Re:Infosec's inability to quantify risk
by kbenson on Saturday July 25, 2015 @12:32PM
(#9948078)
I took it as half apologetic, but really, for that I was addressing what I saw in general from arguments from apologetics on this issue, not specifically this reaction.
> It's not encouraging them to double down and do more live traffic tests, it's encouraging other people to calibrate their reactions a little bit, so as to not lose sight of the very real benefit that came out of the research.
Sure, I think it's extremely important research. I think it's great they did it. But I think the outcry is important too, so as to not lose sight of the very real benefit that comes out of keeping public safety in mind when performing experiments. It sucks that these guys have to be a poster child for this, when a slap on the wrist would suffice, but I think it's important that both sides of the issue aren't discounted because of the other side.
> It's not encouraging them to double down and do more live traffic tests, it's encouraging other people to calibrate their reactions a little bit, so as to not lose sight of the very real benefit that came out of the research.
Sure, I think it's extremely important research. I think it's great they did it. But I think the outcry is important too, so as to not lose sight of the very real benefit that comes out of keeping public safety in mind when performing experiments. It sucks that these guys have to be a poster child for this, when a slap on the wrist would suffice, but I think it's important that both sides of the issue aren't discounted because of the other side.