In hindsight, it's obvious to everyone that Valasek and Miller went too far.
It's not encouraging them to double down and do more live traffic tests, it's encouraging other people to calibrate their reactions a little bit, so as to not lose sight of the very real benefit that came out of the research.
> It's not encouraging them to double down and do more live traffic tests, it's encouraging other people to calibrate their reactions a little bit, so as to not lose sight of the very real benefit that came out of the research.
Sure, I think it's extremely important research. I think it's great they did it. But I think the outcry is important too, so as to not lose sight of the very real benefit that comes out of keeping public safety in mind when performing experiments. It sucks that these guys have to be a poster child for this, when a slap on the wrist would suffice, but I think it's important that both sides of the issue aren't discounted because of the other side.
> In college, I owned a poorly maintained VW bug that would occasionally lose power on the freeway, such as from an electrical connection falling off from vibration. I caused more risk by not maintaining my car than these security researchers did.
If while in college and driving this vehicle you decided to film yourself, made it clear your were pretty certain the car was going to lose power, got onto a freeway, and when the car lost power said something to the effect of "oh shit, this is dangerous", then yes, you would be facing a lot of criticism right now too.
If you were a researcher and had a few more years than college age under your belt, and if the point was also to raise awareness about something dangerous, you should expect criticism doubly so, because more is expected from you than some yokel on youtube trying to make a funny video.
Driving a car is an inherently dangerous activity. We've become complacent about it, but there's still many deaths each year (~1.4 of each 100 deaths was car related in 2013)[1]. For most people, it's the most dangerous thing they'll do each day. Driving requires a level of cognitive dissonance about how likely other drivers are to be paying attention, and driving with good intentions. When this is broken, though obviously dangerous driving on the road (such as the speeder doing dangerous lane changes) or introducing unnecessary risks, our reaction is to punish. Police stop dangerous drivers when they see them. These researchers broadcasted equivalent behavior, they are getting an equivalent response (albeit from the public).
1: http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr64/nvsr64_02.pdf