive. If these are one-way streets as is common in urban areas 9th Avenue's closest competitors are 11th and 7th and after that competition falls off quickly. Five competitors doesn't make a healthy market - it makes an oligopoly.
The goal is to limit the number of cabs on the road without creating unreasonable barriers to other economic activity using the roadways. This can be done without Medallions, though. Cities could just require a license for taxis, like they do for many other businesses. If that license cheap enough that anyone can afford it (perhaps with a small business loan) but expensive enough to slightly deter entry, then it solves the commons problem without leading to cronyism.
Your argument is like saying that common grazing land is okay because there's a natural limit to how many cows can be on it; the number of cows that can fit, or that can be watched by the available farmers, or any other limit that doesn't take into account how many cows the field can actually handle.
A daily "vehicle fee" to have a vehicle within the city might solve your problem.
https://tfl.gov.uk/modes/driving/congestion-charge
Although, as a matter of policy, ultra-low emission vehicles like electric cars didn't have to pay it.
Of course, it's important that fees apply to all vehicles. When London implemented a congestion charge, taxis were exempt. It wasn't long before people noticed that minicab registration cost much less than a year of congestion charges. The loophole has been fixed, but it's still an amusing example of incentives.
And that analysis understates the subsidy. In fact it would be far more expensive for private organizations to build those roads due to the need to negotiate with individual landowners. I.e. drivers don't pay for the benefit of the government exercising eminent domain to build roads.
Of course, singling out Uber and taxis for special regulation is a nonsensical solution to this issue; the main beneficiaries are people driving their own car.
Safety regulations do not require a medallion system. Artificially limiting the number of jobs for this industry is not necessary to impose safety regulations. Its only unique purpose is to restrict competition and grant a few drivers a monopoly at the expense of consumers and all other would-be drivers.
I don't see anyone arguing that the number of software developers needs to be arbitrarily capped to prevent software bugs. That makes about as much sense as taxi monopolies.
Though, now that you mention it...
This theory that greedy property owners stifled medallion creation is certainly appealing but it doesn't seem supported by the facts at hand.
That seems like a wage that shouldn't be compared to just minimum wage, given that in many places (I don't know about new York) minimum wage is below what you'd consider a living wage that covers necessary expenses.
Population growth alone would require another 600 medallions. But remember: in the 1930s, we were just coming out (or on the upswing) of the Great Recession; so affluence would dictate a much larger number. So why is the number so low?
> Instead, arcane aspects of state and local law and, crucially, the power wielded by wealthy and politically generous fleet owners — who don’t want to see the creation of more medallions lest the value of theirs decline — make that [more medallions] virtually impossible.
There you have it. It is, for the lack of a better word, greed. When you have hedgefunds owning medallions[1], you know it's a bad sign. Essential services for the general populace should not be a vehicle for hedge funds.
An ideal (or, a better) system would be responsive. It would look at how busy cabs are, and accordingly change the number of medallions in circulation. Every year (or every nth year, take your pick), have a Dutch auction[2] of the desired number of medallions. Disallow renting of medallions (only the owner gets to drive the cab), which will kill speculation. Put an app around the whole system, so users can hail cabs from their mobile devices. Pain eased.
[1] http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB100014240527023036530045792143...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dutch_auction